The Best Restaurants in Key West, According to our Tastemakers

In Key West, Florida the turquoise Caribbean sea, unrivaled access to fresh fish and multi-colored sunsets draw some of the best chefs in the world. Eaters can take their pick, whether an Italian eatery or classic steakhouse. Local ingredients like sweet pink shrimp, plump lobster, and iconic key limes appear on menus across the island. But where do the savviest, most experienced foodies consider the best restaurants in Key West? This is our Tastemaker List. We gathered data covering thousands of restaurants to find the top choices according to our smartest diners. Lucky Key West locals and visitors looking to book a table need to check out these remarkable restaurants.