Shelter Island (San Diego) Restaurants

Amazing!!! We ordered the fish, pork chop and lasagna for the table + appetizers - Brussel sprouts, meatballs and grilled shrimp on toasted bread. Cocktails didn’t disappoint. Best gin martini. Spectacular view and service. Thank you for a beautiful night!

We had a wonderful dining experience at Cesarina. We were seated promptly (arriving right on our reservation time). The service was efficient and our server was very familiar with the menu, and frank and open with his descriptions/comments about various menu items. The food was served surprisingly promptly, and everything our party of 3 had was delicious. The pasta was exceptional. Everyone we interacted with acknowledged my wife's birthday (which was the occasion we were celebrating). The atmosphere is comfortable and not too noisy (of overly loud). We had a wonderful evening and everyone at Cesarina should be commended for the fine job/product they provide.

The dishes have amazing flavor! However, speak with your server if you’re particularly sensitive to spicy dishes. All the servers were lovely. And of course, this is probably the best night time view in town!

we had the most magical experience at sea level restaurant on Harbor Island in San Diego. What a beautiful day it must’ve been 80° with a clear sky overlooking the San Diego skyline. We were so fortunate to have my favorite waitress, Bernadette she has the best smile and the best attitude of any server, waitress waiter I know in all of San Diego county. And having gone there so many times in the past 10 or 12 years, we got to know the best assistant to server, his name was Jimmy attention to detail is unbelievable and he’s so pleasant and he recognizes us every time we come there we had a great experience and the food was incredible and I don’t want to say this out loud but my wife and I split the fish and chips and for an extra three dollars you get four pieces of fish instead of three love this place you can’t do better than an afternoon outside at C level.

The seafood platter had a considerable spread of shellfish. Every bite was delightfully fresh with complimentary savory garnishes. The Caesar salad was a nice opening to our platter with slices of anchovies perfectly placed. Our group very much enjoyed the warming taste of the creamiest lobster bisque before sharing the steak and vegetables.