Best American Restaurants in St. Michaels

Knoxie's Table at The Inn at the Chesapeake Bay Beach ClubKnoxie's Table at The Inn at the Chesapeake Bay Beach Club
(276)
$$$$
American | Stevensville, Eastern Shore
Hunters' Tavern at the Tidewater InnHunters' Tavern at the Tidewater Inn
(178)
$$$$
American | Easton, Eastern Shore
The Robert Morris InnThe Robert Morris Inn
(161)
$$$$
American | Oxford, Eastern Shore
CharlestonCharleston
(3255)
$$$$
American | Harbor East, Baltimore
The Prime Rib - Baltimore (The Original)The Prime Rib - Baltimore (The Original)
(3420)
$$$$
American | Downtown, Baltimore
MagdalenaMagdalena
(349)
$$$$
American | Mt. Vernon, Baltimore
The Food MarketThe Food Market
(2745)
$$$$
American | Hampden, Baltimore
SoBo CafeSoBo Cafe
(495)
$$$$
American | Federal Hill, Baltimore
EdenEden
(1118)
$$$$
American | Rehoboth Beach, Ocean City / Delaware Shore
Lib's Grill - Perry HallLib's Grill - Perry Hall
(640)
$$$$
American | Perry Hall, Baltimore Suburbs
Paul's Homewood CafePaul's Homewood Cafe
(556)
$$$$
American | Annapolis, Greater Annapolis
Cask & Grain KitchenCask & Grain Kitchen
(171)
$$$$
American | Canton, Baltimore
Woodberry KitchenWoodberry Kitchen
(10269)
$$$$
American | Downtown, Baltimore
Gunther & Co.Gunther & Co.
(794)
$$$$
American | Canton, Baltimore
Blue Hill TavernBlue Hill Tavern
(2569)
$$$$
American | Canton, Baltimore
Level Small Plates LoungeLevel Small Plates Lounge
(1382)
$$$$
American | Annapolis, Greater Annapolis

Best Italian Restaurants in St. Michaels

ScossaScossa
(731)
$$$$
Italian | Easton, Eastern Shore
Rustico Restaurant & Wine BarRustico Restaurant & Wine Bar
(396)
$$$$
Italian | Stevensville, Eastern Shore
Hersh'sHersh's
(556)
$$$$
Italian | Federal Hill, Baltimore
Arturo's TrattoriaArturo's Trattoria
(441)
$$$$
Italian | Glen Burnie, Baltimore
La ScalaLa Scala
(2380)
$$$$
Italian | Little Italy, Baltimore
Sotto SopraSotto Sopra
(1900)
$$$$
Italian | Mt. Vernon, Baltimore
LIBERATORE’S Ristorante & Catering - EldersburgLIBERATORE’S Ristorante & Catering - Eldersburg
(333)
$$$$
Italian | Eldersburg, Baltimore Suburbs
CinghialeCinghiale
(1596)
$$$$
Italian | Harbor East, Baltimore
Osteria 177Osteria 177
(1449)
$$$$
Italian | Annapolis, Greater Annapolis
Da Mimmo Finest Italian CuisineDa Mimmo Finest Italian Cuisine
(811)
$$$$
Italian | Little Italy, Baltimore
Tino's Italian BistroTino's Italian Bistro
(591)
$$$$
Italian | Columbia, Baltimore Suburbs
Carpaccio Tuscan KitchenCarpaccio Tuscan Kitchen
(1164)
$$$$
Italian | Annapolis, Greater Annapolis
CosimaCosima
(928)
$$$$
Italian | Hampden, Baltimore
Birroteca - BaltimoreBirroteca - Baltimore
(1645)
$$$$
Italian | Hampden, Baltimore
LIBERATORE’S Ristorante & Catering – WestminsterLIBERATORE’S Ristorante & Catering – Westminster
(166)
$$$$
Italian | Westminster, Baltimore Suburbs

Popular restaurants in Baltimore

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in Baltimore

Points South Latin Kitchen
(60)
$$$$
Latin American | Fells Point
Mezze
(71)
$$$$
Tapas / Small Plates | Fells Point
Tagliata Restaurant
(319)
$$$$
Italian | Harbor East
View all Baltimore restaurants
St Michaels / Tilghman Island Locals Are Talking About
What’s iconic about St Michaels / Tilghman Island?
Natural beauty and small town charm.
C
Cyoung5555 - Washington DC
What do locals love about St Michaels / Tilghman Island?
Friendly, small community, feel but with artistic compliments
P
Percie - Baltimore
What do you love most about St Michaels / Tilghman Island?
Watching sunrise and/or sunset over the water.
OT
OpenTable Diner - Philadelphia

Treat your taste buds: Explore St. Michaels restaurants.

St. Michaels Restaurants

Theo's Steak, Sides & SpiritsTheo's Steak, Sides & Spirits
591 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | St Michaels / Tilghman Island, Eastern Shore

Excellent, great food, wine, ambience, and knowledgeable and friendly staff. Love this restaurant More

OpenTable Diner -
Bistro St MichaelsBistro St Michaels
566 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary French | St Michaels / Tilghman Island, Eastern Shore

Gary, our waiter, was great! Very attentive and detail oriented. More

OpenTable Diner -
t at The General Storet at The General Store
243 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | St Michaels / Tilghman Island, Eastern Shore

My husband and I had a wonderful date night dinner experience here. We drove in horrible weather and were relieved to find this out of the way gem. The menu is pared down to a few choices. Sadly, they weren’t offering the Chai Tea Rubbed Roasted Chicken on the menu and only one seafood option existed. I chose the blackened scallops. They just melted in my mouth. It was served with a generous portion of brussels sprouts, and a sweet potato puree and was so fresh and delicious. My husband had a tasty mushroom ravioli and we shared a kale salad with pomegranates. Our Pinot Grigio and Rose wines by the glass were both lovely. Service was good and the background music was lovely jazz. The atmosphere is very contemporary with a rustic, industrial blend that is so in style right now. I look forward to returning in better weather and also trying brunch. More

OpenTable Diner -
StarsStars
774 reviews
$$$$
Farm-to-table | St Michaels / Tilghman Island, Eastern Shore

It had been raining most of the day when we arrived at 6:30. The parking lot was poorly lighted and had fairly deep puddles we had to walk through to get to the awning-covered doorway. We would like the disabled parking signs to be more prominently displayed. Otherwise, as indicated above, the service, food and ambiance at Stars is excellent. More

OpenTable Diner -

Discover Tilghman Island

St. Michaels and Tilghman Island feature a variety of attractive dining choices in the Baltimore area. French cuisine is popular in St. Michaels alongside classic American food and good, old-fashioned deli sandwiches. Anyone looking for a large, delicious and inexpensive club sandwich has come to the right place! If you're looking for an authentic Maryland food experience, make time to try out some of this area's incredible seafood dishes like crab Imperial and crab soup. No area in the world catches as many crabs as the state of Maryland, and both St. Michaels and Tilghman Island have plenty of restaurants that make the most of this local delicacy.