We loved the food and service was great. The filet was done to perfection! My husband had the snapper and it was great. We were seated upstairs. It was quiet but we didn’t like how closed in we felt on a beautiful night! Shades down and dark walls. Might have been nice on a winter night. We prefer the room downstairs.

We were dining here on our first night in St Michaels.. The steaks were very good. we felt rushed during the meal and did not have a relaxing time and good reflections about this restaurant. We were in and out in under an hour and felt that we were taking someone else's table. They were busy and we felt their business.
Your options for steaks were 8 ounces of filet or 16 ounces of Strip or Rib eye. Thats not a large
variety in sizes.

Excellent meal! We waited a bit for our table (45 minutes) but the manager sent over salads as a consolation (much appreciated!) The crab cakes were full of meat and very little filler and the steaks at the table were cooked perfectly.

Crabcake was devine. French Onion soup had a wonderful flavor. Wedge salad was not your traditional blue cheese dressing but friends said it was one of the best they had.

Theo's had a great atmosphere. Sometimes when you have such a high quality menu you lose the comfortable atmosphere. Not the case. Amazing food. Great decor. Great service.

Great and attentive service,,,a little slow on taking orders and refilling, but it was ok. Food was outstanding and lively atmoshere, but not too loud.

Not bad. Nice bar.

Fantastic restaurant. Great food and even better service!

Consistently the best.

Why go elsewhere?! ................................................................................

St. Michaels best!

One of the better steaks I’ve had in the last 6 months. Incredible value and the wine list isn’t bad

Good food, good service. Reading the mixed reviews I want sure if we would get good or bad. Our food was great and service food too.

We ate here on a Saturday evening as a group of 6. We arrived a little early and did have to wait to be seated but we were offered drinks at the bar while we waited. The food was delicious and the service was good. It's at the higher end of my price range but we left feeling full and with leftovers. We were celebrating a special occasion and the couple at the table next to us was there for their anniversary so the ambiance was very nice.

Very nice dining atmosphere
Filet delicious
Tasty side dishes
Good coffee

We had a great meal here. I had the shrimp tempura and fish and chips. My husband had a salad and the ahi tuna. The wine list was nice and we were both satisfied with our selections.

Wait staff and kitchen were very accommodating with our special requests.

Service was outstanding!! Food was very delicious, but on the pricey side.

thoroughly enjoyed an excellent meal with superb service.

My husband and I had an excellent dinner. I ordered the filet mignon, he ordered the NY strip steak. We both ordered our steaks with the fresh chimichurri sauce. Our steaks were as tender as butter - melted in our mouths. For side vegetables we had the trio of mushrooms and sauteed fresh spinach. Both very good. Both steaks came with mashed potatoes. There was also artisan bread for the table. Great wine and beer list. For dessert we shared the Boston Cream Cake. The staff were very professional. A really great, quiet and romantic dinner.

Sadly, we used to love Theo's. As usual, we ordered the signature Chateaubriand For Two. The beef was nearly tasteless and served with a gelatinous sauce, the vegetables dry and uncompelling. Our server was strangely distracted, considering that we were his only table. The bar seemed busy and perhaps that is the new emphasis. Given the cost of the meal, I think Theo's is off the list.

I liked the place overall . The steak wasn't up to par with ruthchris but the oysters where good just like Ava's pizza

Excellent, great food, wine, ambience, and knowledgeable and friendly staff. Love this restaurant

I had shrimp and grits and it was outstanding! It's been on my list of entrees to try and I was not dissapointed. My boyfriend had steak and baked potato and the steak was pricy but good flavor. Baked potato was cold. The service was slow and not very good. I asked for a straw I never received. The fella was slow getting to us to start prob 10 minutes and he continued the same theme at the tables around us as well. For the price of the meals your service should match the quality of your food. Serving is not for everyone but it makes for an amazing experience when the food and service match. Everyone else was friendly and thanked us for coming on the way out. I wasn't completely turned off but would ask for a different server if he is there again.

The Theo’s Salad and bread basket were amazing. The sirloin steak, mashed potatoes and mushrooms were excellent. Service was great and the offer of a drink while we waited a few minutes for our table was appreciated.

Food was delicious. French onion soup was absolutely delicious. The hostess that met us at the door was and is always so helpful (Im sorry I don’t remember her name). Service is always excellent. The bartender Jen was great and even remembered us from our last visit! Also our waitress Laura was excellent. Very attentive to our table of 6. We shall request her next time we dine there!

Theo’s is a very special place for us, with many wonderful memories; this time, we were there with dear friends to celebrate my boyfriend’s birthday, and the restaurant did not disappoint. From the cocktails to dessert, every single part of dinner was perfect. Our server was gracious and attentive. And the meal- steaks expertly prepared, perfectly cooked and seasoned, sides were delicious, and dessert was yummy. In short, another perfect Theo’s meal. Thank you so much!

It was our first time at Theo's. We are from South Jersey and frequently stay at our daughter's family summer place in Cambridge. LOVED Theo's and definitely plan to return....great food and atmosphere

Always enjoyable v

The server suggested the Chateaubriand for Two, which was an excellent choice. We were celebrating a birthday, which was annotated in our reservation. Although the restaurant did comp the desert we chose, which was very nice, there was no other mention of the celebration. At every other nice restaurant we have been to, a birthday celebration usually garners a slightly more special desert or attention given. The piece of cake we ordered for desert was delivered on a simple white plate. It looked like a COSTCO cake had been thrown on a random plate and brought out. We also had to ask throughout the night for refills of water. Overall good, but definitely not great.

Theos simply has the best staff and steaks around!

They ran out of Oysters, Espresso, and Tea. The waiter was great at the beginning but disappeared towards the end of the meal which coincided with the end of the football game. Steak was amazing though and I would come back.

We went to Theos for my Boyfriends birthday. Very nice place, great staff, food was excellent. The only down side was that it was more expensive than a restaurant I would usually choose to dine in; but for a romantic ,special occasion dinner Theos is perfect..

I went to Theo's on 1/10/18 with a group of girlfriends, and had a wonderful time! Audrey, greeted each of us at the door, and as always was just as sweet as could be, and our waiter, Curtis was fabulous! Jenn our bar tender stopped at our table to say hello, as well as owner Chis! What a great group of people!!!

All the ladies had a fabulous night, ate great food and are looking forward to another fun evening at Theo's very soon!

Thanks to everyone for making our night so memorable!

Lori

Great as usual!

Theo’s is a great place for dinner in St Michael’s MD...they have a long time staff that does an excellent job...Been going to Theo’s for a number of years...good food, good value and a fun place to go to. Highly recommend...

Theo's was amazing as always. We have never had anything but superb food and drinks there. Highly recommend!

This was my second time in a month.. Love it..My husband said it was one of the best filets he has ever had... and he is very picky..

Never disappoints! Burgers were amazing. My kids love the shrimp tempura and the tuna tartar.

Spot on Theo’s. Attentively seamless service is the underpinning of a fine meal. Layer in professional purveying, a thoughtful menu with side paths, a chef crew that knows exactly- and I mean exactly- wha they are doing with the food and you get an exceptional restaurant experience.

But you also leave thinking this is not a fluke. The confluence of skills and staff make for a replicable experience.

Veronica the server was a model of table tending, a standard by which others should be judged.

Also- the best beef I have ever eaten. (See my comment on procurement and chef skills.)

Theo’s is a very, very good restaurant.

Neighborhood tavern in St. Michaels. We sat in the bar area which had limited seating but we liked it very much. Food and service was great. Dining rooms looked trendy and quite full of diners! Reservations are a good idea.

Great st Michaels restaurant ! The steaks and ambiance are great, and the service is friendly and helfpul. 5/5 would recommend