Best Seasonal Restaurants in St Michaels / Tilghman Island

We love Theo’s! We’ve been quite a few times and always have a wonderful experience

Everything was amazing!! From the appetizer to dessert!!

A hidden gem amongst St Michael's vibrant eating scene. Perfect rare tuna loin appetizer which was large enough to share. Both of our entrees were great, fish and chips for my wife and a huge perfectly cooked NY strip done au poivre style with the best sauce I've ever had. It's a small, nondescript storefront with not a lot of advertising, so it's easy to miss. Give them a try, their food is some of the best we've had in St Michaels.

Fun concept and a great place to meet friends for either just a glass of wine or an entire meal. Service was great - staff was friendly and attentive.

Unexpected gem in the country. I enjoy good pork chops, and the Iberico pork rack was perhaps the best I have ever had. I usually favor savory over sweet, but the blueberry drizzle was outstanding.