The Best Restaurants in Florida Keys, According to our Tastemakers

The OpenTable Team

The best restaurants in the Florida Keys deliver on several compelling fronts. Expansive flavor profiles range from Caribbean-influenced and classic Italian to Asian-fusion. The top eateries across this tropical island chain boast ample seaside venues situated in beachfront cottages, historic mansions, and open-air dock-side terraces. What do the most acclaimed chefs in the Keys have in common? A mastery of fresh local fish and seafood that includes Key West pink shrimp, Florida lobster, and yellowtail snapper. But where do the smartest, most experienced eaters go for an amazing meal in the Florida Keys? Welcome to our Tastemaker List. We pulled data covering thousands of area restaurants to find the best of them all according to OpenTable's savviest users. Together, these restaurants offer every element that makes the Florida Keys so special – sunshine, stunning scenery and delicious cuisine, plus everyone's favorite cool beverages, of course. Anyone heading to the Keys or lucky enough to live there should book a table at one or more today.

Restaurants:Nine One Five, La Trattoria Oceanside, Bistro 245
Price Range:$$ - $$$
Cuisines:Contemporary American, Italian
Neighborhoods:Key West
For 2 people today
Party Size
For 2
Date
Today
Time
7:00 PM

Nine One Five

$$$$·Contemporary American·
Key West
2,288 reviews
  • Great for Outdoor Dining
  • Good for a Date
  • Romantic
A sophisticated eatery inside a Victorian home on Key West’s famous Duval Street, Nine One Five presents a refined take on new American cuisine with global influences. It’s one of Read more
96% recommended
Fit for Foodies in Key West / Florida Keys
There aren’t any available tables for 2 today at 7:00 pm
View Availability

La Trattoria Oceanside

$$$$·Italian·
Key West
1,069 reviews
  • Good for a Date
  • Romantic
  • Special Occasion
La Trattoria Oceanside opened in 2011, a testament to the enduring popularity of the original La Trattoria in Old Town, which dates to 1983. Just like its sister restaurant, the OcRead more
93% recommended
Best Overall in Key West / Florida Keys
There aren’t any available tables for 2 today at 7:00 pm
View Availability

Bistro 245

$$$$·Contemporary American·
Key West
617 reviews
  • Waterfront
  • Scenic View
  • Good for a Date
One of the best restaurants in the Florida Keys for upscale fine dining on the waterfront is Bistro 245. The restaurant sits adjacent to the harbor inside Key West’s MargaritavilleRead more
86% recommended
Hot Spot in Key West / Florida Keys
There aren’t any available tables for 2 today at 7:00 pm
View Availability

Pierre's Restaurant & Lounge

$$$$·Contemporary American·
Islamorada
406 reviews
  • Romantic
  • Scenic View
  • Waterfront
An antique-filled two-story plantation on the waterfront of Islamadora houses one of the best restaurants in the Florida Keys – Pierre’s Restaurant and Lounge. Dinner at Pierre’s iRead more
87% recommended
Best Service in Key West / Florida Keys
There aren’t any available tables for 2 today at 7:00 pm
View Availability

Azur

$$$$·Mediterranean·
Key West
1,368 reviews
  • Good for a Date
  • Neighborhood Gem
  • Great for Outdoor Dining
Mediterranean-inspired cuisine showcasing top-quality local ingredients is the signature of Azur in the heart of Old Town Key West. The restaurant presents brunch and dinner in itsRead more
96% recommended
Best Overall in Key West / Florida Keys
There aren’t any available tables for 2 today at 7:00 pm
View Availability

Cafe Marquesa

$$$$·Contemporary American·
Key West
1,119 reviews
  • Special Occasion
  • Fit for Foodies
  • Good for Anniversaries
Café Marquesa sits inside the Marquesa Hotel, an Old Town Key West icon comprising a set of 19th-century conch houses restored to their former glory. Fitting with such an exceptionRead more
98% recommended
Best Overall in Key West / Florida Keys
There aren’t any available tables for 2 today at 7:00 pm
View Availability

Antonia's

$$$$·Italian·
Key West
1,098 reviews
  • Good for a Date
  • Special Occasion
  • Romantic
As a Key West locals’ favorite for more than 30 years, Antonia’s is undoubtedly one of the best restaurants in the Florida Keys. Its home-style, from-scratch Italian cuisine, offerRead more
94% recommended
Best Value in Key West / Florida Keys
There aren’t any available tables for 2 today at 7:00 pm
View Availability

Little Pearl

$$$$·Seafood·
Key West
1,278 reviews
  • Fit for Foodies
  • Neighborhood Gem
  • Creative Cuisine
With chic nautical décor to complement its seafood-centric menu, Little Pearl is a delightful little restaurant in Key West. It’s of the best restaurants in the Florida Keys to dinRead more
94% recommended
Best Overall in Key West / Florida Keys
There aren’t any available tables for 2 today at 7:00 pm
View Availability

Seven Fish

$$$$·Seafood·
Key West
1,137 reviews
  • Special Occasion
  • Good for a Date
  • Fit for Foodies
In a striking venue with floor-to-ceiling windows in Key West, Seven Fish offers excellent local seafood dishes, often with exotic tropical flavors. Standout items on the dinner meRead more
94% recommended
Best Overall in Key West / Florida Keys
There aren’t any available tables for 2 today at 7:00 pm
View Availability

Tavern N' Town - Marriott Key West

$$$$·American·
Key West
1,383 reviews
  • Happy Hour
  • Good for Anniversaries
  • Good for a Date
Tavern N’ Town, the signature restaurant of the Marriott Key West hotel, specializes in shareable cuisine. Its dinner menu features tapas, salads, soups, rustic pizzas, entrees froRead more
93% recommended
Best Overall in Key West / Florida Keys
There aren’t any available tables for 2 today at 7:00 pm
View Availability

Angler & Ale at Hawks Cay

$$$$·Caribbean·
Duck Key
279 reviews
  • Kid-friendly
  • Great for Outdoor Dining
  • Waterfront
Sunny, dockside seating and a cheerful, nautical-themed dining room complement the friendly atmosphere at Angler and Ale, an upscale-casual lunch and dinner spot at Hawks Cay ResorRead more
81% recommended
There aren’t any available tables for 2 today at 7:00 pm
View Availability

DiGiorgio's Cafe Largo

$$$$·Italian·
Key Largo
473 reviews
  • Comfort Food
  • Neighborhood Gem
  • Casual
A feature on Food Network’s “Diners, Drive-In and Dives” brought national attention to DiGiorgio’s Café Largo, but locals already regarded the family-run Italian-American eatery onRead more
Neighborhood Gem in Key West / Florida Keys
There aren’t any available tables for 2 today at 7:00 pm
View Availability

Castaway Waterfront Restaurant & Sushi Bar

$$$$·Seafood·
Marathon
180 reviews
  • Waterfront
  • Casual
  • Local Ingredients
A Marathon institution, Castaway Waterfront Restaurant and Sushi Bar dates to 1951. From its early days the eatery stuck with a simple, winning concept of offering cold drinks and Read more
Fit for Foodies in Key West / Florida Keys
There aren’t any available tables for 2 today at 7:00 pm
View Availability

A&B Lobster House

$$$$·Seafood·
Key West
2,100 reviews
  • Special Occasion
  • Scenic View
  • Great for Outdoor Dining
A&B Lobster House, a Key West icon since 1947, is one of the longest-running and certainly one of the best restaurants in the Florida Keys. Its waterfront setting, with views over Read more
88% recommended
Best Service in Key West / Florida Keys
There aren’t any available tables for 2 today at 7:00 pm
View Availability

The Stoned Crab

$$$$·Seafood·
Key West
125 reviews
  • Casual
  • Waterfront
  • Fun
When it comes to sustainable, all-local seafood, Key West gem The Stoned Crab is one of the best restaurants in the Florida Keys. The restaurant’s sustainable seafood program incluRead more
There aren’t any available tables for 2 today at 7:00 pm
View Availability

Bagatelle

$$$$·Seafood·
Key West
1,360 reviews
  • Great for Outdoor Dining
  • Good for a Date
  • Romantic
A 19th-century, two-story house on Duval Street in Key West is home to Bagatelle, an approachable fine-dining restaurant specializing in southern and Caribbean flavors. Its wine liRead more
81% recommended
Hot Spot in Key West / Florida Keys
There aren’t any available tables for 2 today at 7:00 pm
View Availability

Southernmost Beach Cafe

$$$$·Caribbean·
Key West
805 reviews
  • Waterfront
  • Great for Outdoor Dining
  • Scenic View
With a “boat to table” concept, ocean views and chef Matt Slattery’s tempting cuisine, Southernmost Beach Café draws an appreciative crowd of locals and tourists alike. Seafood-cenRead more
95% recommended
Scenic View in Key West / Florida Keys
There aren’t any available tables for 2 today at 7:00 pm
View Availability

Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar at The Perry Hotel

$$$$·Seafood·
Key West
338 reviews
  • Waterfront
  • Great for Outdoor Dining
  • Scenic View
There’s live music every night at Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen and Bar, an inviting venue inside Stock Island’s upscale Perry Hotel. The restaurant is open all day, seven days a weeRead more
92% recommended
Not available on OpenTable
View More Info

Sarabeth's

$$$$·American·
Key West
761 reviews
  • Great for Outdoor Dining
  • Neighborhood Gem
  • Fit for Foodies
Sarabeth’s is open for breakfast, brunch, lunch and dinner on Wednesdays through Sundays. It’s a gem of Old Town Key West, housed in a 19th-century landmark with indoor and outdoorRead more
95% recommended
Not available on OpenTable
View More Info

Latitudes on Sunset Key

$$$$·Contemporary American·
Key West
9,456 reviews
  • Scenic View
  • Romantic
  • Great for Outdoor Dining
Among many accolades, Food & Wine named Latitudes on Sunset Key the most romantic restaurant in Florida. Rest assured it’s just as impressive a venue for any non-romantic occasion Read more
95% recommended
Best Overall in Key West / Florida Keys
There aren’t any available tables for 2 today at 7:00 pm
View Availability
Discover our curated lists