Best American Restaurants in St. Augustine

BellwetherBellwether
(35)
$$$$
American | Jacksonville, Jacksonville
DoroDoro
(215)
$$$$
American | Neptune Beach, Ponte Vedra Beach
Five Points TavernFive Points Tavern
(169)
$$$$
American | Jacksonville, Jacksonville
Nineteen & Traditions at TPC SawgrassNineteen & Traditions at TPC Sawgrass
(220)
$$$$
American | Ponte Vedra Beach, Ponte Vedra Beach
Seasons 52 - JacksonvilleSeasons 52 - Jacksonville
(3089)
$$$$
American | Jacksonville, Jacksonville
Sunrise Café at Omni Amelia Island Plantation ResortSunrise Café at Omni Amelia Island Plantation Resort
(112)
$$$$
American | Fernandina Beach, Amelia Island
Stonewood Grill & Tavern - JacksonvilleStonewood Grill & Tavern - Jacksonville
(828)
$$$$
American | Jacksonville, Jacksonville
Nona Blue Modern Tavern - Ponte Vedra BeachNona Blue Modern Tavern - Ponte Vedra Beach
(312)
$$$$
American | Ponte Vedra Beach, Ponte Vedra Beach
Ragtime Tavern & Seafood Grill - Atlantic BeachRagtime Tavern & Seafood Grill - Atlantic Beach
(92)
$$$$
American | Atlantic Beach, Jacksonville
3 Palms Grille3 Palms Grille
(134)
$$$$
American | Ponte Vedra Beach, Ponte Vedra Beach
The Blind Rabbit - Jax BeachThe Blind Rabbit - Jax Beach
(164)
$$$$
American | Jacksonville Beach, Jacksonville Beach
Seven Bridges - JacksonvilleSeven Bridges - Jacksonville
(114)
$$$$
American | Jacksonville, Jacksonville
The HilltopThe Hilltop
(118)
$$$$
American | Jacksonville, Jacksonville
Gigi's Restaurant at Ramada MandarinGigi's Restaurant at Ramada Mandarin
(327)
$$$$
American | Jacksonville, Jacksonville

Best Italian Restaurants in St. Augustine

Terra & AcquaTerra & Acqua
(272)
$$$$
Italian | St. Augustine, St. Augustine
Poppy's ItalianoPoppy's Italiano
(521)
$$$$
Italian | Ponte Vedra Beach, Ponte Vedra Beach
Cucina SouthCucina South
(555)
$$$$
Italian | Fernandina Beach, Amelia Island
Enza's Italian RestaurantEnza's Italian Restaurant
(1434)
$$$$
Italian | Jacksonville, Jacksonville
Four Seasons BistroFour Seasons Bistro
(335)
$$$$
Italian | Fernandina Beach, Amelia Island
Vito's Italian RestaurantVito's Italian Restaurant
(176)
$$$$
Italian | Jacksonville, Jacksonville
Maggiano's - JacksonvilleMaggiano's - Jacksonville
(3703)
$$$$
Italian | Jacksonville, Jacksonville
BRIO Tuscan Grille - Jacksonville - St. John's Town CenterBRIO Tuscan Grille - Jacksonville - St. John's Town Center
(519)
$$$$
Italian | Jacksonville, Jacksonville

Popular restaurants in Jacksonville

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in Jacksonville

Terra Gaucha Brazilian Steakhouse
(250)
$$$$
Brazilian Steakhouse | Jacksonville
III Forks - Jacksonville
(495)
$$$$
Steakhouse | Jacksonville
Gilbert's Social
(339)
$$$$
Southern | Jacksonville
Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant - Jacksonville
(471)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Jacksonville
Fogo de Chao Brazilian Steakhouse - Jacksonville
(381)
$$$$
Brazilian Steakhouse | Jacksonville
Firebirds Wood Fired Grill - Jacksonville
(111)
$$$$
American | Jacksonville
View all Jacksonville restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore St. Augustine restaurants.

St. Augustine Restaurants

Collage RestaurantCollage Restaurant
2753 reviews
$$$$
Global, International | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

Collage does absolutely everything right- Ambience, service, and exquisite food and drink. A must! More

OpenTable Diner -
Llama RestaurantLlama Restaurant
244 reviews
$$$$
Peruvian | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

Fabulous! Absolutely delicious food beautifully presented. Great service. Fun atmosphere. More

OpenTable Diner -
Preserved RestaurantPreserved Restaurant
1077 reviews
$$$$
Southern | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

Hubby and I went there for Valentine’s Day and it was fabulous!! Food was delicious and the service was excellent!! Looking forward to going back. More

OpenTable Diner -
Raintree RestaurantRaintree Restaurant
1843 reviews
$$$$
International | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

Terrific food, service & ambience. Celebrated Valentine's Day on the day after & everything was perfect. More

OpenTable Diner -
La Cocina International RestaurantLa Cocina International Restaurant
555 reviews
$$$$
International | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

Celebrated Valentines Day and a birthday. Everything about this restaurant is superb. Rack of lamb presented beautifully and prepared perfectly. If you’ve never been You are in for a treat More

OpenTable Diner -
BlackFly - St AugustineBlackFly - St Augustine
818 reviews
$$$$
Seafood | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

Wanted to dine somewhere new, found Blackfly, made our reservations. We had a really nice time there. The food was very good and so was our server, Lissette. If you’re not too full after dinner, please have a slice of their blood orange cake, delicious 😋 More

OpenTable Diner -
Michael's Tasting RoomMichael's Tasting Room
1273 reviews
$$$$
Global, International | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

The food was excellent and the service was attentive without being intrusive. Chef Michael was in the dining room several times during the evening. More

OpenTable Diner -
Old City HouseOld City House
329 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

Very good meal, great atmosphere, quiet so you can have an enjoyable conversation. More

OpenTable Diner -
St Marys Seafood & MoreSt Marys Seafood & More
28 reviews
$$$$
Seafood | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

My husband and I had our Valentine’s Day dinner with our daughter here and the food and service was outstanding. Definitely will be back More

OpenTable Diner -
Columbia Restaurant - St. AugustineColumbia Restaurant - St. Augustine
5196 reviews
$$$$
Spanish | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

Excellent dinner . Had 1605 salad, Delish, and paella delish Audray our waitress was wonderful. Would come again when we are in town. Many interesting dishes. Good service AND NO WAIT! More

OpenTable Diner -
The Reef of St. AugustineThe Reef of St. Augustine
714 reviews
$$$$
Seafood | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

Good menu selection. Delicious fresh fish cooked perfectly! Extremely friendly waiters. More

OpenTable Diner -
Terra & AcquaTerra & Acqua
272 reviews
$$$$
Italian | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

Excellent food. Pizza was very tasty and service was above average. More

OpenTable Diner -
La PentolaLa Pentola
51 reviews
$$$$
International | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

The waiter was a bit goofy. He seemed distracted and on several opportunities felt obligated to offer his opinion or comment on private conversations that took place among our friends. We were a party of 6 and asked (at the beginning of dinner) that we have three separate checks. Well, the checks were all messed up and incorrect. After three tries, he still couldn't get it right. We offered to help him straighten out the checks but he refused. That's what sometimes happens when the waiter does not write the orders down. Anyway, the food was delicious, but portions were on the small side. I've eaten there three times and twice had problems with the wait staff. I probably won't be going back as there are too may other good choices for food and service in St Augustine. More

OpenTable Diner -
A1A Ale WorksA1A Ale Works
180 reviews
$$$$
Seafood | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

Never disappointed with A1A ! Food was fast and great. Service was good and friendly. This is One of our favorites in St. Augustine 😊 More

OpenTable Diner -
Le PavillonLe Pavillon
256 reviews
$$$$
Continental | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

The food was good and the server was attentive. The filet was prepared as requested, as well as the other meals More

OpenTable Diner -
Cellar 6Cellar 6
664 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

Doug , our waiter was great! Great way to send our Anniversary. Water was awfullllll. More

OpenTable Diner -
Hurricane PattysHurricane Pattys
166 reviews
$$$$
Seafood | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

So, It was Valentine's Day and they had an awesome special, a 4- course dinner for $40. It was busy when we arrived but that didn't stop our server from being pleasent and welcoming. It did take a few extra minutes to get our mixed drinks but they were worth the wait. My hubby had the Lasagna Del Mar as a main course, which he loved because it was packed with seafood in every bite! I on the other hand had been craving a prime rib, I was instantly transported to The Flintstones. It took up almost the whole plate, was perfectly medium rare and a breeze to slide my knife through. Oh my, in my opinon it was a perfect Valentine's date the service was wonderful and so was the food. I'm looking foreward to next Valentine's day and I'm also looking foreward to going back and trying the all you can eat crab legs day! Thank you Hurricane Patty's! More

OpenTable Diner -
Costa BravaCosta Brava
1198 reviews
$$$$
Southern Spain | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

Great experience even though Very busy Valentines day. Martin the server was fantastic, and food wonderful. More

OpenTable Diner -

St. Augustine Diners' Choice Winners

St. Augustine's best restaurants based upon thousands of OpenTable diner reviews
Llama RestaurantLlama Restaurant
244 reviews
$$$$
Peruvian | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

Fabulous! Absolutely delicious food beautifully presented. Great service. Fun atmosphere. More

OpenTable Diner -
Collage RestaurantCollage Restaurant
2753 reviews
$$$$
Global, International | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

Collage does absolutely everything right- Ambience, service, and exquisite food and drink. A must! More

OpenTable Diner -
Preserved RestaurantPreserved Restaurant
1077 reviews
$$$$
Southern | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

Hubby and I went there for Valentine’s Day and it was fabulous!! Food was delicious and the service was excellent!! Looking forward to going back. More

OpenTable Diner -
La Cocina International RestaurantLa Cocina International Restaurant
555 reviews
$$$$
International | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

Celebrated Valentines Day and a birthday. Everything about this restaurant is superb. Rack of lamb presented beautifully and prepared perfectly. If you’ve never been You are in for a treat More

OpenTable Diner -
Raintree RestaurantRaintree Restaurant
1843 reviews
$$$$
International | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

Terrific food, service & ambience. Celebrated Valentine's Day on the day after & everything was perfect. More

OpenTable Diner -
BlackFly - St AugustineBlackFly - St Augustine
818 reviews
$$$$
Seafood | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

Wanted to dine somewhere new, found Blackfly, made our reservations. We had a really nice time there. The food was very good and so was our server, Lissette. If you’re not too full after dinner, please have a slice of their blood orange cake, delicious 😋 More

OpenTable Diner -
Michael's Tasting RoomMichael's Tasting Room
1273 reviews
$$$$
Global, International | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

The food was excellent and the service was attentive without being intrusive. Chef Michael was in the dining room several times during the evening. More

OpenTable Diner -
St Marys Seafood & MoreSt Marys Seafood & More
28 reviews
$$$$
Seafood | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

My husband and I had our Valentine’s Day dinner with our daughter here and the food and service was outstanding. Definitely will be back More

OpenTable Diner -
Old City HouseOld City House
329 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

Very good meal, great atmosphere, quiet so you can have an enjoyable conversation. More

OpenTable Diner -
Columbia Restaurant - St. AugustineColumbia Restaurant - St. Augustine
5196 reviews
$$$$
Spanish | St. Augustine, St. Augustine

Excellent dinner . Had 1605 salad, Delish, and paella delish Audray our waitress was wonderful. Would come again when we are in town. Many interesting dishes. Good service AND NO WAIT! More

OpenTable Diner -

Cities Nearby St. Augustine