Best Neighborhood Gem Restaurants in St. Augustine
Price
Cuisine
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility
9 restaurants available nearby
How are Featured results ranked
How is content generated
See what locals rave about
- BBOBJacksonville / Northeast Florida •10 reviews5.0Dined 1 day agoFirst of all the service was impeccable. Pleasant, attentive but not overbearing. Meal was staged perfectly and presented at our pace. Carne Di Manzo (appetizer) was tasty. The beef was very tender. Lobster ravioli was good. The lobster tail cooked to perfection. But the ravioli was a bit al dente for my taste. Homemade Butter rum cake was SO yummy….and that its served warm was a welcome surprise. This was our first time dining at Collage. Can’t wait to go back. There are several appetizers and entrees we would like to try.More infoCollage RestaurantPrice: Expensive• Global, International• St. Augustine•4.9
- CChristieAtlanta •1 review5.0Dined 1 day agoWe were sat upon arrival for our reservation. The leather bound EXTENSIVE meno was a nice touch. Ethan, our waiter, was jovial, attentive, but not hovering. We took our time ordered drinks (Raising Cane was a fun, different flavor!). The meatballs were unique and "exotic" spices as claimed in the menu. The tuna tartar had a little bit of kick with flavoring, but the highlight was the grilled toast. We shared a small tossed salad which was just the right amount after two apps. Our mains were Duck Pappardelle (special) and pasta al vodka with chicken thighs. Both were outstanding, with nice portions size. As we were leaving my husband gave his best review "We need to come back here, there are several other things I'd like to try!" A nice after dinner walk back to our car, parked on the river. (Give yourself plenty of time to get parked and walk, as there is no direct parking on these beautiful old brick streets.)More infoForgotten TonicPrice: Moderate• Contemporary American• St. Augustine•4.8
- SSteveJacksonville / Northeast Florida •1 review5.0Dined 2 days agoRestaurant is in an historic building c. 1879 which creates a nice atmosphere. At the front desk were asked if this was to celebrate a special occasion and were given a handwritten card and our desert was decorated accordingly - a nice touch. Food was excellent and service was first class. Extensive wine list. There is a choice of indoor and outdoor seating.More infoRaintree RestaurantPrice: Moderate• Contemporary American• St. Augustine•4.7
- JJimPhiladelphia County •3 reviews5.0Dined 2 days agoFrom start to finish we had a fabulous experience.More infoCordovaPrice: Expensive• Mediterranean• St. Augustine•4.5
- JJohnBath/Somerset •1 review4.0Dined 4 days agoA lovely place for a quiet meal with friends. Food was excellent, portions large, and service attentive.More infoLa Cocina at the Cellar UpstairsPrice: Expensive• Global, International• Saint Augustine Beach•4.6
Discover best neighborhood gem restaurants in St. Augustine
Discover the hidden culinary treasures of St. Augustine with our curated list of neighborhood gem restaurants in Jacksonville / Northeast Florida. Each restaurant selected exemplifies exceptional dining experiences that resonate with both locals and visitors alike, offering a mix of stunning ambiance, impeccable service, and uniquely crafted menus. St. Augustine, known for its rich history and picturesque settings, provides a perfect backdrop for these dining spots, enhancing the overall experience with their distinct local charm and hospitality. The restaurants featured on this page are celebrated for their commitment to quality and originality, often incorporating local ingredients and innovative culinary techniques to delight the palate. Whether you're in the mood for sophisticated seafood with oceanfront views, traditional Spanish and Mediterranean dishes, or modern twists on comfort food, St. Augustine's neighborhood gems have something special to offer. Each establishment has garnered high praise for not only their food but also for their attentive service and inviting atmosphere, making them must-visit destinations. Perfect for those seeking an intimate dining experience or a memorable meal in a scenic locale, these restaurants stand out as true gems in Northeast Florida's dining scene. Immerse yourself in the flavors and stories of St. Augustine as you explore these exceptional dining choices.