Best American Restaurants in Petaluma

View all

Best American Restaurants in Petaluma

Popular restaurants in San Francisco

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in San Francisco

Yoshi's Oakland
(718)
$$$$
Japanese | Oakland
Kincaid's Bayhouse - Oakland
(317)
$$$$
Steak | Oakland
View all San Francisco restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Petaluma restaurants.

Petaluma Restaurants

Wild Goat Bistro - PetalumaWild Goat Bistro - Petaluma
973 reviews
$$$$
American | Petaluma, Wine Country

Food amazing but pricey for me. Ambiance very nice. Service patchy. More

OpenTable Diner -
Central MarketCentral Market
1878 reviews
$$$$
Organic | Petaluma, Wine Country

I think it’s the best! Consistently excellent food and service. More

OpenTable Diner -
Della FattoriaDella Fattoria
152 reviews
$$$$
Farm-to-table | Petaluma, Wine Country

Team Della has created a wonderful dining experience in downtown Petaluma, beautiful, thoughtful, delicious food, perfect size portions and a fantastic wine menu with just the right balance of local and European wines. Service is warm and professional, overall great value and ambience. More

OpenTable Diner -
The ShuckeryThe Shuckery
433 reviews
$$$$
Oyster Bar | Petaluma, Wine Country

Chef is extremely helpful in revising as needed for allergies. Food was fresh and delicious. More

OpenTable Diner -
Pub RepublicPub Republic
304 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Petaluma, Wine Country

Good food and a lively atmosphere More

OpenTable Diner -
Buffalo Wild Wings - PetalumaBuffalo Wild Wings - Petaluma
7 reviews
$$$$
Sports Bar | Petaluma, Wine Country

Good place to have some food and beer and watch a game. More

OpenTable Diner -
Tolay - Sheraton PetalumaTolay - Sheraton Petaluma
115 reviews
$$$$
Seafood | Petaluma, Wine Country

Food was quite good considering it was a hotel restaurant. The bartender was very nice. More

OpenTable Diner -
red brickred brick
93 reviews
$$$$
Gastro Pub | Petaluma, Wine Country

See all specials

We had a lovely leisurely meal listening and dancing to Los Blue Notes. It was a perfect Sunday afternoon! More

OpenTable Diner -
Barber CellarsBarber Cellars
2 reviews
$$$$
American | Petaluma, Wine Country

Barber Cellars is my go to tasting room experience. The couple that own the tasting room are so gracious and fun. You will feel right at home. Great wine and no pretentiousness. The cheese pairing is local and perfectly paired with the wine. I've also brought my nephew here and he loved the free Pac Man and piano! It's located on the ground floor of the Hotel Petaluma, a great parlor to wander over to for bbq oysters and bubbles after a tasting! More

OpenTable Diner -

Petaluma Diners' Choice Winners

Petaluma's best restaurants based upon thousands of OpenTable diner reviews
Wild Goat Bistro - PetalumaWild Goat Bistro - Petaluma
973 reviews
$$$$
American | Petaluma, Wine Country

Food amazing but pricey for me. Ambiance very nice. Service patchy. More

OpenTable Diner -
Central MarketCentral Market
1878 reviews
$$$$
Organic | Petaluma, Wine Country

I think it’s the best! Consistently excellent food and service. More

OpenTable Diner -
Della FattoriaDella Fattoria
152 reviews
$$$$
Farm-to-table | Petaluma, Wine Country

Team Della has created a wonderful dining experience in downtown Petaluma, beautiful, thoughtful, delicious food, perfect size portions and a fantastic wine menu with just the right balance of local and European wines. Service is warm and professional, overall great value and ambience. More

OpenTable Diner -
The ShuckeryThe Shuckery
433 reviews
$$$$
Oyster Bar | Petaluma, Wine Country

Chef is extremely helpful in revising as needed for allergies. Food was fresh and delicious. More

OpenTable Diner -
Pub RepublicPub Republic
304 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Petaluma, Wine Country

Good food and a lively atmosphere More

OpenTable Diner -
Butcher Crown RoadhouseButcher Crown Roadhouse
32 reviews
$$$$
Barbecue | Petaluma, Wine Country

Two of us went to Butcher Crown on a Sunday morning, arriving right after they opened at 11:00 so the place was fairly empty. It was nice and quiet. The menu didn't have a large selection of offerings but what they had sounded interesting. We ended up getting the Butcher Burger and El Tejano (only available on weekends). WOW!!! I was told the Butcher Burger was the best burger in Northern California - and it looked like it. I had the El Tejano and it was awesome. I would have like the bun to have been a little bigger (can't believe I said that - how often does that happen) but there was so much brisket and onions and other good stuff piled on the bun it got a little messy. We decided to get the Bistec Quesadilla and split it as an appetizer. It, too, was awesome. The steak, onions, poblano combo with the cheeses and sauce they use is incredible. We had half of it left over to take home and enjoy later. We both had the fries with Old Bay seasoning as sides. I'm from Maryland - born on the Chesapeake Bay and weaned on Blue Crab - I've had a lot of Old Bay seasoning. We both thought the fries were a little salty and would have preferred a lot less Old Bay. And we both managed to finish the fries. Bottom line, the food was outstanding. The service was excellent. We're looking forward to our next visit and taking some friends with us. More

OpenTable Diner -
Tolay - Sheraton PetalumaTolay - Sheraton Petaluma
115 reviews
$$$$
Seafood | Petaluma, Wine Country

Food was quite good considering it was a hotel restaurant. The bartender was very nice. More

OpenTable Diner -
red brickred brick
93 reviews
$$$$
Gastro Pub | Petaluma, Wine Country

See all specials

We had a lovely leisurely meal listening and dancing to Los Blue Notes. It was a perfect Sunday afternoon! More

OpenTable Diner -