Best American Restaurants in Cape May

Peter Shields InnPeter Shields Inn
(3632)
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore
Washington InnWashington Inn
(4321)
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore
Ebbitt RoomEbbitt Room
(2243)
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore
Back Bay BistroBack Bay Bistro
(258)
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore
The Blue Pig TavernThe Blue Pig Tavern
(2098)
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore
Oyster Bay Steak and SeafoodOyster Bay Steak and Seafood
(870)
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore
Iron Pier CrafthouseIron Pier Crafthouse
(236)
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore
Avalon Links RestaurantAvalon Links Restaurant
(241)
$$$$
American | Cape May Court House, South Jersey Shore
SAX RestaurantSAX Restaurant
(302)
$$$$
American | Stone Harbor, South Jersey Shore
Doc Magrogan’s Oyster House – Sea Isle CityDoc Magrogan’s Oyster House – Sea Isle City
(500)
$$$$
American | Sea Isle City, South Jersey Shore
Daddy ODaddy O
(303)
$$$$
American | Long Beach Island, South Jersey Shore
Tuckers TavernTuckers Tavern
(313)
$$$$
American | Long Beach Island, South Jersey Shore

Best Italian Restaurants in Cape May

Sapore ItalianoSapore Italiano
(2168)
$$$$
Italian | Cape May, South Jersey Shore
Basilicos RistoranteBasilicos Ristorante
(935)
$$$$
Italian | Sea Isle City, South Jersey Shore
La SpiaggiaLa Spiaggia
(278)
$$$$
Italian | Brant Beach, South Jersey Shore
A Modo MioA Modo Mio
(574)
$$$$
Italian | Sea Isle City, South Jersey Shore
Raimondo'sRaimondo's
(279)
$$$$
Italian | Beach Haven, South Jersey Shore
La Fontana CoastLa Fontana Coast
(767)
$$$$
Italian | Sea Isle City, South Jersey Shore
Gaspares Italian BistroGaspares Italian Bistro
(199)
$$$$
Italian | Egg Harbor, Atlantic City
Il Verdi - Tropicana Atlantic CityIl Verdi - Tropicana Atlantic City
(722)
$$$$
Italian | Atlantic City, Atlantic City
Girasole RistoranteGirasole Ristorante
(1223)
$$$$
Italian | Atlantic City, Atlantic City
Italian StreetItalian Street
(44)
$$$$
Italian | Somers Point, Atlantic City
Carmine's - Atlantic CityCarmine's - Atlantic City
(7743)
$$$$
Italian | Atlantic City, Atlantic City
Capriccio at Resorts Atlantic CityCapriccio at Resorts Atlantic City
(1112)
$$$$
Italian | Atlantic City, Atlantic City
Panini Bay Waterfront RestaurantPanini Bay Waterfront Restaurant
(584)
$$$$
Italian | Tuckerton, Atlantic City
Red Room CafeRed Room Cafe
(528)
$$$$
Italian | Ventnor City, Atlantic City
Grotto - Atlantic CityGrotto - Atlantic City
(554)
$$$$
Italian | Atlantic City, Atlantic City

Popular restaurants in Atlantic City

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in Atlantic City

Steve & Cookie's By the Bay
(1185)
$$$$
American | Margate
Italian Street
(89)
$$$$
Italian | Somers Point
Gaspares Italian Bistro
(56)
$$$$
Italian | Egg Harbor
View all Atlantic City restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Cape May restaurants.

Cape May Restaurants

Peter Shields InnPeter Shields Inn
3632 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Fabulous food and outstanding service. Beautiful decor and elegant setting. A must dinner experience in Cape May. Gorgeous inn! More

OpenTable Diner -
Washington InnWashington Inn
4321 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

My husband and I came here for our one year anniversary dinner. It was decorated beautifully for Christmas time, a lovely atmosphere with outstanding service. We got the Burrata and Lamb Cavatelli for appetizers, and Short Rib and Duck for entrees. Not one complaint! We will definitely be returning! More

OpenTable Diner -
The Blue Rose Inn and RestaurantThe Blue Rose Inn and Restaurant
909 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

We were visiting cape may New Jersey for the weekend to enjoy the Christmas immense and selected this restaurant for dinner. This was the first time we have been there and we will definitely be going back. Everything was great about our dining experience especially the ambience of the Victorian home/restaurant. This is a BYOB. More

OpenTable Diner -
Tisha'sTisha's
3527 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

This is my wife's and my favorite restaurant for both special occasions as well as spur of the moment. The food is always very good as well as the service. My personal favorite is the tender and juicy filet topped with crispy onion rings. The fact that it is a BYOB makes it a perfect choice. Tell Brenda I recommended Tisha's. DonTrappler More

OpenTable Diner -
Sapore ItalianoSapore Italiano
2168 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Top notch food and service! A must when in Cape May! I cannot wait to go back! Great BYOB More

OpenTable Diner -
Union ParkUnion Park
1858 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Great service. More

OpenTable Diner -
Oyster Bay Steak and SeafoodOyster Bay Steak and Seafood
870 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

This restaurant is consistently excellent. Peak of summer, peak of holidays, reservations are a must for us! Staff is friendly and attentive even when they are slammed. More

OpenTable Diner -
YBYB
266 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

While in Cape May, this was the second time we visited YB. We were there over the summer and loved it. At the time we were told they would not be open "off season" Lucky for us we found that they were open Friday and Saturday during the off season. The menu is abbreviated but still offers great choices. Best of all they still offer the Peanut Butter Bomb for dessert. Our server was awesome (she was the only one working- the house was very quiet). It gave us a chance to "chat it up" with her. What a super friendly person. We also spoke to the chef who told us that changes were coming to YB. He mentioned menu changes and changes to the physical space. Can't wait !! P.S. Try their sister restaurant Georges for breakfast or Lunch. It's about two buildings up the block. Make sure to have dessert!! More

OpenTable Diner -
MYTHOΣMYTHOΣ
336 reviews
$$$$
Mediterranean | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Wonderful meal, fabulous atmosphere, great overall experience. More

OpenTable Diner -
Ebbitt RoomEbbitt Room
2243 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Excellent dinner. Our waiter was very helpful and jovial. My husband and I had very memorable time at the restaurant. More

OpenTable Diner -
Back Bay BistroBack Bay Bistro
258 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

All I can say is WOW. Great food, excellent service and very nice value. We cannot wait to go back there again. Our waitress was fabulous. The portions are large. More

OpenTable Diner -
The Blue Pig TavernThe Blue Pig Tavern
2098 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Always here in December for our anniversary. Flossie is the best server. Always a fabulous time! More

OpenTable Diner -
Mad Batter RestaurantMad Batter Restaurant
1197 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

We were staying at the hotel and had both breakfast and dinner at the mad batter. Both the service and food were excellent . Sat in the back dining room for dinner and was able to enjoy the music from the bar without it being to loud . I think it was a great value for the quality of food. More

OpenTable Diner -
Iron Pier CrafthouseIron Pier Crafthouse
236 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Great food and service! Will definitely be back. Had various specials which was nice More

OpenTable Diner -
SecondoSecondo
116 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Pat was Great!! More

OpenTable Diner -

Cape May Diners' Choice Winners

Cape May's best restaurants based upon thousands of OpenTable diner reviews
Peter Shields InnPeter Shields Inn
3632 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Fabulous food and outstanding service. Beautiful decor and elegant setting. A must dinner experience in Cape May. Gorgeous inn! More

OpenTable Diner -
Washington InnWashington Inn
4321 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

My husband and I came here for our one year anniversary dinner. It was decorated beautifully for Christmas time, a lovely atmosphere with outstanding service. We got the Burrata and Lamb Cavatelli for appetizers, and Short Rib and Duck for entrees. Not one complaint! We will definitely be returning! More

OpenTable Diner -
The Blue Rose Inn and RestaurantThe Blue Rose Inn and Restaurant
909 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

We were visiting cape may New Jersey for the weekend to enjoy the Christmas immense and selected this restaurant for dinner. This was the first time we have been there and we will definitely be going back. Everything was great about our dining experience especially the ambience of the Victorian home/restaurant. This is a BYOB. More

OpenTable Diner -
Tisha'sTisha's
3527 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

This is my wife's and my favorite restaurant for both special occasions as well as spur of the moment. The food is always very good as well as the service. My personal favorite is the tender and juicy filet topped with crispy onion rings. The fact that it is a BYOB makes it a perfect choice. Tell Brenda I recommended Tisha's. DonTrappler More

OpenTable Diner -
Sapore ItalianoSapore Italiano
2168 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Top notch food and service! A must when in Cape May! I cannot wait to go back! Great BYOB More

OpenTable Diner -
Union ParkUnion Park
1858 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Great service. More

OpenTable Diner -
410 Bank Street410 Bank Street
2101 reviews
$$$$
Seafood | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

The food and service were both Amazing! If you can't make it to New Orleans, this is the next best thing. Definitely fit for Foodies!!! Thanks for another Wonderful Dining Experience....see ya in 2019 More

OpenTable Diner -
MYTHOΣMYTHOΣ
336 reviews
$$$$
Mediterranean | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Wonderful meal, fabulous atmosphere, great overall experience. More

OpenTable Diner -
Oyster Bay Steak and SeafoodOyster Bay Steak and Seafood
870 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

This restaurant is consistently excellent. Peak of summer, peak of holidays, reservations are a must for us! Staff is friendly and attentive even when they are slammed. More

OpenTable Diner -
YBYB
266 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

While in Cape May, this was the second time we visited YB. We were there over the summer and loved it. At the time we were told they would not be open "off season" Lucky for us we found that they were open Friday and Saturday during the off season. The menu is abbreviated but still offers great choices. Best of all they still offer the Peanut Butter Bomb for dessert. Our server was awesome (she was the only one working- the house was very quiet). It gave us a chance to "chat it up" with her. What a super friendly person. We also spoke to the chef who told us that changes were coming to YB. He mentioned menu changes and changes to the physical space. Can't wait !! P.S. Try their sister restaurant Georges for breakfast or Lunch. It's about two buildings up the block. Make sure to have dessert!! More

OpenTable Diner -

Discover Cape May

Cape May is perfect for those who love chowing down on high-quality seafood. New Jersey is well-known for its incredible fish dishes, and you can find some of the best lobster in the world at Cape May restaurants. However, this area also has plenty of variety. It features a number of Asian restaurants, including some amazing pad thai. In addition to the variety, Cape May also has some unique signature dishes of its own. Their pizza is unique because it puts the cheese on the bottom of the pie and the sauce on the top. There are also some great breakfast dishes, such as delicious red velvet pancakes, that you just can't miss.