Best American Restaurants in Cape May

View all

Best American Restaurants in Cape May

Popular restaurants in Atlantic City

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in Atlantic City

Steve & Cookie's By the Bay
(756)
$$$$
American | Margate
A Touch of Italy
(133)
$$$$
Italian | Egg Harbor
La Cucina Ristorante
(61)
$$$$
Italian | Northfield/Linwood
Sofia - Margate
(83)
$$$$
Greek | Margate
View all Atlantic City restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Cape May restaurants.

Cape May Restaurants

Peter Shields InnPeter Shields Inn
3697 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

The restaurant is the best BYOB ever. The value for what you pay is incredible. Beautiful place and impeccable service and an awesome piano player. So worth staying at the inn too for all that they give you too. A yearly trip for us for sure. More

OpenTable Diner -
Washington InnWashington Inn
4378 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Enjoyed the best Valentune’s dinner at the Washington Inn. Outstanding food, service and ambience! More

OpenTable Diner -
Union ParkUnion Park
1865 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Wonderful experience for new Year's Eve. Our server was excellent. Our table for two was a little tight, but manageable. The main dining room was not as loud as I expected, since it was very full - very easy to converse. Would definitely return More

OpenTable Diner -
Tisha'sTisha's
3570 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Consistently fabulous food and great ambiance. Service always impeccable and hostesses welcoming. More

OpenTable Diner -
Sapore ItalianoSapore Italiano
2263 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

The food was delicious and the staff was great. Would come back again but it's a little out of my price range to make it a regular outing. More

OpenTable Diner -
Ebbitt RoomEbbitt Room
2307 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Dinner at the Ebbitt Room is always extra special on Valentine’s Day. The food and service is always perfect. More

OpenTable Diner -
Oyster Bay Steak and SeafoodOyster Bay Steak and Seafood
878 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

We had a great time! The food was delicious and service was very timely! More

OpenTable Diner -
Mad Batter RestaurantMad Batter Restaurant
1240 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Good service, solid food but not a lot of choices. Good if you prefer vegan. More

OpenTable Diner -
Back Bay BistroBack Bay Bistro
270 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Good Food Good Service great value byob More

OpenTable Diner -
YBYB
269 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Valentine’s Day More

OpenTable Diner -
The Blue Pig TavernThe Blue Pig Tavern
2167 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Valentine’s Day dinner with my wife. We had a great server and the food was cooked perfectly. We have dined here before and every time they meet expectations. We love it here! More

OpenTable Diner -
SecondoSecondo
140 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

An amazing meal! The menu options are extensive and all of our choices were delicious! Be careful not to eat all of the fantastic garlic bread so you have room for your meal. We split a strawberry salad from the specials which was great and enough for 4 people. My husband had a salmon dish from the specials and I had the eggplant listed on the regular menu. Both dishes were fantastic and very large. We split one of their deserts-chocolate mouse with a layer of peanut butter on a candy bottom! Our waitress was friendly and informative. A great meal!, More

OpenTable Diner -

Cape May Diners' Choice Winners

Cape May's best restaurants based upon thousands of OpenTable diner reviews
Peter Shields InnPeter Shields Inn
3697 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

The restaurant is the best BYOB ever. The value for what you pay is incredible. Beautiful place and impeccable service and an awesome piano player. So worth staying at the inn too for all that they give you too. A yearly trip for us for sure. More

OpenTable Diner -
Washington InnWashington Inn
4378 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Enjoyed the best Valentune’s dinner at the Washington Inn. Outstanding food, service and ambience! More

OpenTable Diner -
Sapore ItalianoSapore Italiano
2263 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

The food was delicious and the staff was great. Would come back again but it's a little out of my price range to make it a regular outing. More

OpenTable Diner -
Tisha'sTisha's
3570 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Consistently fabulous food and great ambiance. Service always impeccable and hostesses welcoming. More

OpenTable Diner -
Union ParkUnion Park
1865 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Wonderful experience for new Year's Eve. Our server was excellent. Our table for two was a little tight, but manageable. The main dining room was not as loud as I expected, since it was very full - very easy to converse. Would definitely return More

OpenTable Diner -
410 Bank Street410 Bank Street
2101 reviews
$$$$
Seafood | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

The food and service were both Amazing! If you can't make it to New Orleans, this is the next best thing. Definitely fit for Foodies!!! Thanks for another Wonderful Dining Experience....see ya in 2019 More

OpenTable Diner -
YBYB
269 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Valentine’s Day More

OpenTable Diner -
Ebbitt RoomEbbitt Room
2307 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Dinner at the Ebbitt Room is always extra special on Valentine’s Day. The food and service is always perfect. More

OpenTable Diner -
Iron Pier CrafthouseIron Pier Crafthouse
242 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Early New Year’s Eve with friends! Dine here often, wonderful meal and service as always! Have done lots of reviews, so logging in for 2019! More

OpenTable Diner -
Back Bay BistroBack Bay Bistro
270 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Good Food Good Service great value byob More

OpenTable Diner -

Discover Cape May

Cape May is perfect for those who love chowing down on high-quality seafood. New Jersey is well-known for its incredible fish dishes, and you can find some of the best lobster in the world at Cape May restaurants. However, this area also has plenty of variety. It features a number of Asian restaurants, including some amazing pad thai. In addition to the variety, Cape May also has some unique signature dishes of its own. Their pizza is unique because it puts the cheese on the bottom of the pie and the sauce on the top. There are also some great breakfast dishes, such as delicious red velvet pancakes, that you just can't miss.