Cape May Restaurants

Make a free reservation

View all 676 restaurants in Atlantic City

Best American Restaurants in Cape May

Peter Shields InnPeter Shields Inn
(3085)
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore
Washington InnWashington Inn
(3811)
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore
Ebbitt RoomEbbitt Room
(1975)
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore
Back Bay BistroBack Bay Bistro
(208)
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore
The Blue Pig TavernThe Blue Pig Tavern
(1808)
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore
Oyster Bay Steak and SeafoodOyster Bay Steak and Seafood
(668)
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore
Iron Pier CrafthouseIron Pier Crafthouse
(116)
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore
Black Eyed SusansBlack Eyed Susans
(310)
$$$$
American | Harvey Cedars, South Jersey Shore
Avalon Links RestaurantAvalon Links Restaurant
(189)
$$$$
American | Cape May Court House, South Jersey Shore
SAX RestaurantSAX Restaurant
(242)
$$$$
American | Stone Harbor, South Jersey Shore
Doc Magrogan’s Oyster House – Sea Isle CityDoc Magrogan’s Oyster House – Sea Isle City
(372)
$$$$
American | Sea Isle City, South Jersey Shore
Daddy ODaddy O
(216)
$$$$
American | Long Beach Island, South Jersey Shore
Tuckers TavernTuckers Tavern
(201)
$$$$
American | Long Beach Island, South Jersey Shore
North End American GrillNorth End American Grill
(61)
$$$$
American | Wildwood, South Jersey Shore

Best Italian Restaurants in Cape May

Sapore ItalianoSapore Italiano
(1470)
$$$$
Italian | Cape May, South Jersey Shore
Basilicos RistoranteBasilicos Ristorante
(782)
$$$$
Italian | Sea Isle City, South Jersey Shore
La SpiaggiaLa Spiaggia
(174)
$$$$
Italian | Brant Beach, South Jersey Shore
A Modo MioA Modo Mio
(428)
$$$$
Italian | Sea Isle City, South Jersey Shore
Raimondo'sRaimondo's
(198)
$$$$
Italian | Beach Haven, South Jersey Shore
La Fontana CoastLa Fontana Coast
(608)
$$$$
Italian | Sea Isle City, South Jersey Shore
La Fontana Del MareLa Fontana Del Mare
(376)
$$$$
Italian | Strathmere, South Jersey Shore
La Vecchia FontanaLa Vecchia Fontana
(407)
$$$$
Italian | Avalon, South Jersey Shore
Spiaggetta Italian Seafood TrattoriaSpiaggetta Italian Seafood Trattoria
(247)
$$$$
Italian | Stone Harbor, South Jersey Shore
De Ninno’sDe Ninno’s
(94)
$$$$
Italian | Wildwood Crest, South Jersey Shore
Gaspares Italian BistroGaspares Italian Bistro
(136)
$$$$
Italian | Egg Harbor, Atlantic City
Il Verdi - Tropicana Atlantic CityIl Verdi - Tropicana Atlantic City
(575)
$$$$
Italian | Atlantic City, Atlantic City
Girasole RistoranteGirasole Ristorante
(1049)
$$$$
Italian | Atlantic City, Atlantic City
Italian StreetItalian Street
(29)
$$$$
Italian | Somers Point, Atlantic City
Carmine's - Atlantic CityCarmine's - Atlantic City
(7081)
$$$$
Italian | Atlantic City, Atlantic City
Capriccio at Resorts Atlantic CityCapriccio at Resorts Atlantic City
(855)
$$$$
Italian | Atlantic City, Atlantic City
Panini Bay Waterfront RestaurantPanini Bay Waterfront Restaurant
(462)
$$$$
Italian | Tuckerton, Atlantic City
Red Room CafeRed Room Cafe
(428)
$$$$
Italian | Ventnor City, Atlantic City
Grotto - Atlantic CityGrotto - Atlantic City
(486)
$$$$
Italian | Atlantic City, Atlantic City

Popular restaurants in Atlantic City

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in Atlantic City

Italian Street
(575)
$$$$
Italian | Somers Point
Steve & Cookie's By the Bay
(73)
$$$$
American | Margate
Atlantic City Country Club - Taproom Bar & Grille
(57)
$$$$
American | Northfield/Linwood
View all Atlantic City restaurants
Cape May Locals Are Talking About
What do locals love about Cape May?
The Sunsets along the Delaware Bay are wonderful!
OT
OpenTable Diner - Atlantic City
What do locals love about Cape May?
Fabulous restaurants, venues with live music, peace and serenity from the beautiful venue!
C
Cape1220 - Philadelphia
What’s the dining scene like in Cape May?
Excellent choice and variety of restaurants at all price points! We love Fins!
f
fulton - New York Area

Treat your taste buds: Explore Cape May restaurants.

Cape May Restaurants

Union ParkUnion Park
1507 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

The lamb chops were some of the best I have had. Cooked perfectly. Love the beet salad. Everyone enjoyed their meal. One of our favorites. More

OpenTable Diner -
Peter Shields InnPeter Shields Inn
3085 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

We went to PSI for our wedding anniversary and it was wonderful. RJ was our server. He was personable, attentive, and knowledgeable. We were seated in a lovely side patio area with just enough privacy, but allowed for the perfect amount of ambiance for the aesthetic of PSI. We did the chef’s prefixed menu and we were stuffed. I highly recommend PSI to anyone who visits Cape May. More

OpenTable Diner -
Tisha'sTisha's
2990 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

The food, the service were just as expected. Tisha's is one of our favorite restaurants in Cape May. More

OpenTable Diner -
Washington InnWashington Inn
3811 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

The Washington Inn is just one of the most consistent Cape May restaurants and I can say that we have never been disappointed by the food or the service. More

OpenTable Diner -
YBYB
185 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

YB's is one of our favorite restaurants in Cape May and our go to place for special occasions. This visit was for my wife's birthday. Our reservation was for six thirty and although we arrived a bit early, we were greeted by a friendly wait staff that were more than happy to show us to our table. This is a BYOB restaurant and our waitress, a very nice young lady, brought wine glasses and a chilled bucket to hold our wine. The menu gets tweaked every so often, but their steak and crab cakes pretty much remain the same and are out of this world good : ) The sword fish tacos are amazing and the desserts are worth adjusting that extra notch in my belt! YB's is an excellent choice in a town with many so many great choices to dine. More

OpenTable Diner -
Ebbitt RoomEbbitt Room
1975 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Excellence dining experience, interesting cuisine options, all farm-to-table, and lovely service. More

OpenTable Diner -
Oyster Bay Steak and SeafoodOyster Bay Steak and Seafood
668 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Great place everything delicious More

OpenTable Diner -
Sapore ItalianoSapore Italiano
1470 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Delicious meal and excellent service. Both had the specials, one was veal and the other seafood and pasta. Also had Caesar salad which was very good as well. More

OpenTable Diner -
The Blue Rose Inn and RestaurantThe Blue Rose Inn and Restaurant
764 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

A quaint cozy feel. The staff was friendly and attentive. The food excellent. I’d recommend the pork pappardelle! Oh, and the soufflé! More

OpenTable Diner -
Back Bay BistroBack Bay Bistro
208 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Lovely restaurant. Great staff. Excellent service and delicious food. Waitress actually remembered that I liked my salad without lettuce. More

OpenTable Diner -
The Blue Pig TavernThe Blue Pig Tavern
1808 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

the Turkey burger was excellent!! My house drink bourbon (Makers Mark) cherry sour was A+. My only complaint is that the drink was so good and easy to drink that I had two, which for someone who had not had a drink in a few months caused a headache - small price to pay for a wonderful dinner! More

OpenTable Diner -
Mad Batter RestaurantMad Batter Restaurant
951 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Food is always great. Love the ambience and the service! Workers are courteous and very friendly. More

OpenTable Diner -
Iron Pier CrafthouseIron Pier Crafthouse
116 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Wonderful dinner with friends new to Cape May! Did small plates and mains, tried lots of dishes and loved them all! Great service and excellent drinks. More

OpenTable Diner -
410 Bank Street410 Bank Street
1775 reviews
$$$$
Seafood | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

If you want great food and service, 410 Bank St. is the restaurant for you. The menu is outstanding with both turf and surf selections. More

OpenTable Diner -
SeaSaltSeaSalt
519 reviews
$$$$
Seafood | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Flavorful meal and attentive staff More

OpenTable Diner -
Egg & DartEgg & Dart
Reviews Coming Soon
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Welcome to Egg & Dart

Serving scratch made breakfast made for you daily from the owners & chefs from The Pier House.More

A CA Mia-Cape MayA CA Mia-Cape May
124 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

We loved the place. Food was excellent as well as the service. Were treated exceptionally well by all the staff. Highest recommendation More

OpenTable Diner -

Cape May Diners' Choice Winners

Cape May's best restaurants based upon thousands of OpenTable diner reviews
Peter Shields InnPeter Shields Inn
3085 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

We went to PSI for our wedding anniversary and it was wonderful. RJ was our server. He was personable, attentive, and knowledgeable. We were seated in a lovely side patio area with just enough privacy, but allowed for the perfect amount of ambiance for the aesthetic of PSI. We did the chef’s prefixed menu and we were stuffed. I highly recommend PSI to anyone who visits Cape May. More

OpenTable Diner -
Tisha'sTisha's
2990 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

The food, the service were just as expected. Tisha's is one of our favorite restaurants in Cape May. More

OpenTable Diner -
Washington InnWashington Inn
3811 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

The Washington Inn is just one of the most consistent Cape May restaurants and I can say that we have never been disappointed by the food or the service. More

OpenTable Diner -
Union ParkUnion Park
1507 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

The lamb chops were some of the best I have had. Cooked perfectly. Love the beet salad. Everyone enjoyed their meal. One of our favorites. More

OpenTable Diner -
Back Bay BistroBack Bay Bistro
208 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Lovely restaurant. Great staff. Excellent service and delicious food. Waitress actually remembered that I liked my salad without lettuce. More

OpenTable Diner -
Ebbitt RoomEbbitt Room
1975 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Excellence dining experience, interesting cuisine options, all farm-to-table, and lovely service. More

OpenTable Diner -
Sapore ItalianoSapore Italiano
1470 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Delicious meal and excellent service. Both had the specials, one was veal and the other seafood and pasta. Also had Caesar salad which was very good as well. More

OpenTable Diner -
Oyster Bay Steak and SeafoodOyster Bay Steak and Seafood
668 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

Great place everything delicious More

OpenTable Diner -
The Blue Rose Inn and RestaurantThe Blue Rose Inn and Restaurant
764 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

A quaint cozy feel. The staff was friendly and attentive. The food excellent. I’d recommend the pork pappardelle! Oh, and the soufflé! More

OpenTable Diner -
The Blue Pig TavernThe Blue Pig Tavern
1808 reviews
$$$$
American | Cape May, South Jersey Shore

the Turkey burger was excellent!! My house drink bourbon (Makers Mark) cherry sour was A+. My only complaint is that the drink was so good and easy to drink that I had two, which for someone who had not had a drink in a few months caused a headache - small price to pay for a wonderful dinner! More

OpenTable Diner -