The Best Pizza in Miami

Miami has an international reputation for stunning beaches and Art Deco buildings. Cuisines from around the world come to life in this Floridian metropolis — and Italian is arguably the most popular. But where are the coolest, most knowledgeable diners eating out? Welcome to the Tastemaker Lists. Our experts have researched the city’s eateries to find out who is serving the best pizza in Miami. We bring you the best-reviewed and most popular pizza restaurants in Florida’s largest city. Miami is home to pizza joints, trattorias, family-run cafes, and everything in between. There’s classic Italian cuisine at every turn — along with a huge selection of pizzas. Book a table at one of these fantastic eateries on OpenTable, and prepare yourself for some of the best pizza in Miami.

The OpenTable Team

9 Restaurants

Updated February 26, 2020

Restaurants:	Forte dei Marmi, CRUST, Aprile Restaurant & Market…
Price Range:	$$ - $$$$
Cuisines:	Italian…
Neighborhoods:	South Beach, Overtown, Doral…

Forte dei Marmi

$$$$

Italian

South Beach

4.5

1485 reviews

Located in Miami Beach, Forte dei Marmi has a local reputation for its organic ingredients. All the seafood comes from local waters. And the prime meats on the menu are all farm-raised. Freshness and quality are always on the menu here. The stylish dining area is seductive and elegant — perfect for romance. And the style of service takes its inspiration from Italy’s slow dining culture. Servers encourage diners to take their time and stay a while.

At the moment, there's no online availability within 2.5 hours of your request. Do you have another time in mind?

CRUST

$$$$

Italian

Overtown

4.8

2641 reviews

This family-run business has a reputation for rustic Italian cuisine with a contemporary edge. As well as the traditional pizza toppings most people might expect, there are a few that challenge the rules of conventional cuisine. The Truffled Pizza and the Crust Pizza (with figs and prosciutto) are two of the most interesting creations. The dining area at Crust is replete with dark woods, art, and collectibles from Italy. And the style of service is semi-formal. This unique eatery claims to serve the best pizza in Miami. And based on reviews, it’s hard to argue.

At the moment, there's no online availability within 2.5 hours of your request. Do you have another time in mind?

Aprile Restaurant & Market

$$$$

Italian

Doral

4.7

112 reviews

Aprile Restaurant and Market is on 107th Avenue in the Doral district of the city. This ultra-modern eatery features tiled floors, dark woods, and a range of different light fixtures. The result is a classically Italian restaurant with a modern edge. The food here is also modern. Diners can enjoy all the best-loved flavors of Italy, but every dish hits the plate in an artistic, contemporary way. Most of the classic pizzas people expect are available. But for people looking for something different, the Affettato (prosciutto, salami, and pepperoni with truffle oil) is worth a try.

At the moment, there's no online availability within 2.5 hours of your request. Do you have another time in mind?

Ironside Pizza

$$$$

Pizzeria

MiMo / Upper East Side

4.8

198 reviews

Located on 4th Street in Central Miami, Ironside Pizza is simple, spacious, and lots of fun. The style of cooking here is rustic. And the management labels the pizzas as “homemade.” Chefs source most of the ingredients from local sources. But the Ironside take great pride from the fact that many of the ingredients come from Italy. There’s a neighborhood feel here which is infectious. The serving staff know a lot of customers by name — and by their favorite pizza. The range of authentic Napoletana pizzas includes classics such as the Marinara, the Romana, and the Diavola.

At the moment, there's no online availability within 2.5 hours of your request. Do you have another time in mind?

Fratelli La Bufala

$$$$

Italian

South Beach

4.7

649 reviews

Fratelli La Bufala is a lively eatery in Miami Beach. The ethos here centers on healthy ingredients and quality. While many ingredients come from local sources in Florida, a lot of them are flown in from Italian farms. And this is why locals believe this place serves the best pizza in Miami. There’s an authenticity about every dish on the menu. Only 100% buffalo mozzarella makes the top of Fratelli La Bufala’s pizzas. There are also a few pizzas made with buffalo meat. The service style here is familial, so everyone feels as though they’re eating in the owner’s home.

At the moment, there's no online availability within 2.5 hours of your request. Do you have another time in mind?

Experiences available

View Experiences

BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse - Miami Falls

$$$$

American

Kendall

4.5

23 reviews

Located in central Miami, BJ’s Restaurant and Brewhouse is a family-run business with a big reputation for quality. There’s a rustic feel to the decor and decals in the dining area. And that feel extends to many of the dishes available. The restaurant also boasts its own award-winning, handcrafted beer. The pizzas at BJ’s are Chicago-style with a Southern California twist. There are also “Tavern-Style” thin pizzas served on boards. Smokey sauces and hearty cuts of meat characterize the dishes here.

At the moment, there's no online availability within 2.5 hours of your request. Do you have another time in mind?

Tatore

$$$$

Italian

North Miami

4.5

194 reviews

Tatore is a homely eatery on Biscayne Boulevard. The service style here friendly and laid-back. Servers go to extraordinary lengths to make diners feel like they’re eating in someone’s home. The kitchen team makes all the pasta on the premises. And a traditional brick oven is responsible for cooking the pizza. Italian decor and music combine to create an authentic ambiance that transports diners to the coastal regions of Italy. Most of the classic Italian pizzas are on the menu. Among the most popular options are the Arugula e Prosciutto and the Portuguesa (ham, mozzarella, boiled eggs, and black olives.

At the moment, there's no online availability within 2.5 hours of your request. Do you have another time in mind?

Rotelli Pizza & Pasta- Dolphin Mall

$$$$

Italian

Tamiami

4.3

8 reviews

Located inside Miami’s Dolphin Mall, Rotelli Pizza & Pasta is always a hive of activity. Perfect for birthday celebrations and large gatherings, this bustling restaurant offers a fast yet friendly style of service. There are several pasta dishes and classic Italian delicacies on the menu. But the most popular dishes are all hand-tossed pizzas. There are several New York-style pizzas to choose from. Or diners can build their own from a selection of several classic toppings. This place gets very busy, so reserving a table is always a good idea.

At the moment, there's no online availability within 2.5 hours of your request. Do you have another time in mind?

The Brick American Kitchen & Bar

$$$$

Farm-to-table

Kendall

4.3

563 reviews

The Brick in Dadeland is more of an American bistro than a pizza restaurant. The style of service is casual and familiar, and there’s a neighborhood vibe that puts people at ease. People come from far and wide to sample The Brick’s pizza pies. Chefs make the dough fresh on the premises every day. And only locally-sourced meat and vegetables made the toppings list. One of the house specialties is the grilled chicken pizza, made with mozzarella, ranch dressing, and buffalo sauce. For people who like experimental topping combinations, this place is perfect.

At the moment, there's no online availability within 2.5 hours of your request. Do you have another time in mind?

Explore OpenTable

Miami

The Best Pizza