Sister Bay Restaurants
Make a free reservation
Check out diners' favorite restaurants in Sister Bay
Updated on
Diners’ Choice Awards are based on where your fellow diners book, dine, and review. Only verified diners get to review restaurants on OpenTable, so our data doesn’t lie.
See what locals rave about in Sister Bay
- WWendefrykMobile •8 reviews5.0Dined 2 days agoAmazing dinner and our waitress, Haily, was exceptional. Every dish we tasted was prepared beautifully and delicious. The beef cheeks were something I’ll dream about for a long time. Would love the recipe. Library room is so quaint and fun to watch the chefs.More infoChives - Baileys HarborPrice: Very Expensive• American• Baileys Harbor•4.7
- JJamesvipChicago / Illinois •9 reviews5.0Dined 4 days agoExcellent and server the Best! Staff very friendly and professional and make you feel right at home!! Bar tenders very friendly !! JimMore infoBarringer's RestaurantPrice: Very Expensive• American• Fish Creek•4.8
- NNicoleNew York City •1 review5.0Dined 4 days agoThe food was very good. The ambiance was amazing. Service was fantastic. If it’s sushi night, get a roll—best tempura shrimp roll I have ever had! The seafood pasta was good, NY strip was slightly overcooked and quite fatty, the lake perch (pan seared) was good. Don’t skip dessert—the carrot cake was delicious.More infoCHOPPrice: Expensive• Steakhouse• Sister Bay•4.6
- KKathyvipChicago / Illinois •17 reviews5.0Dined on Nov 22, 2024The Japanese hot chicken is awesome! Great menu selections.More infoFat BellyPrice: Expensive• Asian• Sister Bay•4.9
- OTOpenTable DinervipChicago / Illinois •13 reviews5.0Dined on Oct 22, 2024We had a lovely dinner at LURE! It was my mother’s birthday. We had asked for a round table for 6 and that is exactly what was set up. The food was fresh (fish) and delicious! Our server was really friendly, prompt, and seemed to like her job. Everyone had a nice dinner, and the deserts were fabulous THANK YOU!More infoLure (WISCONSIN)Price: Expensive• Seafood• Sister Bay•4.6
Get inspired by our collections of the top restaurants in Sister Bay
Discover Sister Bay
As one of Wisconsin's premier small-town dining destinations, Sister Bay offers a varied selection of eateries from which to choose. Whether you want to dine at restaurants that have been featured in popular magazines and on the Food Network or try a pub burger at a family-owned tavern, you can easily do so in Sister Bay. You can enjoy waterfront views, local award-winning wines and the popular Wisconsin tradition of a Friday night fish fry using locally caught fish. Speaking of local, there is no better reason to visit than to enjoy the many uses of the famous Door County cherries. There is simply no end to the variations of pies, juices and wines that are produced from the region’s freshly picked cherries.
Explore OpenTable
- Sister Bay Dog Park
- Village Green Lodge
- Country House Resort
- Gordon Lodge
- Pirate's Cove Mini Golf
- Open Hearth Lodge
- Somerset Inn & Suites
- The Nordic Lodge
- North Bay State Natural Area
- Pine Grove Resort
- Marshalls Point State Natural Area
- Eagle Harbor Inn
- Edgewater Resort
- Waterfront Park
- Water Street Gallery
- Koepsel's Farm Market
- Waterbury Inn
- High Point Inn
- Gibraltar District School No. 2
- American Folklore Theatre