Diners' Choice: Italian restaurants in Indiana

OpenTable

Updated June 05, 2025

Looking for restaurants with the best overall Italian cuisine in Indiana? You’re in the right place. Each month OpenTable analyzes more than 400,000 new diner reviews. We sort the results by category to help you discover new favorites. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

DeLullo's Trattoria

4.8

4.8 (335)

$30 and under

Italian

Cicero

About the restaurant

We are an Italian style restaurant located just blocks from Morse Reservoir in Cicero, Indiana. Delullo's Italian Bistro specializes in hearty Italian specialties, pizzas, hoagies, and salads. We are family owned and operated, and we pride ourselves on using locally sourced ingredients. Our warm and welcoming atmosphere makes you feel at home while our food feeds your soul. Whether you are in the mood for pizza, lasagna, salad, or just a “home-cooked” meal, you are sure to find something flavorful and scrumptious when dining with us!

Top review

Roxane

Dined on Jun 25, 2025

Great food and reasonable prices. I had the chicken pesto ravioli.

Osteria Amici

4.8

4.8 (56)

$30 and under

Italian

Elkhart

About the restaurant

Now Open!
We are here to welcome you to a gathering of food and friends at Amici. As part of Navarre Hospitality and partnered with Paul Cataldo of Antonio's Ristorante, we are driven to provide excellent food, quality, and service, making you want to come back for more.

Top review

Stephanie

Dined 4 days ago

The food was absolutely amazing! We enjoyed multiple pastas, pizzas, and appetizers for the entire table and none of it disappointed. They know exactly what they’re doing here, and if you have not tried it you absolutely need to.

Bridges Wine Bar

4.8

4.8 (896)

$30 and under

Italian

Greencastle

About the restaurant

Craft pizzas, housemade pastas; an incredible assortment of wines and much more!

Sometimes one good idea leads to another. Such is the case with Bridges. With the success of Music on the Square, we began imagining what could happen next. The location next door (19 North Indiana) was up for sale, so we bought it and began thinking of what would be complementary. We started imagining Bridges as a wine bar offering interesting wines to Greencastle. But we soon added a wood burning pizza oven from Italy and more of a restaurant evolved. Ultimately, the idea of Bridges Wine Bar was born. The basement has become a private dining room called The Cellar, an open terrace area on top of the building, which will be used in nice weather, called The Rooftop, and there will be three fully furnished rental apartments which we call The Lofts at Bridges.

We hope you will like our addition to the Square of Greencastle.

Top review

ken

Dined 7 days ago

We had another wonderful dining experience at Bridges! We are there frequently 0n Friday nights. We started with the Wexler Manhattans. The best Manhattan I have ever had. Fortunately, the Oysters Florentine were on the menu. One of our favorites, they never disappoint. Our entrees were great; salmon perfectly grilled for me, my wife had Shishito Peppers and the Burrata Salad. The service is attentive, friendly and personal. I highly recommend. 10 out of 10. Give it a try!

Good Omen

4.9

4.9 (152)

$50 and over

Italian

NW Indy / Zionsville

About the restaurant

Good Omen is a family-owned Northern Italian restaurant with a seasonally rotating menu in the heart of Zionsville and co-owned by mother-and-son partners Nicholas and Diane Gattone. With a background in fine dining in places as far-flung as Chicago, Nantucket Island, and Tuscany, executive chef Nicholas is bringing his knowledge of modern Italian food and wine and a commitment to hospitable dining to his native Midwest. Mangiare!

Aperitivo Hour From 3-5pm
Dinner Starts at 5pm!

Top review

JanVIP

Dined 2 days ago

Four of us worked our way thru the menu, sharing dishes as we traveled through appetizers, salads, pastas, and entrees. Every single bite was outstanding. Wine list excellent and well priced. A thoroughly enjoyable dining experience

Ambrosia

4.8

4.8 (1282)

$31 to $50

Italian

Broad Ripple / Meridian - Kessler

About the restaurant

Ambrosia was founded on the principle that the best food - and the best times of our lives - begin with love. In the Pizzi family kitchen in Liguria, Italy, the dinner table was a treasured space for family and friends. Since 1979, the Pizzi family, which now includes Gino's daughters Manuela, Anna, and Francesca, has been bringing that same love and commitment to the Ambrosia kitchen. Regular patrons and staff are all part of the family, and first-time visitors are welcomed like old friends.

Top review

Tim

Dined 4 days ago

Our anniversary dinner was excellent. James was great. Our entrees, appetizers and desert were excellent. The house Chianti was excellent as well. Very highly recommended.

Discover more

Iozzo's Garden of Italy

4.9

4.9 (4851)

$30 and under

Italian

Downtown Indy

About the restaurant

Originally established in 1930 Iozzo's Garden of Italy is the Newest Oldest Italian Restaurant in Indianapolis. The high quality menu features a mix of traditional Iozzo Family Italian fare along with a modern twist on Italian dishes.

Top review

Katie

Dined 6 days ago

Entrees were a little pricey but was great quality and delicious. Server Sam was super attentive and helpful.

Discover more

4.8

4.8 (1810)

$31 to $50

Italian

Carmel / Westfield

About the restaurant

We are an authentic Italian restaurant established in 2013. In 2020 the business was passed down from one generation to the next to remain in the family and maintain authenticity. We pride ourselves on our quality service and excellent food. All our sauces and pastas are made fresh in house to deliver a modern twist on classic Italian cuisine. We have an extensive wine list featuring boutique wines from Italy. Stop in to experience a taste of Italy right in the heart of Carmel.

Top review

Dined 2 days ago

Nice authentic Italian! Everything was delicious. The staff is amazing. We’ll definitely be back.

Discover more

Matteo's Ristorante Italiano

4.7

4.7 (2350)

$31 to $50

Italian

Noblesville

About the restaurant

Matteo's is the premier Italian experience in the Midwest. Authentic Italian restaurant voted one of the top 25 restaurants in Indiana for the 4th year in a row. Matteo's is perfect for business and family gatherings. Famous for its homemade cuisine.
Conveniently located on the square of downtown Noblesville, across the street from the courthouse.

Top review

Liz

Dined 2 days ago

We had friends in from Dallas, they were very impressed with the ambiance, extremely impressed with our server ( the owner’s daughter). She was delightful! And The food was outstanding!!

Iozzo's on Jefferson

4.8

4.8 (188)

$30 and under

Italian

Greenwood

About the restaurant

Every bite tells a story.
From our early 20th century roots to today, ours is a captivating tale rooted in love, drama, and deliciousness.

We promise to serve the finest in Italian cuisine and wine and provide an upscale and memorable dining experience to all our guests.

Top review

Rod

Dined 3 days ago

Finally, an upscale restaurant in Franklin. Iozzo's has been open for a few months, and after reading all the reviews and speaking with friends who have been there, we decided that we needed to give it a try. Rest assured, we were not disappointed! We had reservations, and we were seated right away. Our water glasses were filled as soon as we were seated. Our server came to the table within 2 or 3 minutes of our arrival, took our drink order, and explained a little about some of the menu items. We started with the Calamari, which came with a choice of Marinara or Spicy Aioli sauce, or both. We decided to try both. If you don't mind a little bit of kick, go with the Aioli; it was delicious. For our entrees, my wife chose the Shrimp Scampi, blackened, and she was very pleased with it. I had the Penne ala Vodka. The Vodka sauce had a good amount of crumbled sausage and just enough kick to get your attention. I highly recommend it! After the meal, we were both so full we decided to skip dessert, but I did have a Double Espresso. They serve Lavazza coffee, which happens to be my favorite; it's what I drink at home. I can't end this review without giving a shout-out to the waitstaff. Everyone we interacted with was friendly, attentive, and professional.

Diavola

4.8

4.8 (1215)

$30 and under

Italian

Broad Ripple / Meridian - Kessler

About the restaurant

Diavola: Upscale Neapolitan Pizzeria, Italian Cucina and Wine Bar. Brick oven fired pizzas, in-house made fresh pastas, both imported and locally sourced quality ingredients daily, gluten and dairy free options as well. We're family friendly and always welcoming. Try something at Diavola tonight!

Top review

Derek

Dined 6 days ago

The Gnocchi special was one of the best pasta dishes I have ever eaten. Every food and drink item was pleasing and our server was great.

Discover more

Popular dish

Margherita

Popular dish

Wild Mushroom Ravioli

Explore Diners' Choice best of Indiana