Diners' Choice: Italian restaurants in Caribbean

OpenTable

Updated April 05, 2025

Looking for restaurants with the best overall Italian cuisine in Caribbean? You’re in the right place. Each month OpenTable analyzes more than 400,000 new diner reviews. We sort the results by category to help you discover new favorites. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

Bella Trattoria

4.8

4.8 (46)

$31 to $50

Italian

West Bay

About the restaurant

Step into our Italian trattoria, where the rustic charm meets modern flair.
The warm ambiance invites you to savor the essence of Italy, with exposed brick walls and cozy seating.

Top review

ChrisVIP

Dined on Apr 12, 2025

Absolutely stunning dinner with my wife. The staff was attentive without being intrusive. The food was outstanding with a creative mix of a classic dish with modern takes. We will absolutely return.

Santino Cucina e Vino

4.8

4.8 (29)

$31 to $50

Italian

Santo Domingo

About the restaurant

Old school italian cuisine in a nice classic ambiance, all our pasta are made fresh daily. Carefully curated selection of Italian wines, amaro and grappa. Great for business lunches on weekdays, family dinner on weekends.

Located in the center of the financial district of Santo Domingo.
Calle Andres Julio Aybar esquina Winston Churchill, acceso de calle en Acropolis Tower, Valet Parking.

Live music on Wednesday.
Salon Privado hasta 30 Personas.

Top review

Alvaro

Dined on Mar 29, 2025

Currently, Santino is hands down one of the best restaurants in Santo Domingo. Excellent food and service in a beautifully decorated space.

Zozo’s at Caneel Bay

4.8

4.8 (1025)

$50 and over

Italian

St. John

About the restaurant

CHILDREN UNDER FIVE ARE NOT PERMITTED *
CHILDREN WILL BE CHARGED IN FULL *
ZOZO'S DOES NOT OFFER A CHILDREN'S MENU *
ZOZO'S DOES NOT OFFER A VEGAN OPTION *
Seatings are at 5:30, 6:00, 6:30, 7:00, 7:30 and 8:00 P.M. The lounge opens for cocktails at 5:00 P.M.
If your reservation request is not available through the on-line reservation system,
the dining room is fully booked.
Reservations for the sunset dining experience are taken up to 30 days in advance.
The cost is $135 per person. ZoZo's also accepts reservations at the bar for parties of two.
Bar reservations may order à la carte from the evening's menu.
A reservation confirmation is an agreement to the terms and conditions of Zozo's cancellation policy.
Credit card information will be held, not charged, at the time of reservation.
Any cancellations made inside of 48 hours of your reservation time
will be charged $135 per person plus 20% gratuity.

Top review

Peter

Dined 4 days ago

Terrific food and atmosphere. Bar tenders were super

Ristorante Pappagallo

4.8

4.8 (516)

$31 to $50

Italian

West Bay

About the restaurant

For parties exceeding 10 people or for additional availability, please contact us at 949-1119 or email us at manager@pappagallo.ky.
Whatever the occasion, Pappagallo provides the perfect setting to satisfy all your senses. From the moment you step onto the wooden bridge leading to the entrance you are transported into another world. We offer several dining options, but it is the spectacular details of our 30-foot Cayman-style, Silver Thatch roof that is truly breathtaking! Under the inspired guardianship of Chef Alex Menegon who demands freshness of food as an absolute priority, the contemporary cuisine at Pappagallo is typified by its simplicity and freshness with Italian daily homemade pastas. Chef Alex uses as much locally caught seafood as is available and only the best of USDA Certified meats are offered; For the sweets-lover, a dessert menu starring only handcrafted desserts. So, sit back, relax and enjoy one of the best dining experiences in Grand Cayman!

Top review

Michael

Dined on Apr 23, 2025

Wonderful food and service. Totally professional staff. Amazing choice of dishes. It is a high end restaurant but ample amount of food on your plate. Tough on US diners with the devaluation of the dollar but worth the visit

Tonino's Osteria

4.6

4.6 (34)

$30 and under

Italian

Nassau

About the restaurant

Indulge in the authentic charm of Tonino's Osteria, Nassau's premier Italian restaurant, where locals and tourists alike converge for a culinary journey filled with vibrant flavors and a lively ambiance. With a menu crafted from the freshest ingredients, our dishes promise bold and inspiring tastes, reflecting our commitment to high-quality dining. Proudly serving the Nassau community for over five years, Tonino's Osteria is more than a restaurant; it's a destination where every meal is a celebration. Join us for an extraordinary experience, blending skillful cooking, inviting surroundings, and the rich traditions of Italian cuisine. Let Tonino's Osteria elevate your dining to new heights, where each visit becomes a cherished memory in the heart of Nassau's culinary haven. 🍝🍷🇮🇹

Top review

SkipVIP

Dined on Apr 16, 2025

Outstanding authentic dinner. Service was superb and the food was delicious. Highly recommended

Grappa

4.7

4.7 (41)

$31 to $50

Italian

Dorado

About the restaurant

Quaint local eatery, serving refined Italian cuisine.

Top review

jessicaVIP

Dined on Apr 9, 2025

Absolutely amazing. Better than the restaurants at the Ritz Carlton reserve nearby.

La Pizzarra

4.8

4.8 (23)

$30 and under

Italian

Santurce

About the restaurant

For those who challenge the ordinary and embrace the unknown, welcome to La Pizzarra and Katsubowl headed and crafted by Chef Escobar.

Here, we don’t follow predefined recipes. Instead, we fuse the best of Italy and Asia, breaking boundaries to create a universe of bold, authentic, and surprising flavors.

We are not just a pizzeria or an Asian-inspired concept. We are a destination for those who think differently, who find beauty in the unexpected, and who elevate the everyday into something extraordinary.

From our handcrafted Neapolitan pizzas to crudos, sushi, and noodles inspired by Asia, every dish tells a story of passion, creativity, and courage.

Dare to feel, taste, and discover. This is a space for the curious, for those with a taste for the extraordinary.

Visit us at La Parada 23 in Santurce, across from Cobian’s Plaza and steps from Centro de Bellas Artes.

Top review

Yui

Dined 2 days ago

Excellent food and service. Definitely will recommend to everyone!

Discover more

Experience

Katsubowl

Bucatini Market & Cucina

4.5

4.5 (17)

$31 to $50

Italian

Aruba

About the restaurant

Discover the true essence of Italy at Bucatini, where tradition and simplicity come together for an unforgettable dining experience. Our carefully crafted menu celebrates classic Italian flavors with recipes passed down through generations.

From handmade, aromatic fresh pasta to our wood-fired pizzas, every dish is made with the freshest, highest-quality ingredients. The menu includes antipasti, creamy risottos, and traditional desserts like irresistible tiramisu, all inspired by the love for authentic Italian cuisine.

With a warm, family-friendly atmosphere, we invite you to enjoy a meal that will transport you straight to a trattoria in the heart of Italy. Come share special moments and celebrate the beauty of simplicity and authenticity. We look forward to welcoming you with open arms and a great glass of wine!

Top review

frankVIP

Dined on Apr 23, 2025

Fabulous dinner. Highly recommend!! The lasagne was amazing!

Tavola Condado Trattoria Local

4.7

4.7 (198)

$30 and under

Italian

San Juan

About the restaurant

Tavola trattoria is a very cozy place in the heart of Condado, Puerto Rico with delicious homemade Italian dishes. Our menu included artisan pizzettas, fresh seafood, risottos and homemade pasta everyday with fresh ingredients.
You need to try our famous appetizers like Carpaccio di Manzo, eggplant involtini, truffle mac & cheese, Manchego croquettes and fry burrata. Tavola also have our customers favorites like the half boneless chicken al Forno and the carbonara pasta. Don't forget to try the creme brulé and the chocolate cake.

Top review

Kristina

Dined 3 days ago

Food was great ! Vibe was awesome! Experience top notch def would recommend!

Pesce Italian

4.7

4.7 (1409)

$30 and under

Italian

St Thomas

About the restaurant

Fresh Seafood ~ Homemade Pasta ~ Local Ingredients
Step outside of St Thomas and into Tuscany when you dine at PESCE iTALiAN. Offering the best in fresh In-House made Pasta, as it is made daily at our live action pasta station! The PESCE iTALiAN menu reflects the culinary sensibilities of the Italian people: rustic yet sophisticated.
Creative blends of herbs and spices, with a fusion of fresh ingredients and local seafood adds a contemporary twist to the elements of creating phenomenal Italian cuisine that has proudly served the East End of St Thomas for over a decade. Of course, another building block in creating the perfect experience is the friendly, dedicated staff that is knowledgeable of the beautiful relationship between food and wine – served with the warmth and hospitality of the Italian people. Our Wine Spectators Award Winning List is sure to offer many options to pair the perfect wine with any of the Italian delicacies on menu.

Top review

Sam

Dined 5 days ago

Excellent food and service. Convenient location in Red Hook. Very nice staff and a varied menu with pasta, seafood, vegetarian and meat options. Highly recommended even if it does not have sea views.

Discover more

Popular dish

Spaghetti Carbonara

Popular dish

Spaghetti & Meatballs

Popular dish

Rigatoni Bolognese

Explore Diners' Choice best of Caribbean