Diners' Choice: Best Overall restaurants in Caribbean

OpenTable

Updated June 05, 2025

Looking for the best overall restaurants in Caribbean? You’re in the right place. Each month, OpenTable analyzes nearly 2 million global diner reviews from the past four months. We sort the results by location and category to help you discover new favorite restaurants. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

Epicuro

5.0

5 (120)

$50 and over

Global, International

Condado

About the restaurant

True to its name, the Chef’s Table feels gloriously indulgent, inviting lucky diners on a hedonistic journey encapsulating Antonio Pérez’s life in Puerto Rico and his culinary career across South America, Europe, and Asia. The setting feels intimate and wildly special, with just 12 seats surrounding the open kitchen, complemented by a lounge area for a welcome cava before dinner or a post-tasting menu digestif. The themed-driven five-course menu changes monthly along with its wine pairing.
This is not merely another dining experience; it’s an intimate journey through the heart and soul of a Puerto Rican cook and his global culinary influences. Do not reserve a number of diners higher than desired, in our kitchen everything is prepared for all confirmed reservations, as such, we will regard it as a no show who has failed to comply with the reservation. If you wish to cancel your reservation, please give us at least three day’s notice. Thank you for your kindness and understanding.

Top review

Karen

Dined on May 30, 2025

Amazing! Excellent service, outstanding food!!!!!!

Discover more

Experience

Chef's Table (Wednesday)

Experience

Chef's Table (Thursday)

Experience

Chef's Table (Friday)

Piñangó Asian Bistro

5.0

5 (31)

$31 to $50

Sushi

Caguas

About the restaurant

A space to enjoy good sushi and various Asian dishes. Cozy place, with the "open kitchen" concept and an intimate atmosphere. Served by its owners.

Top review

ANNABELLEVIP

Dined 2 days ago

We are big sushi lovers and discovered Piñangó, a hidden gem that we will certainly visit again. It is very small sushi bistro in Caguas, but it is BIG in flavors! We were seated in front of the chef who was very sweet and explained to us all of our questions and informed us of the specials. All of our appetizers looked so good that we tried four of them: dumplings, fried chicken bao buns, fried eggplant, and the hamachi special. Not only did they look great, they tasted spectacular! We also ordered three different sushi rolls (can't remember the names) which were all wonderful. The sushi rolls were very fresh and the chef very creative. My husband and I will definitely be back and we surely inform our friends of this wonderful sushi bistro. Your palate will not be disappointed.

NOVA

5.0

5 (65)

$31 to $50

Mediterranean

West Bay

About the restaurant

NOVA offers an idyllic and inspired dining experience on the stunning shores of the Cayman Islands. Nestled on the north shore of West Bay, this beachfront gem serves a unique blend of Mediterranean-Japanese fusion cuisine, offering delicious, hearty dishes paired with innovative cocktails. With its open-air setting, NOVA provides the perfect backdrop for a laid-back yet elegant dining experience. Enjoy a refreshing poolside lunch, followed by handcrafted cocktails on the beach, or savor a sunset dinner with picture-perfect ocean views. This dog-friendly restaurant features an outdoor patio by the ocean, making it the ideal spot to gather with friends and family. Whether you're seeking delicious food by the sea or a memorable sunset experience, NOVA offers a one-of-a-kind atmosphere in West Bay.

Top review

MeganVIP

Dined 1 day ago

First, Maria and the entire team were fantastic and the view for a sunset dinner is tough to beat. Everything we had was delicious and perfectly prepared, especially the Branzino for two. It’s the best Branzino I’ve ever had and I’ve had a few. Don’t miss the rum Negroni or the wahoo ceviche too. Cheers!

BLT Steak NY at the St. Regis Bermuda Resort

4.9

4.9 (217)

$50 and over

Steakhouse

St. George's

About the restaurant

BLT Steak showcases a contemporary steakhouse fare with inspiring ingredients in a modern yet contemporary setting. Savor the finest classic steak cuts alongside a generous selection of fresh seafood, signature salads along with an upscale cocktail’s menu while taking in the exquisite ocean view scene.

We look forward to serving you!

Note: Outside seating base upon only on availability and on arriving times

Top review

PATRICKVIP

Dined on Jun 5, 2025

Food and service were great, just a high premium due to the location...which is to be expected. Dining costs on the island are high across the board, but this was the best meal start to finish that we've had so far.

L’Escale

5.0

5 (17)

$31 to $50

French

Nevis

About the restaurant

Transport yourself to the French Antilles without having to fly. L'Escale, a French Caribbean bistro, opens for lunch and dinner with a wide variety of specialty and classic cocktails, French inspired menu with all your favourites, snails, salad nicoise, mussels and more! Perched on top of the water with panoramic views to St. Kitts, with an unbeatable sunset and beautiful trade winds. Beautifully decorated indoor and outdoor seating, as well as a comfy bar for whatever your evening desires.

Only a short minute drive or five minute walk from the water taxi.

Top review

KimVIP

Dined on Apr 26, 2025

Wonderful evening at L’Escale last night. The ambience is truly spectacular and the food was excellent. Best bartender on the island! Very creative and delicious cocktails! Wait staff were friendly and attentive as well. So easy and quick to get over from St.Kitts on the ferry from Reggae Beach. Highly recommend and can’t wait to go back!

GD Cakes

5.0

5 (20)

$30 and under

Breakfast

Gobernador Piñero

About the restaurant

GD Cakes is a European-inspired bakery and brunch restaurant that has been delighting customers with its exceptional baked goods and culinary creations for over a decade. It features a classic-chic space with luxurious touches.

At the core of GD Cakes success is a passionate team of skilled bakers, pastry chefs, and culinary experts who are dedicated to crafting the finest cakes, pastries, and brunch dishes. Using only the freshest, locally-sourced ingredients and family recipes made from scratch and baked daily, they meticulously prepare each item ensuring that every bite is a symphony of flavor and texture.

GD Cakes is the destination for unforgettable culinary experiences.

Top review

Nancy

Dined on May 17, 2025

The food and service was wonderful. The food, coffee, and drinks were top notch.

Highbourne

4.9

4.9 (82)

$31 to $50

Mediterranean

Exumas

About the restaurant

For general inquiries and group bookings please call the restaurant at 1.242.824.4563 or email xuma@highbourne-exumas.com.

Group bookings are parties of 12 or more guests, please note that group bookings will be required to dine from one of our shared set menus and require a credit card authorization form to secure reservations, all details available on inquiry.

Please kindly note, Xuma Restaurant is closed on Tuesdays.

Top review

Jennifer

Dined on Jun 8, 2025

Beautiful restaurant and amazing atmosphere! Just lucky to be able to be here on this wonderful island!

The Clubhouse at Bitter End Yacht Club

4.9

4.9 (43)

$50 and over

Farm-to-table

Virgin Gorda

About the restaurant

Established in 1969, our Clubhouse has been a sought-after destination for seafarers for over 50 years. Our open-air dining room is a stunning blend of tropical and nautical elements surrounded by seaside outdoor seating. Join visitors from around the globe and enjoy breathtaking views of the North Sound as you experience our sea-to-table menu, which features fresh-catch seafood and locally sourced produce from Virgin Islands farms.

We serve breakfast, lunch and dinner daily. Reservations are required to secure a table.

Whether you're seeking a romantic dinner for two or a memorable group dining experience, our Clubhouse is the ideal location for your BVI dining experience.

Top review

MaryVIP

Dined on Jun 6, 2025

We had a wonderful meal with lots of fresh seafood and amazing servers! Would go back!

Marmalade Restaurant & Wine Bar

4.9

4.9 (7951)

$50 and over

Fusion / Eclectic

San Juan

About the restaurant

Please note Marmalade only offers tasting menus, we do not offer children's menu or a la carte.

GROUPS OF 5 OR LESS, 5 course dinner. All guests pay full price including children, price is per seat.

GROUPS OF 6 OR MORE, Fixed Group tasting menu . All guests pay full price including children, price is per seat.

Marmalade does not accept Discover credit cards

Top review

JulianVIP

Dined 6 days ago

Santi was the best server. Friendly, professional, knowledgeable about the menu and wines, and a great sense of humor. Food was all incredible. One thing we appreciated about the restaurant was how the interior decor softened the noise significantly. Made for a great dining experience. We will be back to Puerto Rico just to come here again!

Discover more

4.9

4.9 (13)

$50 and over

Cocktail Bar