Best Restaurants in Montauk

Best American Restaurants in Montauk

Muse at the end

(324)

$$$$

American | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Tillie's

(52)

$$$$

American | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Highway Restaurant and Bar

(340)

$$$$

American | East Hampton, Long Island / Hamptons

Coach Grill & Tavern

(87)

$$$$

American | Oyster Bay, Long Island / Hamptons

Heirloom Tavern

(638)

$$$$

American | Glen Head, Long Island / Hamptons

Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar, Huntington, NY

(3681)

$$$$

American | Huntington, Long Island / Hamptons

Vine Street Cafe

(853)

$$$$

American | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

Cove Hollow Tavern

(63)

$$$$

American | East Hampton, Long Island / Hamptons

The Jamesport Manor Inn

(1216)

$$$$

American | Riverhead, Long Island / Hamptons

red/bar brasserie

(449)

$$$$

American | Southampton, Long Island / Hamptons

George Martin The Original

(1452)

$$$$

American | Rockville Centre, Long Island / Hamptons

OHEKA Bar & Restaurant

(1095)

$$$$

American | Huntington, Long Island / Hamptons

Swallow Restaurant

(600)

$$$$

American | Huntington, Long Island / Hamptons

Sandbar

(609)

$$$$

American | Cold Spring Harbor, Long Island / Hamptons

Almond - Bridgehampton

(857)

$$$$

American | Bridgehampton, Long Island / Hamptons

Sullivan's Quay

(45)

$$$$

American | Port Washington, Long Island / Hamptons

Mill Pond House

(1673)

$$$$

American | Centerport, Long Island / Hamptons

Best Italian Restaurants in Montauk

Scarpetta Beach

(400)

$$$$

Italian | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

La Fine - Montauk

(121)

$$$$

Italian | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

The Trattoria

(721)

$$$$

Italian | St. James, Long Island / Hamptons

King Umberto Restaurant

(688)

$$$$

Italian | Elmont, Long Island / Hamptons

Trattoria DiMeo

(298)

$$$$

Italian | Roslyn, Long Island / Hamptons

Sant Ambroeus - Southampton

(92)

$$$$

Italian | Southampton, Long Island / Hamptons

Tutto Il Giorno - Southampton

(146)

$$$$

Italian | Hamptons, Long Island / Hamptons

La Ginestra - NY

(165)

$$$$

Italian | Glen Cove, Long Island / Hamptons

Ciro's Italian Restaurant - Kings Park

(392)

$$$$

Italian | Kings Park, Long Island / Hamptons

18 Bay

(397)

$$$$

Italian | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

Cipollini Trattoria and Bar

(751)

$$$$

Italian | Manhasset, Long Island / Hamptons

Uva Rossa

(428)

$$$$

Italian | Malverne, Long Island / Hamptons

Piccolo Restaurant of Huntington

(813)

$$$$

Italian | Huntington, Long Island / Hamptons

Il Luogo Ristorante

(688)

$$$$

Italian | Rockville Centre, Long Island / Hamptons

Andrea's 25 of Commack

(703)

$$$$

Italian | Commack, Long Island / Hamptons

Treat your taste buds: Explore Montauk restaurants.

Montauk Restaurants

Scarpetta Beach

400 reviews

$$$$

Italian | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

He food and ambiance was great. Very romantic and lively if you want to party next door and dance. More
OpenTable Diner - 09/15/2018

Tillie's

52 reviews

$$$$

American | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Great food ,great service, beautiful place. Everything was top notch! More
OpenTable Diner - 08/19/2018

Navy Beach

263 reviews

$$$$

Seafood | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

We got there early and were seated early, the waitstaff was perfect the food was delicious. The view was beautiful. We plan on going back again and again, even though we live an hour and a half away. More
OpenTable Diner - 09/01/2018

Muse at the end

324 reviews

$$$$

American | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

great experience, wonderful service. I want to come back other times More
OpenTable Diner - 09/20/2018

Backyard Restaurant @ Solé East

156 reviews

$$$$

Mediterranean | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Excellent service, impeccable food! The mussels and the NY Stripe were fantastic. Definitely going tomorrow night for drinks around the fire pit!! More
OpenTable Diner - 09/05/2018

South Edison

515 reviews

$$$$

Seafood | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

One of our top Montauk dining spots. Always a well curated menu. It tends to be a bit loud (it is popular!) and the wait staff can be a bit rushed (they're busy!), but dont let that stop you. We make sure to dine there at least once per trip. More
OpenTable Diner - 09/17/2018

Grey Lady - Montauk

67 reviews

$$$$

Seafood | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Really enjoyed the Grey Lady in Montauk. Food was awesome, great service, super cool reggae band playing. Only minor quibble would be the drinks we ordered. Super expensive and REALLY weak and on the pricey side. Other than that this place is highly recommended. Drink beer! More
OpenTable Diner - 09/02/2018

32 Star at Gurney's Yacht Club

13 reviews

$$$$

Fusion / Eclectic | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Beautiful spot overlooking Montauk Harbor... we were there on a weekday evening after Labor Day, so it was pleasantly quiet. Service was impeccable, food was superb. We had Ahi tuna, iceberg wedge salad with blue cheese dressing and cheesecake for desert. We loved it, would recommend highly! More
OpenTable Diner - 09/13/2018

La Fine - Montauk

121 reviews

$$$$

Italian | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

I don't understand the negative reviews. We loved it. The food and the service were great and the setting was very charming. More
OpenTable Diner - 09/15/2018

Swallow East

71 reviews

$$$$

American | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Amazing food and service. More
OpenTable Diner - 04/29/2017

ALL DAY @ Breakers Montauk

Reviews Coming Soon

$$$$

Café | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

ALL DAY at Breakers offers guests casual dining with indoor + outdoor seating, poolside service (coming soon), a full bar, grab & go offerings, and (soon) a Beach Bites x Breakers to-go menu featuring online ordering.More

See All