Best American Restaurants in Montauk

View all

Best American Restaurants in Montauk

Popular restaurants in New York Area

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New York Area

HAVEN Riverfront Restaurant and Bar
(278)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Edgewater
Serafina 105
(116)
$$$$
Italian | Upper West Side
OFFER
View all New York Area restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Montauk restaurants.

Montauk Restaurants

32 Star at Gurney's Yacht Club32 Star at Gurney's Yacht Club
15 reviews
$$$$
Fusion / Eclectic | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Wife’s birthday More

OpenTable Diner -
Scarpetta BeachScarpetta Beach
424 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Our waitress was outstanding! Thanks for another great night at Scarpetta! More

OpenTable Diner -
Muse at the endMuse at the end
341 reviews
$$$$
American | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

My boyfriend and I had a great meal at this restaurant during the off season (January). Service was great, food was delicious, very enjoyable. Being one of the only restaurants in the area that is still open during the off season, it was packed for dinner. The only downside is that it was very noisy, so much so that we had to repeat ourselves to be heard over the chatter. There was a very large and loud group sitting in the center of the room that was responsible for most of the noise, but the acoustics of the room make it so all of the sounds echo and bounce off of the walls. It would be helpful to add some sort of texture/materials to the walls or floor to absorb some of the noise. More

OpenTable Diner -
Tillie'sTillie's
57 reviews
$$$$
American | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Nice place to enjoy a meal. Note that the prices on line menu are not what you find in the restaurant. The lobster roll listed at $25 is $35. The lobster crab cakes at $26 is actually one cake. But the food was good and the view of the ocean spectacular. More

OpenTable Diner -
La Fine - MontaukLa Fine - Montauk
124 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Small, cosy restaurant in historic Montauk Manor whose lobby is a spectacular example of '20s grandeur. The Italian menu is traditional but delicious with well-sourced local ingredients, especially the seafood. The ambiance is intimate and the service warm and friendly. For Montauk, where most of the restaurants charge outrageous prices, the value here is very good. More

OpenTable Diner -
Swallow EastSwallow East
71 reviews
$$$$
American | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Amazing food and service. More

OpenTable Diner -
ALL DAY @ Breakers MontaukALL DAY @ Breakers Montauk
Reviews Coming Soon
$$$$
Café | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

ALL DAY at Breakers offers guests casual dining with indoor + outdoor seating, poolside service (coming soon), a full bar, grab & go offerings, and (soon) a Beach Bites x Breakers to-go menu featuring online ordering.More