Best American Restaurants in Montauk
Price
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility
6 restaurants available nearby
How are Featured results ranked
How is content generated
See what locals rave about
- AAngelaVIPNew York City •2 reviews5.0Dined 2 days agoThe mussel appetizer dish was phenomenal, I’d recommend it to anyone!More infoMuse at the endPrice: Expensive• American• Montauk•4.6
- MMargauxNew York City •10 reviews5.0Dined 7 days agoAlways delicious. Great outdoor patio. Quick service with a smile. We had a fantastic breakfast for Mother’s Day. Everyone in our group enjoyed their meals.More infoBird on the RoofPrice: Moderate• American• Montauk•4.7
- AAmyVIPNew York City •86 reviews4.0Dined on Apr 26, 2025Love this restaurant. Been going for years. Food and drinks always good. My scallops could have been warmer. My husband loved his smash burger. Great waitress. Very limited menu. Maybe because it’s so early in the season? Not one salad offered and only a few entrees. So if you are a very fussy eater I’d check the menu on line before going.More infoSouth EdisonPrice: Expensive• Contemporary American• Montauk•4.2
- OTOpenTable DinerNew York State •2 reviews4.0Dined on Nov 29, 2024Wonderful food, attentive service, but very noisy. Cries out for a carpet or any sound abatement that might allow conversation at a table for 2 to4. Miss the old original Gurney’s corny Italian rococo decor that was a relief from the now ubiquitous “ zen”running to “ Amish “ look of un inviting plain colorless Uber simple gray fixtures. Looks as if it was decorated by Monks who have taken a vow of poverty. Art work is all black, gray and during late fall no view of gorgeous ocean after early sunset. No music either but the noise would drown it out anyway. Very pricey for teensy portions.More infoGigi'sPrice: Expensive• American• Montauk•4.5
- SSusanNew York State •1 review5.0Dined on Sep 7, 2024The owner, Leya, is so friendly and energetic. The wait staff is very friendly and accommodating. I'd mention my server, but I forget his name. Sorry because he was just awesome. Loved talking with him. The food, drinks and entertainment were great. Even surprise guest Jason Momoa promoting his vodka, Meili (which is fantastic!) was an added bonus. I honestly have nothing negative at all to say about Duke's. All around it was a great experience! Hope to return next summer.More infoDukesPrice: Expensive• American• Montauk•4.1
Discover best American restaurants in Montauk
Discover the essence of American cuisine in the charming town of Montauk, Suffolk, New York State, where the local dining scene thrives with a distinctive blend of traditional and innovative flavors. Montauk offers a variety of American dining experiences, from cozy, rustic settings to elegant, fine dining establishments, all imbued with the local spirit and ingredients sourced from the surrounding farms and waters. Each restaurant in Montauk is committed to delivering not only mouth-watering dishes but also an ambiance that complements the scenic beauty of this coastal town. Whether you're craving seafood freshly caught from the Atlantic, classic comfort foods, or culinary innovations, Montauk's American restaurants ensure a memorable gastronomic journey. The dining scene here is a vibrant reflection of Montauk's rich cultural tapestry, appealing to both locals and visitors alike. Enjoy a satisfying meal in Montauk, where every restaurant promises a unique taste of American hospitality and culinary excellence.