Best American Restaurants in Bay Harbor

Bennethum's Northern InnBennethum's Northern Inn
(56)
$$$$
American | Gaylord, Northern Michigan
Carriage House at Hotel IroquoisCarriage House at Hotel Iroquois
(76)
$$$$
American | Mackinac Island, Northern Michigan
1852 Grill Room1852 Grill Room
(102)
$$$$
American | Mackinac Island, Northern Michigan
Tracey'sTracey's
(35)
$$$$
American | Munising, Northern Michigan
Aerie Restaurant & LoungeAerie Restaurant & Lounge
(464)
$$$$
American | Acme, Northern Michigan
Booked 7 times today
Mary's Bistro Draught HouseMary's Bistro Draught House
(16)
$$$$
American | Mackinac Island, Northern Michigan

Best Italian Restaurants in Bay Harbor

FunistradaFunistrada
(500)
$$$$
Italian | Glen Arbor / Maple City, Northern Michigan
Booked 8 times today
PepeNero Ristorantino Italiano / Ballaro Wine LoungePepeNero Ristorantino Italiano / Ballaro Wine Lounge
(75)
$$$$
Italian | Traverse City, Northern Michigan
Booked 1 time today
ChiantiChianti
(53)
$$$$
Italian | Mackinac Island, Northern Michigan

Popular restaurants in Northern MI

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in Northern MI

Aerie Restaurant & Lounge
(70)
$$$$
American | Acme
PepeNero Ristorantino Italiano / Ballaro Wine Lounge
(117)
$$$$
Italian | Traverse City
Bennethum's Northern Inn
(227)
$$$$
American | Gaylord
View all Northern MI restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Bay Harbor restaurants.

Bay Harbor Restaurants

Vintage Chophouse l Wine BarVintage Chophouse l Wine Bar
89 reviews
$$$$
Steakhouse | Bay Harbor, Northern Michigan
Booked 2 times today

We came to meet friends we had not seen in years--to catch up, talk, and share particularly good food. The waitress was both attentive and sensitive to our need to talk. It was perfect! Thanks. Jane H. More

OpenTable Diner -

Discover Bay Harbor

Bay Harbor is a Michigan city in the Upper Peninsula with a number of dining options. Mediterranean food, especially, is popular in the Bay Harbor area. One can find various salads and fried fish flavored and spiced with feta cheese and much more. Those who are staying in the area have many breakfast options including hearty pancakes, thick meats, and various styles of homemade toast. However, those visiting the Upper Peninsula should try out some pasties. This unique dish is of Cornish origin and is a hand pie stuffed with meats, vegetables, and gravy. It is a Michigan specialty that is hard to find anywhere else.