Turtle Bay Restaurants

Really great experience. Service was personable and friendly. Food was outstanding. Price quality very good. Would go here again and again if I were to live in NYC More

OpenTable Diner - 12/29/2018

Excellent find in midtown for "old school" Italian. Fast service, pleasant host (? owner) who visited each table to check that everything was ok. Very unassuming store front but welcoming inside on a cold January weekend night. Recommend the Caesar Salad, fettuccine alfredo, and spaghetti and meatballs. Large portions with plenty of leftovers. Tiramisu was an excellent "to go" dessert at the end of the night. If you're a smaller group and can't get a reservation on Open Table, consider just showing up to eat at the bar. Will definitely go back the next time I'm visiting family in the area. More

OpenTable Diner - 01/11/2019