Best American Restaurants in Sanibel

Captiva HouseCaptiva House
(412)
$$$$
American | Captiva Island, Ft. Myers
Doc Ford’s – CaptivaDoc Ford’s – Captiva
(109)
$$$$
American | Captiva Island, Ft. Myers
McGregor CafeMcGregor Cafe
(64)
$$$$
American | Fort Myers, Ft. Myers
The StandardThe Standard
(151)
$$$$
American | Fort Myers, Ft. Myers
KC American BistroKC American Bistro
(858)
$$$$
American | Naples, Naples
Bistro 821Bistro 821
(3087)
$$$$
American | Naples, Naples
Cafe Lurcat - NaplesCafe Lurcat - Naples
(2710)
$$$$
American | Naples, Naples
Verdi's BistroVerdi's Bistro
(406)
$$$$
American | Marco Island, Marco Island
Mezzo - The Ritz-Carlton Golf Resort, NaplesMezzo - The Ritz-Carlton Golf Resort, Naples
(5)
$$$$
American | Naples, Naples
Stonewood Grill & Tavern - NaplesStonewood Grill & Tavern - Naples
(1299)
$$$$
American | Naples, Naples
Sam Snead's Tavern - Lely ResortSam Snead's Tavern - Lely Resort
(337)
$$$$
American | South Naples, Naples
Laishley Crab HouseLaishley Crab House
(2662)
$$$$
American | Punta Gorda, Punta Gorda
The Wine Loft- NaplesThe Wine Loft- Naples
(84)
$$$$
American | Naples, Naples

Best Italian Restaurants in Sanibel

Osteria TuliaOsteria Tulia
(1604)
$$$$
Italian | Naples, Naples
Campiello - NaplesCampiello - Naples
(4862)
$$$$
Italian | Naples, Naples
Angelina's RistoranteAngelina's Ristorante
(2412)
$$$$
Italian | Bonita Springs, Bonita Springs
Molto TrattoriaMolto Trattoria
(559)
$$$$
Italian | Naples, Naples
Pazzo! Italian CafePazzo! Italian Cafe
(2280)
$$$$
Italian | Naples, Naples
Da Vinci RistoranteDa Vinci Ristorante
(1181)
$$$$
Italian | Marco Island, Marco Island
Sophia's Ristorante ItalianoSophia's Ristorante Italiano
(833)
$$$$
Italian | Naples, Naples
Caffe MilanoCaffe Milano
(694)
$$$$
Italian | Naples, Naples
Cirella's an italian bistro & sushi bar - Bonita SpringsCirella's an italian bistro & sushi bar - Bonita Springs
(1149)
$$$$
Italian | Bonita Springs, Bonita Springs
Bice - NaplesBice - Naples
(1657)
$$$$
Italian | Naples, Naples
Alberto's on FifthAlberto's on Fifth
(1534)
$$$$
Italian | Naples, Naples
Sale e Pepe - Marco Beach Ocean ResortSale e Pepe - Marco Beach Ocean Resort
(987)
$$$$
Italian | Marco Island, Marco Island
BarbatellaBarbatella
(1102)
$$$$
Italian | Naples, Naples
Trattoria AbruzzoTrattoria Abruzzo
(800)
$$$$
Italian | Naples, Naples

Popular restaurants in Naples

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in Naples

Ruth's Chris Steak House - Bonita Springs
(293)
$$$$
Steakhouse | Bonita Springs
South Fork Grille
(325)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Estero
The Saloon
(210)
$$$$
Steak | Bonita Springs
View all Naples restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Sanibel restaurants.

Sanibel Restaurants

Il Cielo - SanibelIl Cielo - Sanibel
986 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Sanibel, Ft. Myers

Excellent food and phenomenal staff. Andre was our server, he exceeded our expectations and made the evening truly special. More

OpenTable Diner -
Sweet Melissa's CafeSweet Melissa's Cafe
1602 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Sanibel, Ft. Myers

Perfect from the cheese plate to the entrees! Delicious interpretation on standard fare. Try the miso-glazed scallops or the Osso Buco. Amazing! More

OpenTable Diner -
Shima at The Sundial Beach ResortShima at The Sundial Beach Resort
268 reviews
$$$$
Japanese | Sanibel, Ft. Myers

Service was superb. Chef made the experience fun. The sushi (which two in our party ordered) was pronounced by them as excellent. My husband ordered the chicken entree & I ordered the beef. Both were excellent.We will definitely go back again. More

OpenTable Diner -
Thistle Lodge RestaurantThistle Lodge Restaurant
834 reviews
$$$$
Fusion / Eclectic | Sanibel, Ft. Myers

We were away on vacation. We wanted a quiet charming restaurant away from hustle bustle. We found it ten times over. We loved everything More

OpenTable Diner -
Sea Breeze CafeSea Breeze Cafe
83 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Sanibel, Ft. Myers

Great food, excellent service with ocean view, what else do you need? More

OpenTable Diner -
Normandie Seaside Cafe at West Wind InnNormandie Seaside Cafe at West Wind Inn
Reviews Coming Soon
$$$$
Seafood | Sanibel, Ft. Myers

The Normandie is located at the West Wind Inn and is known as the best kept secret on the island. the restaurant serve breakfast , lunch and dinner every day, the ambiance is very relaxing and the menu offer choices for everybody. The restaurant is very casual and welcomes families .make sure you reserve for dinner because it fills up quickly.More

Sanibel Diners' Choice Winners

Sanibel's best restaurants based upon thousands of OpenTable diner reviews
Il Cielo - SanibelIl Cielo - Sanibel
986 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Sanibel, Ft. Myers

Excellent food and phenomenal staff. Andre was our server, he exceeded our expectations and made the evening truly special. More

OpenTable Diner -
Sweet Melissa's CafeSweet Melissa's Cafe
1602 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Sanibel, Ft. Myers

Perfect from the cheese plate to the entrees! Delicious interpretation on standard fare. Try the miso-glazed scallops or the Osso Buco. Amazing! More

OpenTable Diner -
Shima at The Sundial Beach ResortShima at The Sundial Beach Resort
268 reviews
$$$$
Japanese | Sanibel, Ft. Myers

Service was superb. Chef made the experience fun. The sushi (which two in our party ordered) was pronounced by them as excellent. My husband ordered the chicken entree & I ordered the beef. Both were excellent.We will definitely go back again. More

OpenTable Diner -
Thistle Lodge RestaurantThistle Lodge Restaurant
834 reviews
$$$$
Fusion / Eclectic | Sanibel, Ft. Myers

We were away on vacation. We wanted a quiet charming restaurant away from hustle bustle. We found it ten times over. We loved everything More

OpenTable Diner -
Sea Breeze CafeSea Breeze Cafe
83 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Sanibel, Ft. Myers

Great food, excellent service with ocean view, what else do you need? More

OpenTable Diner -

Discover Sanibel

There's a little piece of paradise just off of Fort Myers, Florida where you can nap in a hammock between the palms under a vibrant blue sky. It's a seashell collector's dream. Restaurants here serve some of Sanibel's most delectable dining options. Most places are quaint little island affairs with delicious shrimp, savory crab, grilled fish and other seafood, but there are also more upscale seafood specialists with views over the ocean. There is a place for every taste on the island. For some land-based options, visit a local steakhouse or savor Mexican or French cuisine at one of Sanibel's locally owned establishments. End your evening with some freshly made ice cream or gelato by the beach.