Best Comfort Food Restaurants in Shelter Island / San Diego Bay

Food, drinks and atmosphere was amazing. We'll be back to try other dishes, hats off to the chef!

Incredible, inventive and absolutely delicious menu. There were four of us and we had four starter and four entrees and everything was excellent. Our waitress was enthusiastic about the menu choices and attentive. The space itself is gorgeous. Highly recommend - a real treat.

This was the first visit to this hotel and restaurant. We had breakfasts twice and overall pleased with the experience. It was interesting having breakfast potatoes that included 4 or 5 kinds, including sweet potatoes. The most highest price item was eggs, potatoes, meat choice and toast and...See More

Great views, great food. Never been disappointed..

Amazing Food. Amazing Service. Amazing View! Could not ask for anything better.

Massive outdoor space. Loved the QR ordering and that you could close your tab from the table. Stone’s beers did not disappoint!

My wife and I dined here for dinner on our 35th wedding anniversary. It was wonderful. Spectacular view, great food, excellent service. It reminded us of our days in Hawaii. Thank you.

Came here for a date night! Absolutely loved the ambiance. Such a beautiful view of the water and the star of India. The server was friendly and quick plus the food was amazing ! Highly recommend

DO NOT MISS THIS. I am biased... I truly love El Agave. I discovered the amazing and subtle flavors of Moles and surprising Mexican cuisine there. They introduced me to a world of tequila and mezcal that were to be shipped and enjoyed. There staff is great and very knowledable.

Dining experience was great with the exception of having a adjacent table using a speaker phone during our dinner experience.