Best Casual Restaurants in Middleton

72 restaurants available nearby

Ruth's Chris Steak House - Middleton1. Ruth's Chris Steak House - Middleton0.12 mi
(671 reviews)
$$$$
Steakhouse | Madison,

"Food was amazing tasted outstanding and the dessert was wonderful(Strawberry shortcake) was divine the steak that I had ordered medium rare came out perfectly and the temperature was perfect and the shrimp was outstanding.We'll go there definitely again and again Amazing job over all. Server Ismael was GREAT"See more

Johnny's Italian Steakhouse - Middleton2. Johnny's Italian Steakhouse - Middleton0.17 mi
(293 reviews)
$$$$
Steakhouse | Middleton,

"It was not busy, and we sat in a comfortable booth. Our server was polite and attentive. Everything was delicious"See more

Point Burger Bar - Middleton3. Point Burger Bar - Middleton0.4 mi
(12 reviews)
$$$$
American | Madison,

"Great build your own burger! Service was very friendly and attentive. A little pricey but a good experience."See more

Villa Dolce4. Villa Dolce0.74 mi
(423 reviews)
$$$$
Italian | Middleton,

"We love Villa Dolce...great food, ambience and service in happening downtown Middleton. It's always a treat."See more

Vin Santo- Wisconsin5. Vin Santo- Wisconsin0.78 mi
(883 reviews)
$$$$
Italian | Middleton,

"We are regular Vin Santo customers and we have never been disappointed. Always great food and service."See more

Benvenutos - Middleton6. Benvenutos - Middleton0.96 mi
(73 reviews)
$$$$
Italian | Madison,

"Good food. No issues"See more

Eno Vino Wine Bar and Bistro7. Eno Vino Wine Bar and Bistro1.57 mi
(1054 reviews)
$$$$
Tapas / Small Plates | Madison,

"Food was delicious and the restaurant itself was beautiful. Will definitely be returning."See more

1847 at The Stamm House8. 1847 at The Stamm House1.73 mi
(18 reviews)
$$$$
Bistro | Middleton,

"The food was all delicious. I ordered the pan fried perch. A couple suggestions would be to have that it is flour dredged on the description. It also needed a little seasoning. Steaks were awesome! Carrot cake was also amazing."See more

Imperial Garden9. Imperial Garden2.11 mi
(235 reviews)
$$$$
Chinese | Middleton,

"Food was great. Our waitress was expected to handle too many tables"See more

Captain Bill's - Middleton10. Captain Bill's - Middleton2.17 mi
(979 reviews)
$$$$
American | Middleton,

"I went to captain bills with my husband for our anniversary. They were not very busy and we were able to get a table outside. They had acoustic music which was a pleasant surprise. The atmosphere was great. The food ended up being amazing and it was fairly priced. Unfortunately our service was really slow. The waiter seemed like he might have been the manager or owner. He wore many hats (waiter, bartender, lighting tiki torches) and was running around very busy. But that meant that we got little attention. He was very nice when he did stop by, but he completely forgot to bring out soup before the meal. I think he did the same to the table next to us as I heard him bring out shrimp at the end of the meal and say “better late than never”. We weren’t in a hurry luckily because the meal took almost 2 hours. He took drinks off of our bill to apologize and again he was very nice. But we didn’t understand why another waiter could have helped instead as no one else seemed as busy as he was. Everything else was great and the food was amazing! We will go back but hopefully they will be better staffed."See more