Best Italian Restaurants in Wailea

Mike our server was AMAZING!!! Very attentive as well as other staff members of Matteo's. Had the Butternut Squash Ravioli and it was the BEST ravioli I have ever had! The homemade past makes all the difference and the amount of butternut squash they put in the ravioli is a good portion and did not make the ravioli soggy at all. Also had the Fettuccine Frutti Di Mare and let me just say "chef's kiss" this dish was also outstanding, the bounty of the ocean is showcased with crab, shrimp, and clams. The flavor profiles were wonderful and I can see why they do not put salt/pepper on the tables, you will not need it for any of the food at Matteo's because the luxurious seafood infused sauce, light yet decadent, where the brine of the ocean meets the richness of culinary precision. What sets this sea food dish apart from others is the balance with enough richness to dance on the palate without overpowering the sea's natural sweetness. The presentation is as elegant as it's flavors. The plating is minimalist yet thoughtful - a testament to the chef's philosophy of letting quality ingredients shine. This dish transforms a simple plate of past into a profound culinary journey. It's not just a dish; its a love letter to the ocean and a triumph of Italian cuisine. This is a neighborhood gem and can see why he won Maui's Best Chef!!! If you want quality, fresh, food with exceptional service, go to Matteo's!

We have dined at Cassanovas many times. Never disappointed. The food is great. service is consistently good. Highly recommend this restaurant is you like good pasta.

It was a lovely dinner. It started with buratta salad and then the fresh catch. It had nice music playing and a very friendly bar tender. We loved it.

Great selection of food with a beautiful ambiance! Will definitely be going back!

Absolutely wonderful! Beautiful views of sunset! The chicken piccata was a wonderfully surrounded by a variety of hearty mushrooms which made for a delicious and interesting take on the original. The Lobster pizza was brilliant with infinitely more lobster than you would have assumed! Drinks are creative and delicious. Service staff is top notch and accommodating. They don’t miss a beat, while simultaneously somehow never interrupting.