The Pewter Mug

Food and service (Chet) were superior. We were seated in a booth as requested, but it was beside the middle of the salad bar and all the coming and going of patrons and suppliers was quite distracting. The openness required by the salad bar adversely affected the "ambiance"...
I will definitely be going back for the quality of the food and especially the Prime Rib, but I now know to request a different location.

Great place for prime rib, beef stroganoff, sea scallops, salad bar (or specialty salads for those not wanting to go through the salad bar). If you go through the salad bar, you must wear disposable gloves and a mask (which I liked). Not a fancy place, but nice enough.

The Pewter Mug offers a menu that rivals some of the better restaurants in Naples in a casual, open atmosphere. We started with the escargot appetizer which was served steaming hot and was delicious with the asiago cheese topping. The Mug's soup & salad bar is available and a favorite of my husband's. He commented on how good the clam chowder was. We shared the seared sea scallop with risotto entree which was very tasty and plenty for two of us. We plan to take friends there when they visit.

Good value

I think that The Pewter Mug serves the best prime rib in southwest Florida. The salad bar is pretty impressive too. I always have an enjoyable meal every time I go there.

Great food! Great service! Jaime, Colleen and Cindy are wonderful!!!

Food and service (server Seth) great. Prime rib perfectly prepared, delicious. Not a fan of salad bars and there was no other option, i.e. fresh veg, especially during COVID, it was very crowded, maybe try again after Season.

New location is very nice. Good COVID protocols. Service was excellent food was very good and affordable. We will go back.

Good experience

We had a great dinner to celebrate my mother's 88th birthday! Our server made the occasion extra special with her careful attentiveness. The food, especially the prime rib and ribeye steak, were fantastic. The salad bar is wonderful, too!

The blackened prime rib is outstanding!

We are new in town and looking for decent prime rib. Pewter Mug delivered.
Wendy was super. The gin/tonics were a bit wimpy, however. Salad bar was great!
Thank you.

Unbelievable food. Horrendous service. Had reservations and we were seated a couple of minutes late, as is expected on New Years Eve (about 6:45). Didn't see anyone for another 29 minutes (7:15). No menu's, no water, no drink orders, nothing.

Its unfortunate when an establishment knows they are going to be at capacity and don't have enough help to make things flow smoothly.

My prime rib was excellent and will go again for that. Otherwise, they need do fix whatever was wrong.

Very friendly service; salad bar was outstanding and food was cooked to order with fine quality product.

Nice atmosphere, great salad bar and great service. Lots of food choices and our meals were great. Will go there again..

We had a great dinner. Service was excellent and the salmon and prime rib were made to perfection. This was our first time there and will not be our last!

Great food and service! One of our top 3 restaurants we like to dine at in the area.

Food is always good, never a bad experience, luv salad bar, a favorite when in Florida. See you in 2021. John was a fabulous server!

We had the prime rib and the filet. Both taste terrific. My prime was a little cold when it got to the table. The salad bar was stocked full and the soups were very good. I would go there again. The value was good

We had an early Christmas Eve dinner of prime rib. It was top-notch in its preparation, just a perfectly cooked cut of meat. Service was friendly and timed well for delivery of our entrees. Pewter Mug is our favorite restaurant in FL.

We had a wonderful meal. I had French Dip, my husband had Shrimp Carbonera. Yummy. Stephanie was our server, she was attentive and very sweet. Decor needs updating but it's clean and quiet. Will definitely return.

Tables were spaced apart and you had to wear gloves snd your mask to go to salad bar. I felt it was a very safe dining experience. The food was outstanding!

Service and food were great!!

Great food! Great service! Cindy, Jaime and Colleen are terrific! Consistently good!!!

The best Prime Rib anywhere we have ever eaten!!!!

We love The Pewter Mug because they offer out-of-the-ordinary cuisine without the high prices associated with elevated presentation. They always have prime rib. But my favorite is usually a fish special, served on a bed of risotto or cheesy grits or something similar, with perfectly prepared vegetables. The salad bar is excellent, but the prepared salads are outstanding: mostly recently I had a beet salad with orange segments, and a wedge of romaine with hard-boiled egg and bleu cheese. Our favorite restaurant in the Naples/ Bonita area!

The food was exceptional. The server while friendly showed little interest and the salad bar lacked in choices of bread and soup.

Four of us ordered the Thanksgiving day special meal which was very good and we all had enough leftover to have another meal. The only disappointing part of the special was that it did not include a piece of pumpkin pie which would have been nice as part of the special. We did order desserts to split and it was all very delicious. Would eat our Thanksgiving meal there again.

The food was tasty but no real fluff to the limited menu. Service was good. Seth the bartender was our server. He was friendly and attentive. The place just seemed to lack the extra pizazz but would probably go again and sit at the bar for a quick dinner and drink.

Hadn’t been to this new location since the restaurant moved. Very nice ambiance. Food was very good as well as service. Best salad bar in Naples! Lots to choose from.

Always great

The filet was tasteless and chewy..... the salad bar was a mess and what is that brown sauce in the FRENCH DRESSING spot at the salad bar? The bread and rolls were never re-filled,,,, none there after we got 1..... been to the Pewter mug over 30 times and it used to be very good,,, this night was Not good....

I had the fish and chips and the fish was excellent. Light flaky batter and non greasy. I opted for the baked potato rather than fries.
Only downside is during COVID Florida is allowing 100% occupancy in restaurants. It’s ridiculous to have people sitting that close together.

food is always good, services friendly and efficient, and salad bar is great

excellent escargot!

Prime Rib was awesome! Service was amazing! It is hard to find good Prime Rib in Naples.

very nice establishment , great for special occasions. very nice cocktail lounge
would highly recommend, service is second to none

We felt the salad bar was the best part of the meal.
Scallops had no flavor and my husbands fish was mediocre.
The main restaurant looked nice but we were seated in the back room that was not near as nicely decorated. I feel like it was overpriced for the meals we received.

I've always found good food and service at the PM every time I go there.

Everything we have eaten has been very good... the Prime Rib is great,,, Ribs very tender