Monticello Restaurants
Make a free reservation
Book for dinner in Upstate New York
Introducing OpenTable Icons
Book the city's award-winners, hot newcomers, and hard-to-get tables.
Book the city's award-winners, hot newcomers, and hard-to-get tables.
New restaurants to OpenTable in Upstate New York
Check out diners' favorite restaurants in Monticello
Updated on
Diners’ Choice Awards are based on where your fellow diners book, dine, and review. Only verified diners get to review restaurants on OpenTable, so our data doesn’t lie.
Cellaio Steak By Scott Conant - Resorts World Catskills
Price: Very Expensive•Steakhouse•4.7(3,113)Renowned chef, author and restaurateur Scott Conant introduces an Italian-inspired steakhouse, Cellaio, nestled in the picturesque Catskill Mountains. A play on the Italian term for a butcher’s pantry, Cellaio offers Conant’s take on the traditional steakhouse, complementing aged steaks with the antipasti, market salads and house made pastas that have become synonymous with his cooking. A relaxed bar and lounge greets guests upon arrival and leads to a spacious dining room featuring roomy crescent-shaped booths, communal seating and an interactive decanting station. For private events, a pair of intimate dining rooms reveal incomparable views of the surrounding mountains. Whether it’s to celebrate a big win or for a weeknight dinner with friends, Cellaio Steak is a destination dining experience for upstate New York built on generous hospitality.The Eldred Preserve
Price: Expensive•American•4.5(270)The Homestead Restaurant + Lounge at The Eldred Preserve, named "The Best Fine Dining Restaurant in the Upper Delaware Valley," offers an elevated dining experience — featuring house-aged steaks and farm-to-table fare — all year long.
The modern steakhouse features several unique experiential spaces, including floor-to-ceiling windows in its main dining area, a wine-tasting room, private dining room, sunroom dining area, and an expansive covered, heated outdoor patio that’s ideal for dining al fresco. Guests can enjoy custom cakes for special occasions, holiday dining events, and special onsite performances.
The Homestead’s menus are ever-changing, and include a list of carefully-crafted signature cocktails, a wide selection of world-class wines, and an array of spirits and beers, many distilled or brewed in and around Sullivan County, N.Y.
The Lounge, also a Readers' Choice award winner, offers a comfortable atmosphere, beautiful views, and a nice selection of lighter dining fare.
Outdoor dining in Upstate New York
See what locals rave about in Monticello
From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
- JJohnVIPPhiladelphia County •62 reviews5.0Dined 2 days agoFood and service was outstanding with our server Samantha very attentive to our needs and requests. Hope to be back in the furure.More infoThe Eldred PreservePrice: Expensive• American• Monticello•4.5
- JJoAnnAtlantic City / South Jersey Shore •4 reviews5.0Dined 3 days agoAwesome steak house. Food is delicious and Rudy our waiter, was the best. He was knowledgeable about the food and its preparation and had a nice demeanor and very courteous! I recommend this steak house ! Outstanding in every way!!we celebrated our anniversary!More infoCellaio Steak By Scott Conant - Resorts World CatskillsPrice: Very Expensive• Steakhouse• Monticello•4.7
- JJohnVIPPhiladelphia County •61 reviews4.0Dined 3 days agoFood was very good but would not substitute. Example, instead of mash potatoes and vegetables, ask for a side of pasta. Owner? Said NO substitute. Why does a restaurant ask if it’s a special occasion and does not acknowledge it! It was our anniversary. A plus was the white tablecloths.More infoCiao BellaPrice: Moderate• Italian• Monticello•4.8
- NNoreenScranton / Poconos •3 reviews5.0Dined on Jun 20, 2025Loved the food, ambiance and staff! I highly recommend Lotus!More infoLotus - Resorts World CatskillsPrice: Very Expensive• Asian• Monticello•4.5
- OTOpenTable DinerNew York City •2 reviews5.0Dined on Mar 8, 2025Food was amazing. Waitress was great. Will definitely return.More info24/7 Diner - Resorts World CasinoPrice: Moderate• American• Monticello•4
Frequently asked questions
The best reviewed restaurant in Monticello is Ciao Bella
The best vegetarian restaurants in Monticello are Cellaio Steak By Scott Conant - Resorts World Catskills, The Eldred Preserve and Lotus - Resorts World Catskills
The restaurants with the best service in Monticello are Cellaio Steak By Scott Conant - Resorts World Catskills, Ciao Bella and Lotus - Resorts World Catskills
The restaurants with the best ambiance in Monticello are The Eldred Preserve, Ciao Bella and Cellaio Steak By Scott Conant - Resorts World Catskills
Explore OpenTable
- Jellystone Park at Birchwood Acres
- Best Western Monticello
- Silver Lake Dam
- Ohave Shalom Synagogue
- Rivoli Theatre
- Monticello Casino and Raceway
- St. John's Episcopal Church and Rectory
- Sullivan County Historical Society Museum
- De Hoyos Memorial Park
- Holiday Mountain Ski Resort
- Econo Lodge Monticello
- Anshei Glen Wild Synagogue
- Super 8 Monticello
- Holiday Mountain Ski & Fun
- Monticello Amusement Park Historical
- Tarry Brae Golf Course
- Inn At Lake Joseph
- South Fallsburg Hebrew Association Synagogue
- Hebrew Congregation of Mountaindale Synagogue
- Concord Monster Golf Course