The Neely House
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Black Garlic Soy glaze, Pointe Reyes Bleu, Pickled Red Onion, Kale Served on Sourdough boule
Steak & Eggs
Prime Filet, Hollandaise, Two Eggs your-way, Home Fries & Toast
The food was excellent, atmosphere pleasant and staff helpful and accommodating as usual.
Great experience, first time there. Went for brunch, lots of delicious choices on the menu. Service was excellent and the coffee was fantastic! Will definitely be going back, loved the atmosphere!!
Above and Beyond
Food and drinks well priced
We had such a wonderful brunch! We are age-old friends who live in multiple cities and states, and were searching for a special place for our get together. The Newly House certainly met, and exceeded!, every expectation. The menu was amazing, the drink offerings were intriguing and expertly mixed. The ambiance of the restoration and the servers all combined to make this a special event, and one place we can honestly recommend to our friends.
The French toast is to die for! Excellent service; our water glasses were kept full.
We had a girls day out starting with brunch at the Neely House. It did not disappoint. The food was great, especially the French Toast with Berry Compote. Will definitely be back to visit for dinner.
Amazing! Great atmosphere, beautiful setting! Filet was cooked perfectly with amazing flavor. The Duck was surprising, but I world order again. We will be back!
Food was great. Service and atmosphere were also outstanding. Not something one would expect to find in Muncie, Indiana.
Was mine and my husbands first visit! Not our last! The service was good, waitress was excellent…attentive, patient(first timers), and answered all questions we had about the food(some of which I had to look up first). The atmosphere was great! The ambiance was delicate which made it quite nice and relaxing for me; with the soft yet some deep color, the easy classical listening music to the library feel! The only thing for “me” is what I see as mutilated books glued to the walls. I am a fan of breathing, the beauty of trees, and a fan to respecting those who put in the work to write for our knowledge, entertainment, and passion. However, that hasn’t deterred me from coming to enjoy the atmosphere, people, and most definitely and deliciously the food! I ordered the in bone rib eye, came with asparagus and puréed potatoes and my husband had ordered the baked Campanelle lobster. When they brought our food my first thought was hmm I feel my husband and I should switch plates, because my order was so much bigger than his lol! My steak was huge and so juicy and tasty I had to share with my husband and still brought a lot of it home!! He shared his with me and his baked campanelle lobster was very good too!!! We really have no complaints!! Just YUM!!
TABLE SERVICE WAS GREAT, SEEMED LIKE SHE DIDN'T HAVE ENOUGH SUPPORT. FRYER BROKEN WENT FOR THE FRIED CHICKEN. DRINKS WERE GREAT. MAYBE A SIGN OF THE TIMES.
My wife and I have eaten here several times and it's one of our favorite spots. However, drink service was very slow. Food was fantastic as usual.
Great place to enjoy beautiful weather and delicious food!
This was our first and last trip to The Neely House. While the ambiance and food were wonderful...we did not plan on being there for a 2 hour tour while we waited for our meals.
We were in town from Texas and found The Neely House. Except for the slow service and 3 hours later our experience with the quality of food, ambience was exceptional.
Good bye party
Today was our second visit here and we truly enjoyed it!
We ate outside this time instead of inside and our service was wonderful. The drinks were delicious, food arrived in a timely manner and our waiter was attentive and outstanding! We've already made reservations for next weekend! We appreciate this place beyond words not only for the food and the care taken at the details but that something so wonderful is so close to home!
Way too loud! Way too close! No privacy to carry on our own atmosphere. Everyone was aware of what everyone else was doing. We did not like that experience in fine dining. Sorry !
1 outta 5
It was a great day with wonderful food and service!
Delicious food with a great atmosphere. Will return
This restaurant exceeds expectations. Beautiful decor, great food , drinks and service. A special and memory making experience with our college student grandson.
This was one of the best experiences I have had in my life. I’ll be back!
We had an amazing evening. The server was very attentive, food was perfect especially the tuna, and drinks were superb. Thank you for a lovely evening.
Birthday! Great outdoor patio with lots of seating.
Excellent food and service. Top notch. Highly recommend this place.
The Neely House is one of our favorite places to eat dinner. We had never had brunch there before and had out of state guests coming. We were all impressed and look forward to returning!
This was a very charming and delicious place for brunch. We ate inside but outside also looked lovely. Food was very good.
We celebrated our 50th Wedding Anniversary!
Best cocktail - smoked Manhattan!!
Josh was a wonderful server. We had a big party and he delivered everything on time and with class.
Family in town from Fl, granddaughter in the play, “Mona Mia”.
Ben is a wonderful server and reflects the quality of this place.
Fantastic! I just wish I would have discovered it sooner!
My wife and I had a wonderful brunch on a Sunday morning. Everything from the ease of making a reservation thru the wait staff and meal was exceptional. Anxious to return in the near future.
We love eating at the Neely House! The food is always good, the cocktails strong but tasty, and amazing service!
Thei Benedicts we’re wonderful and the service outstanding.
The staff was friendly, the restaurant was beautiful, and the Neely House is a place I would recommend couples go for their anniversary.
Service, food and atmosphere was very good. Highly recommend Sunday Brunch.
We had a lovely meal outside. The food was delicious, with 2 caveats. One of our diners had the roast beef sliders and thought the buns were too heavy and chewy for that use, though the meat was delicious. We also ordered the peach cobbler which came literally floating in butter. Our server thoughtfully noticed that something wasn’t right and took it off the bill.
Our server was knowledgeable and pleasant - the pace of the service was perhaps a little too fast.
Food was not hot. warm at best. Service was good. Price was good.
Everything about this place is outstanding. Worth every penny. Which by the way the meal was also very affordable.
Great food, drinks, and service. We were seated ahead of our reservation time which was very nice. They were somewhat busy but our food and drinks came extremely fast and everything was very hot and fresh.
The Neely House offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (765) 216-1647.
The Neely House is rated 4.8 stars by 259 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.