Prime House Steak and Seafood
All steaks are dry aged 21-28 days with our experienced staff. With the experience of Peter Luger SteakHouse and Molinos, our staff is knowledgeable and are able to provide excellent outcomes.
We have a patio, as well as indoor seating.
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Contactless payment available
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
- Staff temperature check required
- Diner temperature check required
Spectacular food, exceptional and friendly service from all staff - looking for our next reason to dine at Prime again !
This restaurant serves excellent steak and other delicious preparations in addition all the wait staff plus the owner and his wife are very nice people who look after your needs and take good care of you in a pleasant way.
We have been many times since they opened and each time seems to be better. We are full-time residents .
My wife and I recommend it highly.
Amazing food and service. Always treated well!!!
We had a lovely meal on the patio at Prime House Steak. The calamari was not our favorite. It was very nice and crispy, but a bit bland for our taste. Our rib steak was very tasty and we would order it again! Our main disappointment was with the server who was rushing us to order our appetizer, main and dessert all at once. He told us if we waited to order our dinner until after the appetizers had arrived, we would have an hour and a half wait for our main course. What?? It was not even very busy in the restaurant. We didn't listen and ordered course by course, as we prefer. Our meal arrived in a timely manner and was delicious!
Excellent food and service
Waiter was nice, but the food was subpar. Incredibly high price point for bad cuts of meat and not well cooked, can get better steaks elsewhere.
Great food, reasonable prices and great service
Great service and food!
Our service was great. We were greeted promptly and sat at a table of our choosing. Our server, Sam, was prompt and attentive. The food was par to subpar. We ordered filet and ribeye. Neither justified the high price point. Other local places have better steak for the same price point.
Value was not there as the strip was tough and without much flavor.
This was my 2nd time eating here. The first time was fabulous! The food was spectacular, as was the service. This time, the special penne vodka with pieces of filet was barely eatable. Our waiter was fine but too quick to leave.
The difference in the meals was enough for me to say 'never again'. So sorry. I really wanted to support our local restaurants.
Had a party of 7 including a 5 and 7 year old. Were seated promptly at a nice outdoor table. No kids menu, but waiter said they would make whatever the kids wanted. Was very accommodating, and the steaks and seafood were excellent. Definitely will be back!
The service was outstanding! Sam was amazing. Food was ok. Expensive and didn't have much flavor or seasoning to it.
Terrific steaks served by attentive waiters.
Food was great. 3 course fixed price was very good and modestly priced for the good quality and selection. Bone-in NY strip was excellent. Our server, Sam, was exceptional. Nice wine selection too!
Our server was very friendly and restaurant environment was cozy, clean and charming. We were a party of five (with 3 kids) visiting area from Midwest. The restaurant offers no children’s menu. When we asked if they had any kid options, we were referred back to adult menu. Good option for adults. Not a great option for families with young children.
Overall our dining experience was very good. The food was very good, the server and the rest of the staff were great and the restaurant ambiance was nice. A bit pricey and the menu was tough to understand because some entree’s came with sides and other didn’t so you had to ask the server about each item.
The atmosphere was calming. The food was very good and the service was good.
The food and service were excellent and the value of the three course meal was just what I wanted. A medium-rare steak with great sides, a very nice Caesar salad and key lime pie for desert.
We live in Fort Myers but brought family for dinner from out of state. We all RAVED about the steaks we ordered- Ribeyes and 14 ounce NY strips- cooked to perfection! Excellent fresh Cesar and mixed salads and probably the best key lime pie I’ve had anywhere and that is saying something when you live in Florida. Great mashed potatoes as well, plus a solid wine list. Extremely nice staff; we will be back! Bravo!
Great friendly service, nice atmosphere. The Fillet was a great cut of meat, inside temperature was perfect, just a little charred on the outside. We would come back again.
We celebrated our 3 year anniversary at Prime Steakhouse and it was perfect! The dining room is beautiful and elegant. The staff are all seasoned professionals and amazing. The food was delicious. We enjoyed most things that we ordered and were thrilled with the amazing presentation of our meal. We wanted to drink the steak sauce—it’s that good. My dry aged porterhouse melted in my mouth. A true gem!
Steak was at the very top I’ve had at numerous steakhouses. Excellent.
Great dining experience! Great menu, steaks and awesome presentation. Can’t wait to come back!
The menu is confusing as far as how entree's are prepared and what sides are included. Our server did not communicate this well either leading to confusion and too many side dishes. We enjoyed the ambiance on the outdoor patio however and appreciated the dessert for our son, whose 30th birthday we were celebrating.
Wonderful owners and staff! We had the porterhouse for three, DELICIOUS! Every bit as good as a high end steak house if not better! Good wine too!
Their Porterhouse steak is one of the best steaks I have eaten.
Great food Excellent service and staff. Would definitely go back soon.
My wife and I ordered porterhouse for two based on favorable reviews online. The steak was flavorful but rare rather than medium rare as ordered and contained a fair amount of gristle. We called over our waiter, Adrian, who argued there was no gristle in it and insisted on trying to cook the meat further in the juice on the plate rather than returning it to the kitchen. He further reached over the table and took several pieces of meat from the serving dish and put them on my wife’s plate contending to show her they weren’t too rare. We felt that was very rude. He further brought one check for the two couples and rudely answered when asked to split it. Reason for the request was our check was considerably more than our friends due to the porterhouse we ordered. All in all, we know steaks can’t always be tender. However, the way we were treated we will not return to this restaurant, in spite of the nice decor inside and out.
Great Food and excellent service. A must for aged porterhouse lovers.
Food was outstanding
The food was awful and the owner was very rude. I would not recommend this place and will never return. They serve frozen vegetables and cold potatoes with there very average to poor tasting steak and salmon:(
We had dinner on the enclosed patio and it was great. Everything we ordered was prepared perfectly.
We will definitely be back.
Great food and atmosphere...Very good choice. Will definitely return.
Beef is without question superior.
But try the chop salad.
Steak was awful. Undercooked and raw when it was ordered medium. Service very slow.
This restaurant refused to accept the Open Table rewards card.
We followed all the correct processes for using the card including telling them when we arrived we that intended to use the card and showing them the printed card. They made no indication that they would not accept the card at that time.
When we finished our meal and were paying the bill they said they would not accept the card.
When I discussed this with the restaurant owner he simply complained about how much he had to pay Open Table and attempted to show me his Open Table invoice.
We paid our full bill by credit card and left.
I told the owner that he would never see us again and that I would make it a point to give his restaurant a bad review to everyone I talked to.
I believe that this restaurant should not be listed in Open Table for making reservations.
This restaurant does not accept Open table award cards.
Sam took care of us. Great service from the entire staff. Excellent experience. Was a little loud (Friday evening from 6-8 PM) so if you go with a family member who is hard of hearing you may want to sit in a quieter spot, we were in the middle of the restaurant. The food was outstanding (Porterhouse, New York Strip, Filet, Lobster Ravioli and one of the specials)
Best mashed potatoes! The 3 course steak dinner was delicious!
Prime House Steak and Seafood offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (239) 301-4949.
Prime House Steak and Seafood is rated 4.4 stars by 91 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.