Baklava Ice Cream Cake
slow roasted lamb shank pulled off of the bone, house made gnocchi, carrots, onions, spinach, feta, fennel puree
Overall satisfied, will return again.
They do their best in regard of Covid.
We love this place! We stop by about every time we’re on island. The fresh catch salad is a can’t miss. I had the ono dinner, and that was great, too.
Of course, the pita is wonderful!
Nice patio, good food, friendly staff and no reservation for lunch!
Nice enough place, food decent quality but poor value.
Dinner was served within 6 -8 minutes of ordering, because all they did was slap a piece of pita bread down, put a couple tablespoons of Gyro meat down with some veggies and a small wedge of cheese for $26.
Basically, we paid $60+ tax & tip for two Greek tacos and 2 soft drinks.
We had to grab something else somewhere else as we were still hungry and we are not massive eaters.
Weren't there long! Wasn't good value, wouldn't return or recommend.
Our food was amazing, super fresh and flavorful. We had the Mini Greek Burger, the Ahi Tartar N’Pita Chips, the Chicken Pesto Pita Pitza, and the Bolognese Pasta dinner; every dish was better that the last. Just when I thought it couldn’t get better we finished with the Baklava Ice Cream Cake, the perfect finish to our meal.
Finally I have to mention our server, Karen. She was warm and welcoming while being professional; Karen was friendly and extremely knowledgeable about the menu. I will definitely recommend Pita Paradise to everyone!
The food was ok but the service was horrible. I don’t think I’ve ever been treated so poorly in a restaurant. We were seated outside during happy hour (we didn’t choose where to sit, they did). They refused to serve us from the happy hour menu because “happy hour is only inside”. The waitress was extremely rude and raised her voice when we politely asked to be moved inside. She then proceeded to say that because of covid the indoor capacity was reached. We totally understood that and asked to wait. She then proceeded to allow 10-12 more people inside within minutes. We watched her talk about us to the other waitress and then scoffed and agreed to move us inside. Overall, horrible experience. Clearly taking advantage of tourists, we will not be back.
The happy hour steak kabobs were very good, our our waiter was very friendly and attentive.
Food is always excellent here and the baklava cake is heavenly. Reservations is a must if you want to get seated in timely fashion, especially during lunch.
Wonderful lamb skewers wonderful Ambiance, love the food, love the service great place to eat!
The food was great and our waitress was very nice and attentive. Would recommend.
Not the greatest ambiance but the food was delicious and value was good.
Always good and always consistent. Service very professional. Great choice for bar, lunch or dinner. One of our favorites.
Food was delicious and service was friendly and quick
We ate here 5 years ago and were excited to try it again. However, not the same as we expected. Menu was limited and not as Mediterranean as we remembered, more Italian. Made reservations for 2 different nights and cancelled the 2nd night.
The staff, service,and food is always on point, we eat here every weekend!
Great lunch love the back patio it’s like a garden
Great overall experience Defiantly will go back Also on of the best priced places on the island
Always great food. Fresh!!!!
Really enjoyed dinner here. The service was great and the food delicious . The tiropita appetizer was great. Fresh fish special was vey good. Mousaka excellent. Outstanding baklava cake for dessert is a must!
The baklava cake is to die for‼️
Excellent food and service. Didn’t know what to expect, but was pleasantly surprised. The pita is outstanding!!
Excellent drinks & food recommendations. We will definitely return!
Great service and the food was excellent, as usual!
Tasty food in a safe outdoor patio!
The steak kabobs tasted very bland, as though they did not have seasoning or salt. I asked the waiter for some seasoning and they brought out another kabob, but it was no better. Otherwise the moussaka greek lasagna was superb.
We went for happy hour- food was delicious and the service was stellar.
It's a great deal all around. Food and surroundings are awesome. The owner/manager was delightful when we expressed concerns over the server. Will be be back again soon!
We love this little place! Outside area is great and the staff is friendly and efficient! The food is always consistent and the fish is fresh everyday!
My kids love gyros and pita and hummus, so we tried out Pita Paradise. The staff was very nice and COVID-careful and the space was set up well for social distancing. We ordered the pita and hummus appetizer, which was good, but light on the pita and a bit expensive for the portion. My husband ordered the Bolognese pasta and he enjoyed it, though it was quite heavy. My daughter had a gnocchi dish, in which the dumplings were relatively light, but the chunkiness of the sauce wasn't well suited for them. One of the beef kabobs, which I ordered medium rare, came raw inside and the one which was cooked as ordered was very chewy. The side of rice tasted like a boxed mix. The kids' Caeser salad which my son ordered was overdressed and therefore limp.
Overall, we found the food to be mediocre and would not venture back if hoping for good Mediterranean or Italian food. And, as many restaurants in Wailea, it is quite pricey for the quality.
Waited a while to get our food. On top of that our order was wrong so we had to wait even longer.
We travel to Maui annually, and it's always on our list. Consistently delicious with excellent service.
Always great across the board. We always start with the sampler platter. Not because we need it but because everything on it is so delicious. As for mains, I’ve tried everything on the menu but just can’t help but order the teriyaki chicken pita 9x out of 10. Never disappointed when we visit.
The best of the best. The food is amazing. Homemade gnocchi to die for.
Such good food and friendly service. Highly recommend!
Slow service. Like, really bad.
The food is excellent here with vibrant flavors. I ordered their spicy falafel and it paired well with the tzatziki sauce. Whether you order take out or dine in, I highly recommend.
Food was excellent and staff great
Restaurant was clean, quiet, smelled delicious the moment we walked in. Food was amazing! Wish we had found it earlier in our trip we probably would have eaten there every night!
Perfect early dinner for our family. Craft cocktails were amazing and the food was delicious. Our server was on it and the outdoor seating was so nice. Highly recommend this restaurant.
Pita Paradise offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (808) 879-7177.
Pita Paradise is rated 4.6 stars by 331 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.