Baklava Ice Cream Cake
slow roasted lamb shank pulled off of the bone, house made gnocchi, carrots, onions, spinach, feta, fennel puree
We love this little place! Outside area is great and the staff is friendly and efficient! The food is always consistent and the fish is fresh everyday!
My kids love gyros and pita and hummus, so we tried out Pita Paradise. The staff was very nice and COVID-careful and the space was set up well for social distancing. We ordered the pita and hummus appetizer, which was good, but light on the pita and a bit expensive for the portion. My husband ordered the Bolognese pasta and he enjoyed it, though it was quite heavy. My daughter had a gnocchi dish, in which the dumplings were relatively light, but the chunkiness of the sauce wasn't well suited for them. One of the beef kabobs, which I ordered medium rare, came raw inside and the one which was cooked as ordered was very chewy. The side of rice tasted like a boxed mix. The kids' Caeser salad which my son ordered was overdressed and therefore limp.
Overall, we found the food to be mediocre and would not venture back if hoping for good Mediterranean or Italian food. And, as many restaurants in Wailea, it is quite pricey for the quality.
Waited a while to get our food. On top of that our order was wrong so we had to wait even longer.
We travel to Maui annually, and it's always on our list. Consistently delicious with excellent service.
Always great across the board. We always start with the sampler platter. Not because we need it but because everything on it is so delicious. As for mains, I’ve tried everything on the menu but just can’t help but order the teriyaki chicken pita 9x out of 10. Never disappointed when we visit.
The best of the best. The food is amazing. Homemade gnocchi to die for.
Such good food and friendly service. Highly recommend!
Slow service. Like, really bad.
The food is excellent here with vibrant flavors. I ordered their spicy falafel and it paired well with the tzatziki sauce. Whether you order take out or dine in, I highly recommend.
Food was excellent and staff great
Restaurant was clean, quiet, smelled delicious the moment we walked in. Food was amazing! Wish we had found it earlier in our trip we probably would have eaten there every night!
Perfect early dinner for our family. Craft cocktails were amazing and the food was delicious. Our server was on it and the outdoor seating was so nice. Highly recommend this restaurant.
The fish kebab were moist and wonderful. The Mojito’s we’re great also.
Great food awesome service
Always wonderful getting to come here. Food is fresh, service impeccable and management is so kind and accommodating. Thank you for another lovely night, Pita!
The lamb kabobs were delicious and don’t miss out on the baklava ice cream cake for dessert
Pita Paradise is our favourite restaurant on Maui and we make it here each time we come. The food is always top notch and flavourful and the service is friendly and professional
The outdoor patio is very European courtyard!
We went at 5 pm which is their happy hour. They sat us outside which apparently is not part of their happy hour. The restaurant was empty but I guess they don't cater to clients.
Overall it was average quality food with high prices. They're in the same shopping center with MonkeyPod and charge similar prices, in fact our bill was more here, but the food quality is far less and not at all innovative.
I see no need to return.
Had a nice little double date with friends. All the food was good as usual. Especially the calamari, which I often tell people is the best calamari on the island! Watch out for those tiropitas though... they are tasty but they are small and you only get 2.
Service was pretty good. The food really isn’t good. Apparently the owner catches most of the fish, which is pretty cool.
My husband ordered the swordfish, two 2 oz thin medallions were served. The moussaka that I ordered wasn’t even edible. I’m at a loss to say what was on top of the eggplant, possibly mashed potatoes?
I wouldn’t eat there again or recommend it. Very poor food value.
Food not as good as in the past. Maybe an off night.
Excellent gluten free pasta! We did not expect that. My celic daughter was very happy. (She thought that she was going to eat salad there...)
Always a great meal, wonderful staff and They provide a nice Birthday treat!
Just all around fantastic food and service. We loved the Hamachi Jalapeño Roll!
We loved this restaurant! They have a lovely outdoor courtyard and everyone loved their food. Nice keiki portions and options too. We loved the lamb gnocchi, the mousakka and the baklavah ice cream cake. Great find.
Great fresh fish and pasta. Server Taggart was really good.
lovely ambient, great Mediterranean food, friendly service.
Wonderful & attentive service. The Mediterranean dishes were all yummy, but the two “Italian”/ pasta dishes we had were bland.
The grilled pitas were also good.
Great shish kabobs! We prefer the steak, but the lamb is good too.
Varied menu with plenty of options - many good choices! We all enjoyed our meals and felt that the quality was exceptional and affordable. We actually made a 2nd reservation for dining one more them before we leave town!
I'm mad at myself for not eating here earlier! My wife and I have passed by a million times. For some reason, we never thought to eat here or look up the menu. I think I wrongly associated it with Pita Pit, a sandwich shop from my college years.
I'm so glad we came in. It's now our favorite meal in Maui since we moved here four years ago. The appetizers, entrees, desserts and even the iced tea was amazing. Perfectly cooked fresh kabobs (steak, Mahi, lamb) Wasn't in the mood for alcohol, but if the mixed drinks are half as good as the food, I'll be taking an Uber next time!
Best Greek food I've ever had, and our waitress (Brittany I think) was excellent! Service, timing, friendliness, basically everything was perfect!
I can't wait to come back. You guys are great! See ya soon.
Excellent service and food! One of my favorite restaurants in Maui.
Fantastic dinner!!! Drinks, apps, dinner and dessert were phenomenal! Loved our waitress! Hidden gem in Waliea!
Very enjoyable long lunch
Great service, sat in the courtyard. My food was great.
Excellent service and food! I have been there now twice in one week because it was so good! They offer indoor and outdoor seating. Outdoor seating is in the shade which is perfect! It is a very clean restaurant and I highly recommend it!!
Thank you Tiffany! We greatly appreciate your awesome review. We pride ourselves on the cleanliness of our restaurant, especially these days. We strive for safety and cleanliness for our customers as well as our employees! You enter our home when you dine with us with home cooked family recipes passed down from generation to generation and it shows. Hope to see you again soon! Warm Mahalo
Food was dry and no taste for the chicken and ‘fresh’ fish.
Small portions very expensive.
Consistently excellent service and food. Baklava Ice Cream Pie is the reason for returning time and again. Kabobs are the best. Ziziki Sauce, they should sell pints to go home !
Pita Paradise offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (808) 879-7177.
Pita Paradise is rated 4.6 stars by 318 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.