Carelli's Ristorante Italiano
Carelli's was the winner of the Daily Camera Reader's Choice 2002-2020 award for Best Italian Restaurant and ambiance. It also has won awards from the Denver Post and Boulder Weekly magazines. It has an awesome bar scene and an extensive wine list. Carelli's restaurant features daily fresh fish specials.
stacked eggplant baked with goat cheese, roasted peppers, red pepper coulis
half pound Town Dock ocean squid, lightly breaded
8 oz. grilled beef tenderloin, olive oil, fresh rosemary garlic jus, with potato spears
Service was very poor (not attentive, incorrect input of food order, & unengaged) but food was great.
Enjoyable as always Great service
Dinner was very good. I was disappointed in the Scoozi dish. Ambience was very nice for a date night, waiter was very nice and a nice selection of wine. Will go back but will not order the Scoozi dish again.
Carelli's is always a favorite. They are doing a great job in the covid craziness.
Our favorite restaurant in Boulder. We go every time we are there. The gluten free menu is extensive and all the food is great.
Everything was outstanding from the menu to our server!!
The service and food were excellent. Outdoor dining with heat. Atmosphere is pleasant but you are next to a parking lot but it wasn’t an issue for us.
Carelli’s is hands down one of the best restaurants in the Boulder dining scene. The quality and presentation of the food is always excellent. I have tried many of the dishes on the menu and they are always filling and tasty. Thanks for always being there Carelli’s!!
Decent food. However, tasted like typical restaurant “chain” food (even though not a chain”). Nothing bad about the food, just not great.
Service was very good. Friendly, efficient, and proper.
It’s been awhile sense I was at the restaurant and it was nice to see Greg’s wonderful creating still serving up great food and ambiance despite a crazy pandemic!
If you haven’t tried Carelli’s its time to go and enjoy a nice relaxing experience and great food!
Carelli's, hands down, is the best Italian Restaurant in the greater Boulder area and has been for years. We've not been eating out much because of Covid; however, we were satisfied that Greg was doing all he could to provide a safe dining experience. We requested outdoor seating in a low-traffic area and were seated at the end of the "balcony" area, which was perfect. As for the food, my wife ordered the Trout Special, which came with a dinner salad and I had the white bean soup for my starter and the Manicotti for my main course. Everything was prepared perfectly, service was well timed and the food was as delicious as usual. We washed it down with one of Carelli's wine specials. All-in-all, an excellent dining experience and we highly recommend Carelli's to anyone looking for good Italian food served in a friendly, attractive setting.
2 in our party had not been before- they were very impressed
Carelli's is a great Italian restaurant that I would go to again. We were able to sit outside and maintain a good distance from other tables. Our waiter was very good as well. Food, drinks, and ambiance, this place had it all!
Great server, food and ambiance and we are picky customers.
Great food, as always, amazing drinks, Their staff is very on point with distance and cleaning of surfaces ( seems like every time we looked around someone was spraying something on chairs or doors to keep them sanitized). We were not able to sit outside but felt very safe inside their beautiful restaurant,
Was here for a late lunch. Service was efficient and professional, but not rushed.
Resturant handles Covid well. All the staff wore masks and gloves. Tables seemed to be well spaced.
Loved the eggplant stack and the garlic bread. The Classico pizza was amazing. Nice selection of wines by the glass. Great tiramisu.
Will definitely be back to support this restaurant.
As always, great service and good food!
We haven't been to Carelli's for about a year and wow, things have really changed. We wonder if they changed ownership or chefs. The food was fair and the sauces tasted slightly off. The overflowing basket of garlic bread was too much - would have preferred their former, oven-hot, fresh bread that tasted better with just EVOO. There were other slight changes, smaller cocktail glasses perhaps? I know restaurants have been struggling, so we try to support the local favorites, but I doubt will be back here anytime soon.
Although I have been to Carelli’s several times for dinner and sometimes just for dining at the bar, this was the first time I have been there for lunch. I had a business meeting and Carelli’s was the perfect spot. The patio was a terrific setting . Tables were socially distant so we were able to conduct business an enjoy the day. The service was very timely, friendly, and she let us conduct our meeting without being obtrusive.
As for the food it was delicious as always. I had the Kale Salad with a side of perfectly cooked Salmon. I recommended the Chicken Parmigiana to my associate. He said it was the best he has had. Thanks Carelli’s!
Always a good time and and a great meal. Very consistent restaurant.
Great place! First time we’ve been. Really beautiful ambiance and our server was wonderful. Food was pretty good, though the chicken piccata wasn’t as traditional as I’m used to. Lemon creme brûlée’s was so good. Will for sure be back.
I witnessed an employee who was polishing the utensils, drop a fork on the floor, pick it up and put it back in with the clean forks. I told the manager, but he didn’t seem to care much. He said it would take care of it, but I saw him walk to the bar and stay there. Pretty disturbing. Food was good as always though.
The patio is lovely; service attentive & perfect! Carelli's is a favorite!
The food has always been excellent and out latest visit was no exception!
Had a dinner for 4 at the restaurant. They had good protocols for waiting until table was ready, seating was properly spaced, cleaning was very apparent, and all followed safety guidelines the restaurant had instituted. We enjoyed a variety of appetizers, wine, and various dinner entrees. All were very good accompanied by great attentive service. Enjoyed a couple shared desserts. Very pleasant evening of dining.
The food was fabulous as it has been for many years. This was our first dining experience out since covid. We were nervous about going but were completely at ease once we saw so many tables gone and the remaining ones spread out. Thank you Carelli's!
Strict rules of masks due to covid which we appreciated. Wait staff wore gloves. Great service snd food was excellent. Very impressed how despite current state if affairs how well this restaurant ran. They adapted well without giving up any quality!
Consistently good for many, many years !
Food and Service excellent as always. Their COVID standards, policies, and rules are amazing!!! No wonder its one the hardest places to get reservation.
so nice to go out for dinner again. They sat us on the patio - which was perfect.
Good safety protocols. Clean. Socially distanced seating.
Service and food great!
Excellent COVID dining experience. The restaurant tables were distanced safely and all the staff wore masks. Our waitress was lovely and our meal was exceptional. My husband had the Chicken Parmesan and I had the Halibut & bacon special, both were fantastic. Definitely returning again soon!
Second time here, food was not as good as first. My chicken dish was a little dry, needed sauce plus better seasoning. Roasted broccoli was good, so was garlic bread. Had to ask several times for drink refill.
Food is good. We sat outside, wait staff was great!
Great handling of social distancing with glass door walls completely open and tables well spaced. Food was delicious as always and service was excellent.
It’s so lovely to sit outside with our dogs and enjoy a special dinner. The cocktails are lovely. The menu is very GF friendly. The area around the fire has great views of the foothills.
Favorite for dinners - particularly spaghetti . COVID 19 is a challenge - it is handled well,
We think this local Italian restaurant is hands down the best in Boulder. The ingredients and menu are fresh and inspired. Service is perfect and unrushed. We had the mussels,spinach salad and sausage pasta. All excellent. Probably had too much garlic bread, but it is so good!
Our family loves this great restaurant! Great food, great atmosphere, a fun place!
Carelli's Ristorante Italiano offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (303) 938-9300.
Carelli's Ristorante Italiano is rated 4.6 stars by 306 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.