Calamari & Shrimp
Fried Calamari – Shrimp – Zucchini – Arrabbiata
Potato Dumpling – Fresh Tomato - Basil – Homemade Stracciatella Cheese
Tomato Sauce - Burrata - Basil
They took off some of my favorites from the happy hour entree and dessert menu so not sure we will be back for happy hour.
The food was great just a little noisy later in the evening - hard to have conversations at our table
Food arrived cold after an hour waiting for it. Service was AWFUL
45 mins to get a glass of water. Waiter was MIA
Manager was more clueless. Pulled down his mask to ‘hear’ us when we complained and did nothing
Our flight was late coming from Pittsburgh to Naples and I called Caffe Milano and the put together a take out order. The service and the food was great.
The Italian food here is fabulous. We heard about their half-price happy hour and tried to get in last week. We ended up having dinner at the bar and had a great time. So, this week, we decided to make a reservation. On Open Table, the only reservations available were at 3 pm, the beginning of Happy Hour, or at 5 when it’s over. We took the 3 pm reservation figuring we could have a few drinks and then order dinner a little before 5. We were told upon arrival that they don’t accept reservations during happy hour and were treated rather rudely by the hostess. We were taken to a table and then treated rather rudely by the waiter who seemed to be rushing us to have dinner. No, rushing isn’t the right word. He was pestering us. The food was great but the experience was awful. We’ll never go back.
We had a great Easter dinner. The weather was beautiful and we were able to sit outside on the sidewalk and enjoy 5th Avenue Naples. The food portions were excellent and the quality was outstanding. Service was impeccable.
Wonderful experience for Easter dinner. Having Antonio as server made the difference
and any customer would return to Caffe Milano return for the food and the service.
Easter brunch for 7 very Giid ask for Johnny he’s the best waiter
Service was horrible. Took 2 1/2 hours to eat. Tables around us had come, Ate and left.
Meals took over an hour and none of the four arrived hot. Two were sent back to be heated and arrived back only lukewarm. All of us had lost our appetite by this time and most of the meals were hardly eaten. Very bad experience!!!
All I can say is amazing !!!!!!!!!! Authentic Italian food and the wait staff is amazing and so
Accommodating! Would give this restaurant 5 stars hands down. Antonio the waiter was amazing !
Everything was good but not all staff wore masks and the bathrooms were disgusting.
Wonderful experience. The meatballs....oh my!!! Lewis our server was AMAZING!!! He took such good care of us! Will definitely be back.
We ordered the 2 specials for the day, was over priced and had no flavor. I was very disappointed I don't think I would go back.
Great place! Food and service was amazing! We will definitely revisit! Server was very pleasant and attentive too!
One of our favorite places!
The pasta is amazing. Might want to skip the salad. Just a lot of greens with a couple small tomatoes. Very little dressing. Other than that everything else was excellent.
Thank you for seating is outside. We’ll be back!
Delicious dinner. Great vibe. Little pricey but a special treat. Never disappoints!
Great food and drinks. John, our server was great. He was very helpful with menu selections.
Best food best service our favorite places!!!
The delicious pasta will take your breath away. It was the best lasagna ever!
Loved it! Had a table outside on a gorgeous day. Every bite was delicious.
I honestly don’t know how an Italian restaurant down the street from a liquor store “runs out” of Prosecco, but they did. I don’t understand how any restaurant is “unable” to provide hot water for tea...but they were. Gorgeous pastas, lovely, fresh delicious presentations—Takeout might be the way to go.
The portions were very small and just not very good. We will not be returning.
Excellent meal and very good Italian wine list. Great service and our table allowed for easy conversation.
We really enjoy the food, we dine at Milano quite frequently and for some reason the service has really declined.
Great food and excellent service!
We always have had a very good experience but this time it was disappointing. The food was good as usual. However, the service was slow and it was noisy. We especially didn’t like it when the hostess went to seat us, she tried to seat us at a very small table. We asked to be seated at a larger table (a table for 4). She said OK but we had to be done eating in 1 1/2 hrs. There were plenty of tables available and always when we left in an 1 1/2 hr. We didn’t get it. We thought she was rude.
We've been here several times within the past couple of weeks! Great food, atmosphere, service and reasonable prices!
The hostess was short and rude. One of those dining in our party preferred to be seated away from large crowds due to health issues. When we asked to move to another table that was more isolated, and the hostess simply replied “Florida is at 100% capacity” and walked away. However, a waitress saw the issue we were having and offered to help. She found us a table that was isolated and wonderful. If it weren’t for her our experience would’ve been tarnished. We will come back but we felt that this needed to be discussed. Thank you for a wonderful evening!
Normally, every visit is wonderful with great service, excellent food, etc. On this day, we had a reservation at 3pm for their Happy Hour. Showed up at 3pm to a very long line outside of the restaurant. Never saw that before. We assumed these were people with no reservation hoping to "walk-in". We walked to the front, to the chorus of people in line yelling at us that there is a line, to let the restaurant know we had a reservation. We were greeted by someone (not sure if he was a server or ?) who told us, we had to get in line. He said it didn't matter that we had a reservation. Told us they were very busy (obviously) and were instead seating people according to when they arrived, whether they had a reservation or not. He would not even check us in. We stood in line for around 15 minutes. The line didn't move. No one checked with others in line to confirm reservations, so I'm sure we weren't the only people with reservations not honored at the time of arrival or even close. My husband walked in and found seats for us at the bar. At the bar, the bartender was very nice, provided excellent service and as usual the food was great. The restaurant allows people with reservations a 15 minute grace period to arrive for their seating. They should have at the very least checked us in upon arrival & acknowledged our reservation instead of refusing to do so & not seated people without reservations before people who took the time to make one. THEN they told Open Table we never showed up for the reservation! Clearly, they were very busy, possibly very understaffed as well. Their rep at the door should not have told us it didn't matter that we had a reservation and that they would only seat people based on when they arrived, even if they had no reservation. We were disappointed in the way the restaurant handled seating of people with reservations.Hopefully it was just a one off situation.
The bread is wonderful! Loved the truffle tortellini. My reservation was respected and sat on time.
We will happily return.
Very disorganized. My table was canceled. The food was only OK. I had the linguini with clams and the clams we small and over cooked.
Overall experience at caffe Milano was OK. Our service was good, but the food was just ok. I had fish and my husband had Chicken parm.
Overall dinner here was great. Restaurant was full but we were seated right away upon our arrival. Our server was very pleasant and helpful. He was prompt with taking our order and delivering the courses. The food was tasty well prepared. Only issue I had was the price of the Manhattan I ordered. Outrageously overpriced. Not cool.
Otherwise highly recommended.
Second time downtown and never disappoints. The carbonara is the best my husband has ever had. They usually have olives oil and fresh warm bread but out of the olives We sat outside and loved it even tho noisy Would definitely recommend
Beautiful decor, outstanding food, wonderful service
Caffe Milano does offer delivery in partnership with Uber Eats. Caffe Milano also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (239) 692-8480.
Caffe Milano is rated 4.6 stars by 1832 OpenTable diners.
Caffe Milano does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://caffemilano.localgiftcards.com/.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.