Calamari & Shrimp
Fried Calamari – Shrimp – Zucchini – Arrabbiata
Potato Dumpling – Fresh Tomato - Basil – Homemade Stracciatella Cheese
Tomato Sauce - Burrata - Basil
La mejor comida. Pasta carbonara envidiable 🥰 🥰🥰🥰
We sat on the sidewalk which was extremely crowded, a passerby’s dog literally stuck his head in my plate. Hostess did not acknowledge that we came for our reservation so Open Table sent me an email asking why I was a no show.
Good and service were outstanding. If you do get seated outside, try to sit on the street side.
Outside dining just okay
Natasha made our night! Awesome server who went out of her way to make our celebration special. Food was great! I recommend the eggplant appetizer and the gelato for dessert. Everything in between is always so yummy you won’t go wrong so enjoy the decision!
Very pleased with the service and the food,
the waitress was very kind same as the hostess
I will come back
had the special. It was excellent. Great service. Ashley was great
Always above and beyond. Food is excellent.
One of our favorite places!!! Manager and Maitre d always so accommodating and food consistently good!!!
Excellent food and service. Had the gelato for dessert. It was by far the best I have ever had.
Nice spot for lunch. We dined outside and was very enjoyable.
Food was excellent as always! Luigi gave us great service. Had the seafood pasta was new since we’ve been there was awesome!
Nice atmosphere. Good service. Some items were overcooked.
The food was delicious, service was slow
Definitely order the daily special. Two people in our party had the special (scallops) and it was perfect. My linguini was gummy and disappointing. The gnocchi that others ordered was bland. I expected better. The octopus appetizer was one of the best I've ever eaten. Other appetizers included the olives and the burrata and they were also delicious. For cocktails, the espresso martini was sublime!
Me encanto todo
Yesterday I ordered Sunday lunch special pasta in creamy sauce and seafood that included a small lobster tail. The dish must have been sitting in the kitchen for a while because the sauce had a dried out looks and so did the exposed mollusks in the half open shells. Pasta was lukewarm and in large clumps. This ruined the otherwise very tasty dish for me. Considered returning it but since it was very busy/crowded there I opted for just telling the server to let the Chef know. Did he? I don't know, no one came by our table to get the details. For that reason I am selecting NO to the question if I would recommend Cafe Milano to a friend, at least for a time being. Hope it was an isolated thing and I may come back one day.
Excellent! We ate outside on a bit chillier night but it didn't matter with the heat lamps..they were perfect for enough warmth. Service and food was amazing. The restaurant was super busy which is indicative of it's popularity.
Food was excellent service could have been better.
Food was outstanding!!!! Gnocchi was to die for and the portions are all very generous!
Food was outstanding, as usual. However, I made a reservation and there were no tables outside on the patio (the wait was an hour) and the AC inside the restaurant was off. It was ABSOLUTELY SWELTERING with no apology (in fact, when I brought it up to the server, she complained about how much worse it was for her because she had to work in it all day). After hearing that, I was surprised that nothing (not even fans) had been done about the situation all day. They managed to move us to a table closer to the front door because none of the windows opened and it was stifling in there. I was just surprised that they acted as though it was business as usual when it was horrendous (people at tables all around us were fanning themselves and the women were trying to do what they could to put their hair up.
Food took forever. Waiter argued it was our fault as we ordered pasta and not a sandwich.
Had to ask for refills. Restaurant is understaffed or mis managed.
Best French toast!
Food and service outstanding!!! Noise level high and very crowded.... but worth it!!!!
Purely delicious! What more can I say. Everything was amazing from drinks to atmosphere to food. Can’t wait to visit again soon.
Max was a very good waiter. Quick, and very good food
Natasha was a fantastic server, quite knowledgeable. Owner was gracious.
Good place. Very good food and drinks. Great service.
One of the best food and all freshly made , Pasta and sauce is the
best. Ending with the Gelato for two which actually can do tree or
four is the best I've ever had . We took our guests there three different
times and everyone loved it.
Will be going back end of month.
Food was delicious and our server Carmine was delightful!
We have been here many times and always enjoy the food and experience.
Love their lasagna. Our favorite go to Italian restaurant on 5th.
Great Food and service. Half price menu from
3-6 is hard to beat Would recommend
Service and food were exceptional. A little noisy because we ate outside. I would recommend this restaurant very highly.
Amazing food and service
Food was good, ariciniwas just ok.
We stopped at three for the half price menu and the outdoor seating. The food and service are always outstanding at cafe Milano.
Tiramisu is a must!
Caffe Milano does offer delivery in partnership with Uber Eats. Caffe Milano also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (239) 692-8480.
Caffe Milano is rated 4.6 stars by 1802 OpenTable diners.
Caffe Milano does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://caffemilano.localgiftcards.com/.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.