We had a lovely time. We arrived at 5:30pm on a Tuesday, and happy hour went until 6:00pm. The happy hour menu runs most of the day and is pretty extensive. Great value. I really liked the curry steamed mussels. Give it a try!

Happy hour fun. Menu had quite a bit of selection. Too bad it was too chilly for the patio. Grilled were a hit!

Should’ve avoided a Monday evening visit for the oyster special, knowing they were probably leftover from the weekend brunch scene. Had a horrendous night of GI trauma. Not going back.

amazing deal for .99 oysters on monday, a great hh selection. their elderflower basil martini is delicious! 10/10 recommend

Seems a little overpriced, all things considered

This place is always fantastic from service to food

Excellent place for a nice dinner. Highly recommend.

Absolutely amazing. Staff is always so courteous and polite, every single time. The food is always amazing. Oysters are always so fresh.

Incredible service and food from check in until closing our bill. Will be back!

Loved the vibe and ambiance. Main dish came out cold and had to be sent back. Waiter wasn’t timely with asking how thug were. Had to seek out waitstaff to resolve each time. Will try again ordering different food and different waiter.

We’ve eaten here numerous times and always come for the oysters. They never disappoint! You also can’t go wrong with Monday’s $1 oysters deal.

Good was absolutely amazing we tried the curry mussels magnificent and charred oysters as appetizers entree was the grilled salmon on a potatoe stack topped with a crab cake and asparagus to die for.

We love this place! Perfect for special occasions, as it's a little pricey for our budget, but so worth the splurge when we can!

Made our anniversary perfect, even gave a free dessert.

First time going there and we loved it great services and food was wonderful

We were seated as soon as we walked in the door. I had requested a table by a wall or window. Our table was the one by the opening to the outside. It was VERY noisy. Difficult to have a conversation. The food was excellent

Great selection of oysters (obviously), and salads and entrees are great too! Appreciated the attentive service.

I am a long-time patron of Blue Island. The best, dreshedt seafood in town.

We frequently dine here and are never disappointed. The food is consistently good, servers are friendly and knowledgeable, and the cocktails and wine list are solid.

We had oysters for an appetizer, and we both had an entree and some drinks. Everything was delicious and the service was good. We even found a parking spot in front of the restaurant. Enjoyable evening.

Food was amazing
Tables were a bit too close

Enjoyed a booth near the kitchen but away from other tables. The raw selection was awesome and delicious. Lovely white burgundy, great Caesar salad and killer clam chowder. Paella with halibut for entree. Portions were large so split everything with my date. Very nice time.

Host didn't give us the full menu. We sat there looking at half the menu. Right before we ordered the waiter noticed that we were not given the second page and was kind enough to make sure we had our full selection. Food was amazing.

A nice lunch starting with a few oysters, then on to seafood bisque with a couple of tacos and a slider. Everything was delicious and the service, as always, was great.

A moderately sized dining area with simple yet welcoming décor. The servers are attentive and fast. The classic martini made extra dirty with truffle salt on the rim is a must try. They have a supple selection of oysters on the half shell. The trout dip is a surprisingly delicious and shareable appetizer. The clam chowder is a creamy delight.

Amy was a great server and well informed and willing to answer questions. Great experience. Will be back for sure.

Had a very nice dinner & would go back but it was very noisy.

Great ambiance, and good service. Monday night $1 oysters were surprisingly good! New England clam chowder was great. Trout dip, crab cake and ricotta gnocchi's were nice. Calamari was good too. Jumbo shrimp cocktail was NOT even a little bit jumbo. Lobster was beyond overpriced. Most menu items were overpriced, but it was a nice night out. Probably will only return for Happy Hour or $1 oysters night again.

Many restaurants post pandemic have increased prices (totally understandable and we are happy to pay more) but the quality of the food has decreased. Not true here! Food still fantastic! Our "usual" choices are still top shelf at Blue Oyster. Yay!

Ate outside in a nice little patio. Food was excellent. We included in our reservation that we wanted to sit outside and were celebrating a birthday. It didn't seem like they saw those notes. We were able to eat outside and food and service was excellent.

The halibut was over cooked and the change to the tacos, keeping the shrimp and fish whole, makes them challenging to eat.

Great happy hour drinks and food. Food ordered off regular menu was overpriced and overcooked.

Great foor and a great waitress

Hope was an excellent server and made our evening very enjoyable

Excellent tacos and grilled oysters! Happy hour menu is a good value.

Oysters great! Everything else…too much sauce/dressing.

It was a phenomenal experience. We were seated immediately, our waitress was very attentive and helpful, and the food was delicious.

Excellent service and the drinks were superb

Friendly staff, good service
Happy hour was great! Some prices are a little high but others are good. I will keep going back

Claire, our server, was fantastic and gave us great recommendations! We loved our oysters and entrees and will definitely be back often!