Shelter Island Restaurants

Make a free reservation

View all 31669 restaurants in New York Area

Best American Restaurants in Shelter Island

Vine Street CafeVine Street Cafe
(865)
$$$$
American | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons
Highway Restaurant and BarHighway Restaurant and Bar
(355)
$$$$
American | East Hampton, Long Island / Hamptons
Coach Grill & TavernCoach Grill & Tavern
(94)
$$$$
American | Oyster Bay, Long Island / Hamptons
Heirloom TavernHeirloom Tavern
(656)
$$$$
American | Glen Head, Long Island / Hamptons
Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar, Huntington, NYPrime: An American Kitchen & Bar, Huntington, NY
(3750)
$$$$
American | Huntington, Long Island / Hamptons
Cove Hollow TavernCove Hollow Tavern
(72)
$$$$
American | East Hampton, Long Island / Hamptons
The Jamesport Manor InnThe Jamesport Manor Inn
(1241)
$$$$
American | Riverhead, Long Island / Hamptons
George Martin The OriginalGeorge Martin The Original
(1491)
$$$$
American | Rockville Centre, Long Island / Hamptons
OHK Bar & RestaurantOHK Bar & Restaurant
(1138)
$$$$
American | Huntington, Long Island / Hamptons
Swallow RestaurantSwallow Restaurant
(611)
$$$$
American | Huntington, Long Island / Hamptons
SandbarSandbar
(638)
$$$$
American | Cold Spring Harbor, Long Island / Hamptons
Almond - BridgehamptonAlmond - Bridgehampton
(875)
$$$$
American | Bridgehampton, Long Island / Hamptons
Sullivan's QuaySullivan's Quay
(49)
$$$$
American | Port Washington, Long Island / Hamptons
Mill Pond HouseMill Pond House
(1713)
$$$$
American | Centerport, Long Island / Hamptons

Best Italian Restaurants in Shelter Island

The TrattoriaThe Trattoria
(744)
$$$$
Italian | St. James, Long Island / Hamptons
King Umberto RestaurantKing Umberto Restaurant
(709)
$$$$
Italian | Elmont, Long Island / Hamptons
Trattoria DiMeoTrattoria DiMeo
(311)
$$$$
Italian | Roslyn, Long Island / Hamptons
Sant Ambroeus - SouthamptonSant Ambroeus - Southampton
(93)
$$$$
Italian | Southampton, Long Island / Hamptons
Tutto Il Giorno - SouthamptonTutto Il Giorno - Southampton
(154)
$$$$
Italian | Hamptons, Long Island / Hamptons
La Ginestra - NYLa Ginestra - NY
(174)
$$$$
Italian | Glen Cove, Long Island / Hamptons
Ciro's Italian Restaurant - Kings ParkCiro's Italian Restaurant - Kings Park
(408)
$$$$
Italian | Kings Park, Long Island / Hamptons
Cipollini Trattoria and BarCipollini Trattoria and Bar
(773)
$$$$
Italian | Manhasset, Long Island / Hamptons
Uva RossaUva Rossa
(445)
$$$$
Italian | Malverne, Long Island / Hamptons
Piccolo Restaurant of HuntingtonPiccolo Restaurant of Huntington
(830)
$$$$
Italian | Huntington, Long Island / Hamptons
Il Luogo RistoranteIl Luogo Ristorante
(712)
$$$$
Italian | Rockville Centre, Long Island / Hamptons
Andrea's 25 of CommackAndrea's 25 of Commack
(726)
$$$$
Italian | Commack, Long Island / Hamptons

Popular restaurants in New York Area

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New York Area

HAVEN Riverfront Restaurant and Bar
(391)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Edgewater
Serafina 105
(110)
$$$$
Italian | Upper West Side
Shaking Crab - Upper West Side
(124)
$$$$
Cajun | Upper West Side
View all New York Area restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Shelter Island restaurants.

Shelter Island Restaurants

Vine Street CafeVine Street Cafe
865 reviews
$$$$
American | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

I have stopped ordering scallops at Restaurants because they are usually overcooked or just not that flavorful. The scallops here were presented in the shell in a light but delicious sauce with spinach and bacon but were perfectly cooked. The other dishes (filet and tuna tartare) were also perfectly cooked and were accompanied with tasty sauces that complemented but did not overpower the main dish. More

OpenTable Diner -
SALT Shelter IslandSALT Shelter Island
194 reviews
$$$$
Seafood | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

Great water front restaurant in a beautiful waterfront location. Good food, good service and great location. More

OpenTable Diner -

Shelter Island Diners' Choice Winners

Shelter Island's best restaurants based upon thousands of OpenTable diner reviews
Vine Street CafeVine Street Cafe
865 reviews
$$$$
American | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

I have stopped ordering scallops at Restaurants because they are usually overcooked or just not that flavorful. The scallops here were presented in the shell in a light but delicious sauce with spinach and bacon but were perfectly cooked. The other dishes (filet and tuna tartare) were also perfectly cooked and were accompanied with tasty sauces that complemented but did not overpower the main dish. More

OpenTable Diner -
SALT Shelter IslandSALT Shelter Island
194 reviews
$$$$
Seafood | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

Great water front restaurant in a beautiful waterfront location. Good food, good service and great location. More

OpenTable Diner -
Caci Shelter IslandCaci Shelter Island
47 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

Nice room, nice server, pricy. Eating on Island’s is always pricey. More

OpenTable Diner -
Pridwin HotelPridwin Hotel
80 reviews
$$$$
American | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

Exceptional menu, great ambience, music, staff and food! More

OpenTable Diner -
Red Maple at The ChequitRed Maple at The Chequit
105 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

We love this Restaurant in SI. The carrots were raw with the chicken dish. The broth with the mussels was like water. The waitress was very slow with the orders. Overall the food is usually delicious . More

OpenTable Diner -