Shelter Island Restaurants

Make a free reservation

Quick Search:All 31822 restaurants in New York Area

Best American Restaurants in Shelter Island

View all

Best American Restaurants in Shelter Island

Vine Street Cafe

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-threequarterCreated with Sketch.
879 reviews
American$$$$Shelter Island
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 16 times today

Highway Restaurant and Bar

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-threequarterCreated with Sketch.
369 reviews
American$$$$East Hampton
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 41 times today

Coach Grill & Tavern

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-threequarterCreated with Sketch.
102 reviews
American$$$Oyster Bay
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 4 times today

Heirloom Tavern

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-threequarterCreated with Sketch.
681 reviews
American$$Glen Head
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 24 times today

Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar, Huntington, NY

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-threequarterCreated with Sketch.
3820 reviews
American$$$$Huntington
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 69 times today

Cove Hollow Tavern

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-quarterCreated with Sketch.
82 reviews
American$$$East Hampton
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 13 times today

The Jamesport Manor Inn

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-halfCreated with Sketch.
1264 reviews
American$$$Riverhead
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 0 times today

George Martin The Original

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-threequarterCreated with Sketch.
1531 reviews
American$$$Rockville Centre
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 36 times today

OHK Bar & Restaurant

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-threequarterCreated with Sketch.
1207 reviews
American$$$$Huntington
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 44 times today

Swallow Restaurant

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-quarterCreated with Sketch.
633 reviews
American$$$Huntington
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 17 times today

Sandbar

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-threequarterCreated with Sketch.
679 reviews
American$$$Cold Spring Harbor
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 32 times today

Almond - Bridgehampton

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-threequarterCreated with Sketch.
891 reviews
American$$$Bridgehampton
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 32 times today

Sullivan's Quay

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-quarterCreated with Sketch.
61 reviews
American$$Port Washington
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 8 times today

Mill Pond House

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-threequarterCreated with Sketch.
1753 reviews
American$$$Centerport
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 37 times today

Best Italian Restaurants in Shelter Island

View all

Best Italian Restaurants in Shelter Island

King Umberto Restaurant

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-threequarterCreated with Sketch.
741 reviews
Italian$$Elmont
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 15 times today

Trattoria DiMeo

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-threequarterCreated with Sketch.
335 reviews
Italian$$$Roslyn
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 29 times today

Sant Ambroeus - Southampton

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-threequarterCreated with Sketch.
96 reviews
Italian$$$$Southampton
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 2 times today

Tutto Il Giorno - Southampton

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-threequarterCreated with Sketch.
162 reviews
Italian$$$Hamptons
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 8 times today

La Ginestra - NY

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-threequarterCreated with Sketch.
192 reviews
Italian$$$Glen Cove
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 12 times today

Ciro's Italian Restaurant - Kings Park

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-threequarterCreated with Sketch.
432 reviews
Italian$$Kings Park
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 13 times today

Cipollini Trattoria and Bar

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-threequarterCreated with Sketch.
822 reviews
Italian$$$Manhasset
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 26 times today

Uva Rossa

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-threequarterCreated with Sketch.
470 reviews
Italian$$$Malverne
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 20 times today

Piccolo Restaurant of Huntington

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-threequarterCreated with Sketch.
863 reviews
Italian$$$$Huntington
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 16 times today

Il Luogo Ristorante

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-threequarterCreated with Sketch.
739 reviews
Italian$$Rockville Centre
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 14 times today

Andrea's 25 of Commack

Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.Star_8_Created with Sketch.star-threequarterCreated with Sketch.
757 reviews
Italian$$$Commack
icon/ic_social_proofCreated with Sketch.
Booked 19 times today

Popular restaurants in New York Area

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New York Area
HAVEN Riverfront Restaurant and Bar
(278)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Edgewater
Serafina 105
(116)
$$$$
Italian | Upper West Side
OFFER
View all New York Area restaurants

Popular Neighborhoods

Dine in the most popular neighborhoods
Midtown West
Find a restaurant
Midtown East
Find a restaurant
Theater District / Times Square
Find a restaurant

Treat your taste buds: Explore Shelter Island restaurants.

Shelter Island Restaurants

Vine Street CafeVine Street Cafe
879 reviews
$$$$
American | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

Delicious if a bit pricey. Great service and menu. More

OpenTable Diner -
SALT Shelter IslandSALT Shelter Island
194 reviews
$$$$
Seafood | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

Great water front restaurant in a beautiful waterfront location. Good food, good service and great location. More

OpenTable Diner -

Your Local Dining Scene

OpenTable Gifts gift cards for restaurants!
Jan. 26 - Feb. 10, 2019
$10 - $35 Menus
3-Course Prix-Fixe
$29.95 Dinners
Find New York Area Private Dining Venues
Valentine's Day Special Menus & More
$26 Lunch | $42 Dinner
Enjoy 3-Course Menus
San Antonio Restaurant Week
$35 & $45 Dinners
Earn Free Meals Faster - 1,000-Point Tables
Hudson Restaurant Week
Jan. 28 - Feb. 8, 2019
Find Hot New Restaurants Near You!
OpenTable Mobile: Free Apps For Your Phone!
Business Bites - Weekday Lunches
Gluten-Free Dining - Restaurants & Menus
Group Dining - Tables for 8 to 20
Outdoor Dining - Al Fresco Dining
Sunday Brunch - Restaurants & Menus
DiRoNA Winners - Dine Where the Chefs Dine
James Beard Award Winners & Finalists 2017
OpenTable Insider Picks for NYC
Vegan & Vegetarian Friendly Dining Options
Artisanal Cocktails - Lists with a Twist
Free Corkage & BYOB - Bring Your Own Drink
Napa Valley Vintners Wine Program
Theatre Menus - Book Pre & Post-Show Tables
James Beard Awards Winners & Finalists 2016

Cities Nearby Shelter Island

    • See more cities near Shelter Island

    More Cities Nearby Shelter Island

    • What's your craving? Search by cuisine
    steakdessertfishseafooditaliandining barporkmeatsushifrenchwine barsteakhousebottle servicevegetarianburgers
    Explore the best restaurants near you
    lunchromanticbrunchfuncozycasualspecial occasionsseasonaldate nightlive musicfireplacetasting menuhappy houroutdoor dininggluten free
    Dining around Shelter Island Hot Spots
    Landmark

    Landmark

    1. Palmer House
    2. City Island
    3. Greenport Basin
    4. New London Harbor Light
    5. Goose Island
    Shopping area

    Shopping area

    1. Valley Shopping Center
    2. Saks Fifth Avenue
    3. Tanger Outlets Riverhead
    4. Southington Shopping Center
    5. Bayshore Shopping Center
    Train Station

    Train Station

    1. Quogue Station
    2. New Haven CT Station - Metro North Train Station
    3. Wainscott Station
    4. Stratford Station
    5. Fairfield Station
    Stadium or Arena

    Stadium or Arena

    1. Mohegan Sun Arena
    2. Basketball
    3. Handball
    4. Soccer Field
    5. University Field
    Institution

    Institution

    1. Trinity College
    2. Yale University
    3. Wesleyan University
    4. Eastern Connecticut State University
    5. Central Brooklyn Jazz Consortium
    Monument

    Monument

    1. Essex Island Marina
    2. Ninigret
    3. Rainmaker Statue
    Museum

    Museum

    1. The Museum
    2. Mystic Seaport
    3. Southampton Historical Museum
    4. Amistad
    5. Florence Griswold Museum
    Park

    Park

    1. Monroe Green
    2. Essex Square
    3. Occum Playground
    4. Avon Park
    5. High Park
    Hotel / Lodging

    Hotel / Lodging

    1. Hilton Garden Inn Mystic/Groton
    2. Hilton Garden Inn Riverhead
    3. Madison Beach Hotel, Curio Collection by Hilton
    4. SpringHill Suites by Marriott Waterford / Mystic
    5. Mystic Marriott Hotel and Spa
    Nearby Cities

    Nearby Cities

    1. Southold, NY
    2. Springs, NY
    3. Old Saybrook, CT
    4. Hampton Bays, NY
    5. Madison, CT
    View All