Shelter Island Restaurants

I have stopped ordering scallops at Restaurants because they are usually overcooked or just not that flavorful. The scallops here were presented in the shell in a light but delicious sauce with spinach and bacon but were perfectly cooked. The other dishes (filet and tuna tartare) were also perfectly cooked and were accompanied with tasty sauces that complemented but did not overpower the main dish. More

OpenTable Diner - 11/10/2018

Great water front restaurant in a beautiful waterfront location. Good food, good service and great location. More

OpenTable Diner - 09/29/2018

Nice room, nice server, pricy. Eating on Island’s is always pricey. More

OpenTable Diner - 09/23/2018

Exceptional menu, great ambience, music, staff and food! More

OpenTable Diner - 08/28/2018

We love this Restaurant in SI. The carrots were raw with the chicken dish. The broth with the mussels was like water. The waitress was very slow with the orders. Overall the food is usually delicious . More

OpenTable Diner - 08/24/2018