6 Best Seafood Restaurants In Shelter Island

6 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of The Halyard Restaurant at Sound View restaurant

1. The Halyard Restaurant at Sound View

4.4

Awesome(1598)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Greenport

Booked 16 times today

The Halyard Restaurant at Sound View in Greenport offers an unparalleled seafood experience that captures the essence of Long Island’s North Fork. Renowned for its fresh, local ingredients, diners rave about the "divine scallops" and the "delicious and interesting" tuna tartare, which showcase the authentic flavors of the sea. The restaurant's commitment to quality is evident in every dish, earning glowing reviews for both its culinary excellence and breathtaking views of the Long Island Sound. Whether enjoying the "amazing sunset" or savoring the perfectly prepared mussels and crab cakes, guests are guaranteed a memorable dining experience at The Halyard.

2. Noah's

4.7

Exceptional(2242)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Greenport

Booked 14 times today

Noah's in Greenport is a seafood lover's paradise, celebrated for its fresh, authentic dishes that highlight the bounty of Long Island's North Fork and East End. Diners rave about the "perfectly curated and executed" menu, which changes daily to feature the freshest local catch and seasonal ingredients. Standout dishes like the "best NE Clam Chowder," "crab cakes pure crab with no bread fillers," and "fantastic clam pasta" showcase the restaurant's commitment to quality. Guests are consistently impressed with the "outstanding service" and the inviting ambiance that makes every visit to Noah's an unforgettable experience. It's no wonder Noah's is a beloved destination for both locals and visitors alike.

A photo of Claudio's Waterfront restaurant

3. Claudio's Waterfront

3.7

Very Good(58)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Greenport

Booked 32 times today

Welcome to Claudio’s Waterfront, your Dockside Drinks and Dining destination! Located on the water, in historic Greenport harbor, Claudio’s Waterfront serves the freshest seafood and seasonal fare, celebrating the flavors of the region and the Rich maritime history of this storied locale. Join us to create your own salt-air, sun-kissed summer vibe experience, with the best happy Hour in town, Sunday brunch, Live music on the weekends, or an unforgettable sunset dinner seaside. Days roll into nights at Claudio’s… Sail or stroll over for a Dockin’ Good time!

A photo of The Terrace at the Pridwin restaurant

4. The Terrace at the Pridwin

4.3

Awesome(177)

Price: Very Expensive

• Seafood • Shelter Island

Booked 11 times today

The Terrace at the Pridwin is a seafood lover's paradise nestled on Shelter Island, offering a dining experience that is both exquisite and authentic. The restaurant's commitment to quality is evident in its use of fresh, locally sourced ingredients, ensuring that each dish bursts with flavor. Diners can revel in “the best linguine with clam sauce ever” and delight in the perfectly crispy Fritto Misto. The lobster roll, served on a homemade brioche bun, is a standout, described as a “buttery compliment to the lobster.” With its breathtaking views over Crescent Beach and impeccable service, The Terrace promises an unforgettable seafood dining adventure.

A photo of The Restaurant at Baron's Cove restaurant

5. The Restaurant at Baron's Cove

4.8

Exceptional(73)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Sag Harbor

Booked 14 times today

The Restaurant at Baron's Cove in Sag Harbor is a seafood lover's paradise, offering an authentic and delightful dining experience. Renowned for its succulent fish dishes and buttery lobster rolls, this award-winning establishment takes pride in using fresh, locally sourced ingredients that elevate its classic American fare to new heights. Guests rave about the "excellent food and environment," and the "lovely waitress, delicious lobster roll" that make every visit memorable. With stunning harbor views from the second floor, dining here is not just a meal, but a sensory feast. Experience seafood at its finest in this picturesque setting.

A photo of Captain Jack's On The Coast restaurant

6. Captain Jack's On The Coast

4.6

Exceptional(3)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Southampton

Booked 10 times today

Escape to Captain Jack's on the Coast, a waterfront haven where culinary delights meet stunning views. Enjoy fresh, locally sourced seafood prepared with a Southern flair. Try our award-winning NE Clam Chowder or savor smoked jumbo wings seasoned with lemon pepper dust, served with sautéed cherry peppers and onions. As you dine, take in the breathtaking vistas of Peconic Marina and Wooley Pond. Our nautically rustic ambiance and warm hospitality, ensures an unforgettable experience. Whether you're planning a romantic evening or a lively gathering with friends, Captain Jack's on the Coast promises a memorable culinary adventure.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Best Seafood Restaurants in Shelter Island

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

6 restaurants available nearby

1. The Halyard Restaurant at Sound View

2. Noah's

3. Claudio's Waterfront

4. The Terrace at the Pridwin

5. The Restaurant at Baron's Cove

6. Captain Jack's On The Coast

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable