Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York State

Best Seafood Restaurants in Shelter Island

Price
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility

110 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Noah's restaurant
1. Noah's
4.6
Exceptional(2326)
$$$$
• Seafood • Greenport
Booked 18 times today
Noah's in Greenport is a seafood lover's paradise, celebrated for its fresh, authentic dishes that highlight the bounty of Long Island's North Fork and East End. Diners rave about the "perfectly curated and executed" menu, which changes daily to feature the freshest local catch and seasonal ingredients. Standout dishes like the "best NE Clam Chowder," "crab cakes pure crab with no bread fillers," and "fantastic clam pasta" showcase the restaurant's commitment to quality. Guests are consistently impressed with the "outstanding service" and the inviting ambiance that makes every visit to Noah's an unforgettable experience. It's no wonder Noah's is a beloved destination for both locals and visitors alike.
A photo of The Terrace at the Pridwin restaurant
2. The Terrace at the Pridwin
4.4
Awesome(265)
$$$$
• Seafood • Shelter Island
Booked 57 times today
The Terrace at the Pridwin is a seafood lover's paradise nestled on Shelter Island, offering a dining experience that is both exquisite and authentic. The restaurant's commitment to quality is evident in its use of fresh, locally sourced ingredients, ensuring that each dish bursts with flavor. Diners can revel in “the best linguine with clam sauce ever” and delight in the perfectly crispy Fritto Misto. The lobster roll, served on a homemade brioche bun, is a standout, described as a “buttery compliment to the lobster.” With its breathtaking views over Crescent Beach and impeccable service, The Terrace promises an unforgettable seafood dining adventure.
A photo of Port Waterfront Bar and Grill restaurant
3. Port Waterfront Bar and Grill
new
4.6
Exceptional(8)
$$$$
• Seafood • Greenport
Booked 24 times today
Fresh and innovative menu. Outdoor dining, live music, creative tiki-style cocktails.
A photo of The Halyard Restaurant at Sound View restaurant
4. The Halyard Restaurant at Sound View
4.6
Exceptional(1761)
$$$$
• Seafood • Greenport
Booked 32 times today
The Halyard Restaurant at Sound View in Greenport offers an unparalleled seafood experience that captures the essence of Long Island’s North Fork. Renowned for its fresh, local ingredients, diners rave about the "divine scallops" and the "delicious and interesting" tuna tartare, which showcase the authentic flavors of the sea. The restaurant's commitment to quality is evident in every dish, earning glowing reviews for both its culinary excellence and breathtaking views of the Long Island Sound. Whether enjoying the "amazing sunset" or savoring the perfectly prepared mussels and crab cakes, guests are guaranteed a memorable dining experience at The Halyard.
A photo of SALT Shelter Island restaurant
5. SALT Shelter Island
new
4.7
Exceptional(204)
$$$$
• Seafood • Shelter Island
Booked 23 times today
The story of SALT started with Keith and Ali's love for Shelter Island. SALT was designed as a come as you are restaurant with a focus on fresh and local foods, that anyone can enjoy. They wanted to create a place they would want to go for dinner or drinks and find friendly service from other people who live and love Shelter Island. We treat locals like celebrities and celebrities like locals!
A photo of Anker restaurant
6. Anker
4.4
Awesome(21)
$$$$
• Seafood • Greenport
Booked 5 times today
We are a local, seasonal American seafood restaurant and market located in the heart of Greenport, NY, highlighting the best of North Fork farms and fisheries. Our menu reflects the day's catch and weekly harvest - light, bright, clean flavors - meant to complement the beautiful views of the Peconic Bay on our upstairs covered deck. On the beverage side, guests can expect a mix of classic and seasonal cocktails, craft beers and thoughtfully-selected wines. Offering one of the finest harbor views in Greenport from our second floor patio, the restaurant's design is intended to carry guests away. We hope to welcome you for lunch or dinner soon!
A photo of The Bell & Anchor restaurant
7. The Bell & Anchor
4.9
Exceptional(630)
$$$$
• Seafood • Sag Harbor
Booked 75 times today
In 2012, The Bell & Anchor opened for its first summer. Now, open for much more and much longer than just summer: the waterside Sag Harbor restaurant conceived and operated by David Loewenberg & Sam McCleland stands firmly along side its sister restaurant, the Beacon. At The Bell & Anchor, you'll experience food and wine with deep flavors and textures. The restaurant pulls its inspiration from the rich & deep history Sag Harbor, Noyac, Peconic & the region offer: local seafood, steak, beer, vegetables, and wine. Enjoy!We offer reservations online for our dining room, bar, and patio. Reservations can be made up to two weeks in advance.
A photo of The Palm East Hampton restaurant
8. The Palm East Hampton
4.6
Exceptional(1150)
$$$$
• Seafood • East Hampton
Booked 44 times today
The Palm East Hampton, nestled inside the charming Huntting Inn, offers a seafood cuisine that truly delights the senses. Diners rave about the "amazing lobster" and "delicious fish," praising the restaurant for its exceptional quality and fresh flavors. Guests consistently highlight the "fantastic" service and welcoming atmosphere, noting that every visit is a memorable experience. The Palm's lobster dinner for two is particularly popular, offering "great food and great value" in a stunning setting. As a staple in East Hampton, The Palm's commitment to authentic and fresh seafood makes it a must-visit destination for seafood lovers.
A photo of The Old Mill restaurant
9. The Old Mill
4.7
Exceptional(216)
$$$$
• Seafood • Mattituck
Booked 32 times today
Built circa 1820 as a grist mill, The Old Mill Inn is a newly-renovated historic, waterfront, adults-only (18 years+) bar and restaurant on Mattituck Creek, located on the North Fork of Long Island. It serves classic American fare with a fresh local twist such as fish & chips, crispy squid, oysters, cheese burgers, and seasonal local vegetables.The past and the present collide inside the historic bar room (serving seasonal craft cocktails, wine and beer-on-tap) where the mill's original gear shaft stands among the wooden ceiling beams signed by past patrons, dating back to the late 1800s. The new owner received the award for Historical Renovation of the Year from the Long Island Preservation Society in 2024.
A photo of Gigi’s Montauk restaurant
10. Gigi’s Montauk
4.6
Exceptional(222)
$$$$
• Seafood • Montauk
Booked 90 times today
Since its founding in 1926, Gurney’s Montauk has been a beloved destination for Long Islanders, New Yorkers, and travelers from around the world seeking an iconic, year-round escape by the sea. In Summer 2025, Gurney’s proudly unveils its first-ever flagship restaurant: Gigi’s Montauk. Offering both indoor and outdoor seaside dining, Gigi’s will feature a refined menu of New-American Coastal Cuisine, celebrating the spirit of Montauk with fresh, seasonal ingredients and elevated waterfront hospitality.
‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you

Explore OpenTable

Discover
OpenTable
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Press
More
Our sites
Businesses
  • Restaurant Management Solutions
  • Restaurant Reservation Software
  • Restaurant Marketing Software
  • Restaurant Event Software
  • OpenTable For Restaurants
  • OpenTable For Restaurant Groups
  • Restaurant Resources
  • OpenTable Pricing & Plans
Join us on
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2026 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 500, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo