Best Casual Restaurants in Shelter Island

I had such a relaxing evening dining here. Though it was unexpectedly very busy for a Tuesday night, management and the servers we all doing a great job throughout the night. My server Jen was so polite and sweet and genuinely cared about my experience. Thank you guys!

Fantastic meal! Our server Ernesto was absolutely wonderful and knowledgable about all the fabulous dishes and specials. His service was excellent and he has a lovely way about him. All the staff were fantastic! We are so happy to have this gem in Greenport. Drinks were delicious as well. Looking forward to going back very soon

Fun atmosphere. Food was good but $46 for a lobster roll and it was pretty small. I would have given a better rating but the women’s bathrooms were disgusting. None of the stalls had toilet paper and someone had to go get an employee to restock. Definitely not typical for someplace that charges so much for food.

Great service and Our meals were excellent! Always a great experience.

Great restaurant, exceptional service and good food!