Los mejores restaurantes casuales en Shelter Island

Great, shareable menu. Very nice service. Love the martinis! Great location, although no water view. We go back again and again for the quality.

Great restaurant, exceptional service and good food!

The service was excellent, the food was delicious, and the view was spectacular, particularly the sunset!

Claudio's has always been consistent; bustling with good food.

It's nice to have something a little different in the area! Seafood, kebabs, spices I rarely heard of drew me to this restaurant. OH! ..and they're open on a Wednesday. It looks like they mostly worked out the kinks for a new restaurant. Staff was abundant, super lovely and eager to assist and check in on you. Food was hands down fantastic! Our calamari had spicy peppers and little bits of cuminy sausage. The octopus was grilled PERFECTLY and plated well. The lamb chops were also delish, albeit over cooked. We asked for medium rare and they were close to medium well. No matter, they were still juicy and I was gnawing on the bone. My only tiiiny complaint was the NYC prices of cocktails ($40 for two Gin and tonics) and lack of beer selection. Otherwise their cocktail list was great. I would be happy to return the next time I'm in town.