Catskill Restaurants

Consistently delicious and innovative. Great right menu and always interesting specials from drinks to appetizers, mains and desserts. Wonderfully locally sourced and always. Pleasure to be there.

Service was a bit lacking, bit did not deter from a great overall experience and night out.

I’m a repeat enthusiastic reviewer of our beloved Wm Farmer & Sons; we have been coming for special dinners since we first moved to the area in 2017… indeed, our dinner there the day we toured our home was the first of many. Allow me to say that last night’s birthday dinner with our favorite server was among if not the absolute best. Thank you again and again for your thoughtful, welcoming, pleasant service, beautiful, understated atmosphere and unparalleled seasonal menu that never ceases to satisfy and inspire. We’re so grateful for you!

JayLynn was an excellent server! The food was not only delicious but beautifully presented. Unfortunately, the ambiance of the previously elegant dining room was radically changed to barn-like with walls covered in rough-hewn pine. A truly spectacular setting by the falls was ruined. There were so many other ways to bring the Blackbarn vibe to the setting that would have cost less but retained the paper mill charm.

We stayed at the Stewart House for 2 nights and ate there for dinner each night. The food was delicious both nights. They were busy but gave us attention and treated us well. The menu had so much to choose from, including a carefully picked wine list. The appetizers, main courses and desserts were all great. Fish, steak and veggies all cooked perfectly. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay and our meals. The Stewart House is truly a special place!