Nick's Fishmarket Maui

Food and service very good. Staff friendly. Were not thrilled by our table location, but every restaurant has a few less than desirable tables. We chose not to make a fuss.

Beautiful atmosphere,but no view of the ocean. Food was average, not worth the money!

Absolutely awesome service, and the food was so good

Perfect from start to finish the team who took care of us Leon, Beau, Guy and Chris did everything possible to make our evening a wonderful experience.

Greeted wonderfully by bartenders. Went totally down hill from there. Have eaten at nicks many many times They are not even close to the way they were run before. We’re shown to the group room. As a table of 2 were ignored. Given menus and no wine list then did not see a person other than water person who was the most helpful of the night, for 20 minutes not a person came by. Had to flag down the waiter to get him to take our order. After getting him to pay attention to us we were able to order. Compare this to when they used to pride themselves on fast service by multiple servers. Those days are over! FOOD. Just average not worth the price. Think long and hard before trying Nicks Fishmarket at the Kai Lani.

Reservation for four ready on time. Cozy table. Food was so yummy! Loved the Caesar Salad, the seafood chowder. Brûlée yummy too! Kama Aina discount for locals as well. The Kea Lani hotel that it is situated in is beautiful as well!

Nicks is the best dining experience on Maui. Food, Service,ambiance could not be better.

Vacation very good food but very nice and overpriced

We went to Nick's for our anniversary. Our first visit. The hostess station was crowded and customers were lined up to get in. They were not ready. We were seated at a very nice table near the lawn. It was very nice. The waiter came before too long and helped us make dinner selection decisions. He was helpful and pleasant. Dinner arrived before too long and all looked good until the steak was cut into and it was not medium rare but closer to medium well. The waiter was nowhere to be seen and after way too long I went to the hostess and asked if she could send over our waiter. The manager arrived and was most apologetic. The steak was eaten as served rather than wait for a new one. The other dishes, calamare, fish chowder, etc. were very good. The rest of the evening went well. The apple pie was very good. The manager did not charge for the overcooked steak which we asked him not to do but he did anyway. The meal was expensive from our point of view but the setting was good and we enjoyed ourselves. We might go back again but there are plenty of great places in this price range to include Mama's and Ko. With that said, our next visit to Nick's could be a long time from the first visit.

Highly recommend this spot! Best service I've had at a restaurant and the mahi mahi was amazing. Make a point to go! They are able to accommodate gluten free as well they made me fresh gluten free bread and it was delicious!

It was great the food was perfect. Waiters are fun and they gave us a bonus dessert and it was great. Definitely recommend it!

Being a black male with his black companion, seated in the rear of a restaurant that was filled with 40-50% white, was very uncomfortable. The waiter didn't offer a menu, my lady reached over to a stand next to our table to retrieve a menu. Several waiters looked as if something was wrong as we sat to eat.

We good food with creative ingredients and generous portions. Service was spotty (long stretches with no one showing up to take drink orders for example) but pleasant.

Amazing!! The service was among the best I have ever experienced. Attentive staff - seemed to be 3 people waiting on us! Table next to us had a young, tired child and 2 waiters pushed together two chairs, swept a tablecloth and pillows in it and made a bed for the child to lay in!!! As the mom of 3, I was impressed. It kept the scene peaceful and relaxed for everyone.

We began in the bar for happy hour for great Poke and drinks. The bartender, Raoul, was great. It was a busy bar and he was friendly and had a sense of what everyone needed at any time.

We moved to our restaurant table where Cheston, Avi and one other (sorry! Didn’t get name!) all served us. Bread was brought and they had a peppery flatbread that was amazing! We split the Caesar salad- probably the best we ever had! For the main course my husband got the 14 oz steak which was great. I got the shrimp scampi with homemade pasta and large shrimp. Everything was DELICIOUS. Service was spectacular! Can’t wait to return!

Wonderful dinner

If you want a fantastic meal with outstanding service Nick’s Fish Market is your place. We have gone every year for the past 4 years and it’s one of our favorites!

Nick's Fishmarket capped off our week in Maui and we could not have hoped for a better experience. The food and service were excellent. Dessert was fantastic!! Would definitely recommend. Our server, Bo, made the evening a delight.

Overall everything was fantastic, we went there for my wife’s birthday. The only complaint I have is that we were halfway through our pupu’s before we received our drinks.

Chris is a great server

Nice wine list and very Hugh quality food.

Fantastic scenery! Love the food!

Great /service, great food and ambience. we had a great ime and evening. It was wonderful.

Very poor inattentive service
Too bad as food was excellent

Amazing Macadamia Nut Crusted Mahi Mahi .Going back again before we leave.

We have come here for years this was our worst experience. The service was horrible we had about 4 different people come up and ask us what we wanted then never return . This happened with drinks,wine order etc. then when my Ahi tuna came it was not editable. Could not even cut it with a knife. Someone came by and I complained so he took it away and after a while returned with a new entree ,it was better but not as good as I have eaten at other places on Maui. Then we had to wait and wait for our bill.



Ad

We have eaten at Nick’s Fish Market on multiple occasions. We have been very fortunate to have Guy as our server on most of them. He is unbelievable, makes an ordinary experience incredible. the rest of the staff is also great, the food is very good.

Seared tuna was excellent ! View was great - but would have been better earlier- sunset

It was our 2nd time here on this particular trip to Maui and both times we have had superb food and service. We couldn't have asked for a better dining situation. We make a habit of going Nick's at least once during our visit to Maui.

Always try to eat at Nick ‘s when in Maui and it never disappoints. Food is amazing and staff’s attention to detail impeccable.

We had a delicious and relaxing dinner at Nick's. Our server was very helpful. The setting was very nice with open air seating. Will go back soon!

Back room away from open deck area is not so nice.

Expensive , even the wines and desserts are overpriced

Lovely place. Deliciousand great selection

Not only is the food here delicious the service was a perfect example how how restaurants should run. Cyrus was our head waiter and took excellent care of us but it felt as if all the staff was there to assist in what was truly one of the best serviced meals I have ever experienced. Multiple people came by to wish me a happy birthday, explain to us their favorite items and answer all our questions. After much deliberation we started with the calamari which was a hearty portion, along with the pork wontons which were a new delight for us. The scampi was divine, the steak melted in our mouths and the Mahi Mahi was seasoned and crusted to perfection. Our drinks never went dry, we left full and with the feeling that we had just made several new friends. Would reccomend 10 out of 10 times.

Nice restaurant. Food was extremely tasty! We received a free dessert as it was our baby moon which was a lovely surprise. Food was a little expensive.
Quick service.
My virgin cocktail (mojito) was terrible so I ended up sending it back, but the second attempt to make it was much better.

Food left a lot to be desired for the price. Flavorless. Great service but way over priced. We have had better food at less expensive restaurants. I would not recommend this place nor would I return.

Great tasting food with fair prices. Wait staff were pretty good-could have had more people for how busy it was.

Wonderfully created dishes. Macadamia mahi mahi, lobster mac. In each dish the rich flavor permeated the whole meal, down to the last bite. Bring lots of money, eat like a king.

Great ambiance. Beau was our waiter and he was fantastic! The food and service was amazing! Highly recommend Nicks!

Great location and great food and superior service

Awesome! From the service to the menu to the preparation and flavors...all fabulous!