New Castle Restaurants
Make a free reservation
See what locals rave about in New Castle
- SSusanWashington, D.C. Area •1 review5.0Dined 3 days agoGreat evening with friends. Love the ambience and intimacy of this wonderful gem.More infoCatello's Italian Art Cuisine - PendletonPrice: Moderate• Italian• Fishers•4.7
- JJonIndiana •3 reviews5.0Dined 3 days agoIt’s a nice place to have a nice meal. It’s easy to get to. Nice people and great service. I would recommend this restaurant. $$$$More infoRon Lahody's Steakhouse of AndersonPrice: Moderate• Steakhouse• Anderson•4.7
- DdonaVIPChicago / Illinois •19 reviews5.0Dined 4 days agoAlways a great meal and wonderful service at St Elmo’sMore infoSt. Elmo Steak HousePrice: Expensive• Steak• Downtown Indy•4.7
- MMarciaIndiana •2 reviews5.0Dined on Jun 7, 2025Lindsey was awesome .. very attentive and knowledgeable…More infoHomestretch Steakhouse at Hoosier Park Racing & CasinoPrice: Very Expensive• Steakhouse• Anderson•4.5
- OTOpenTable DinerIndiana •1 review5.0Dined on Feb 27, 2021Mallory was our server and she did a wonderful job!More infoBuffalo Wild Wings - New CastlePrice: Moderate• American• New Castle•3.7
Trending dishes in New Castle
Restaurant experiences trending in Indiana
Discover New Castle
New Castle, Indiana, is a typical Midwestern town located just northeast of Indianapolis, home to several traditional American family-style restaurants serving everything from plate lunches and dinners to hamburgers and french fries. You can also enjoy many excellent local establishments that specialize in comfort food, seafood and great steak in New Castle. One of the real surprises for visitors and travelers is the selection of international food available around the area, including authentic Chinese, French and Mexican. The local pizzerias make pizza and Italian sandwiches with traditional flavor and generous portions. Sushi and Japanese steak are also favorites, prepared for you right at the bar. There is a little something for all palates in New Castle amid a relaxing, close-knit atmosphere.
Frequently asked questions
As of Jun 17, 2025 there are 2 restaurants in New Castle. Filter by “outdoor dining”, “romantic” or “dog friendly”.
On OpenTable we support all cuisines. Find American and more. Use our filters to find exactly what you’re looking for and make your reservation today.
Yes! We partner with restaurants in New Castle who deliver with Toast, Postmates, Uber Eats, Olo, ChowNow.
Yes, you can also see restaurants near you offering takeout.
Yes! OpenTable provides free, convenient and trusted options to book the best restaurants in New Castle either on OpenTable or directly with the restaurant.
Yes, we partner with a third party to bring back menu information for restaurants near you.
Explore OpenTable
- The Hagerstown Museum & Arts Place
- Mahoning Valley Camp
- Shively Park
- Baker Park
- Westwood Park
- Elias Hinshaw House
- Memorial Park
- Babe Ruth Park
- Wilbur Wright Memorial
- General William Grose House
- Huddleston Farmhouse
- Camp Wapi Kamigi
- Hoosier Gym
- Criotz Park
- Knightstown Academy
- Wilbur Wright Birthplace and Museum
- Wilson Park