Best Contemporary American Restaurants in Bay Shore

View all

Best Contemporary American Restaurants in Bay Shore

Best American Restaurants in Bay Shore

View all

Best American Restaurants in Bay Shore

Popular restaurants in New York Area

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New York Area

HAVEN Riverfront Restaurant and Bar
(279)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Edgewater
Serafina 105
(116)
$$$$
Italian | Upper West Side
OFFER
View all New York Area restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Bay Shore restaurants.

Bay Shore Restaurants

The LakehouseThe Lakehouse
1020 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Everything was INCREDIBLE! Just want to thank the whole staff for reading our crazy request - considering we were surprising our twin daughters- that their brother was joining us - and he ran EXTREMELY late driving in from Syracuse!!! It couldn’t have been better and we are all so appreciative of those details!!!!! THANK YOU SO SO SO MUCH!!! The Lake House has always been our favorite restaurant (we drive from Manorville) (we are in the restaurant business) and tonight just solidified why!!! Props to the Chef - everyone loved everything!!! More

OpenTable Diner -
Salt and BarrelSalt and Barrel
620 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Delicious steak night. Great value. Excellent service More

OpenTable Diner -
Captain Bill'sCaptain Bill's
728 reviews
$$$$
Seafood | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Great food. Friendly service. Depressing music from a by-gone era. More

OpenTable Diner -
Verde Kitchen & CocktailsVerde Kitchen & Cocktails
399 reviews
$$$$
Mexican | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Our waiter on Tuesday night was so nice. He really made our experience wonderful. Taco Tuesday was so worthwhile cost wise and the food was delicious! We’ll be back again. More

OpenTable Diner -
Bella VieBella Vie
79 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Warmly welcomed by Owner Mike and Chef Fabrizio for New Years Eve Dinner. Our first visit under new name and owner and wont be our last. Beautiful venue with outstanding drinks and incredibly prepared food by their outstanding Chef. There was a Prix Fixe menu that night which didnt include our favorites but Mike was kind enough to get me Duck Duo with Confit Leg for my main and Bon had the Filet which was like Butta! We had a great time and joined the other revelers for a festive dinner. More

OpenTable Diner -
WhalersWhalers
83 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Sunday brunch was delicious and our server was so friendly and attentive. We would definitely visit again. More

OpenTable Diner -
Corks and Taps of New York inc.Corks and Taps of New York inc.
23 reviews
$$$$
American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

The entire staff was great! They all had smiles on their faces and appeared that they liked being there. The food was delicious! More

OpenTable Diner -
Big Daddy’s East/BDEBig Daddy’s East/BDE
36 reviews
$$$$
Creole / Cajun / Southern | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Have been a Big Daddy’s fan from Day 1 and this new restaurant doesn’t disappoint. They “upscale” menu is very interesting and tasty. Can’t wait to try all the items More

OpenTable Diner -
TGI FRIDAYS - BayshoreTGI FRIDAYS - Bayshore
6 reviews
$$$$
American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Had such a great time. Went on a Sunday and took advantage of their new happy hour specials. Boneless wings of all flavors were delicious as we're the sliders. Our server Diamond was the best. More

OpenTable Diner -

Bay Shore Diners' Choice Winners

Bay Shore's best restaurants based upon thousands of OpenTable diner reviews
The LakehouseThe Lakehouse
1020 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Everything was INCREDIBLE! Just want to thank the whole staff for reading our crazy request - considering we were surprising our twin daughters- that their brother was joining us - and he ran EXTREMELY late driving in from Syracuse!!! It couldn’t have been better and we are all so appreciative of those details!!!!! THANK YOU SO SO SO MUCH!!! The Lake House has always been our favorite restaurant (we drive from Manorville) (we are in the restaurant business) and tonight just solidified why!!! Props to the Chef - everyone loved everything!!! More

OpenTable Diner -
Salt and BarrelSalt and Barrel
620 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Delicious steak night. Great value. Excellent service More

OpenTable Diner -
Bella VieBella Vie
79 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Warmly welcomed by Owner Mike and Chef Fabrizio for New Years Eve Dinner. Our first visit under new name and owner and wont be our last. Beautiful venue with outstanding drinks and incredibly prepared food by their outstanding Chef. There was a Prix Fixe menu that night which didnt include our favorites but Mike was kind enough to get me Duck Duo with Confit Leg for my main and Bon had the Filet which was like Butta! We had a great time and joined the other revelers for a festive dinner. More

OpenTable Diner -
Captain Bill'sCaptain Bill's
728 reviews
$$$$
Seafood | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Great food. Friendly service. Depressing music from a by-gone era. More

OpenTable Diner -
WhalersWhalers
83 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Sunday brunch was delicious and our server was so friendly and attentive. We would definitely visit again. More

OpenTable Diner -
Verde Kitchen & CocktailsVerde Kitchen & Cocktails
399 reviews
$$$$
Mexican | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Our waiter on Tuesday night was so nice. He really made our experience wonderful. Taco Tuesday was so worthwhile cost wise and the food was delicious! We’ll be back again. More

OpenTable Diner -
Corks and Taps of New York inc.Corks and Taps of New York inc.
23 reviews
$$$$
American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

The entire staff was great! They all had smiles on their faces and appeared that they liked being there. The food was delicious! More

OpenTable Diner -
Big Daddy’s East/BDEBig Daddy’s East/BDE
36 reviews
$$$$
Creole / Cajun / Southern | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Have been a Big Daddy’s fan from Day 1 and this new restaurant doesn’t disappoint. They “upscale” menu is very interesting and tasty. Can’t wait to try all the items More

OpenTable Diner -