Best Italian Restaurants in Bay Shore

Price: Moderate (28)Price: Expensive (30)Price: Very Expensive (14)

19 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore restaurant

1. Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore

4.8

Exceptional(926)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Bay Shore

Booked 10 times today

Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore is highly recommended for its outstanding and authentic Italian cuisine. Consistently praised by customers in their reviews, this restaurant offers traditional Italian dishes and unique, delicious creations that are hard to find elsewhere. Whether it's hearty eggplant, pork chop, or baked clams, the food is prepared to perfection, and presented with flair. Many customers have deemed Butera's as their preferred place for Italian cuisine locally, and frequently express their anticipation for the next visit. The exceptional service, large portions, and great ambience also contribute to the overall dining experience. The restaurant further impresses with its attention to customers, with the owner taking the time to greet patrons and ensure their satisfaction.

2. ITA Kitchen

4.4

Awesome(918)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Bay Shore

Booked 8 times today

ITA Kitchen is an Italian restaurant highly praised in numerous reviews for its delightful cuisine and exceptional service. Diners describe their dishes as "amazing," "outstanding," and even the best Italian food they've ever had on Long Island. The restaurant has indoor and outdoor seating, with both options offering a great ambiance and beautiful decor. Staff members are frequently recognized as polite and attentive, significantly enhancing the dining experience. The menu includes a variety of vegetarian and vegan options, with most visitors stating they can't wait to return. ITA Kitchen evidently offers an elevated Italian dining experience, indicative of its reputation and popularity.

A photo of Primi Italian Steakhouse restaurant

3. Primi Italian Steakhouse

4.8

Exceptional(1370)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • West Islip

Booked 16 times today

Primi Italian Steakhouse, located in Islip, New York, is highly praised for embodying a seamless combination of traditional Italian cuisine and exquisite steakhouse fare. With mentions of an extensive and robust wine selection, remarkable service, and a welcoming ambience, Primi is a cherished spot not only for regulars but serves as a delightful culinary surprise for newcomers. Customers consistently praise the attentive staff and unique dishes such as the beef Wellington, Pei mussels, and quality steaks. The restaurant is also admired for its signature cocktails and willingness to accommodate special requests. The general consensus from the reviews is that Primi Italian Steakhouse offers a truly exceptional and authentic Italian dining experience underscored by its top-notch service and cozy, elegant atmosphere.

4. Bella Vie

4.5

Awesome(543)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Bay Shore

Booked 1 time today

Bella Vie is an Italian gem located on Long Island. It consistently earns high praise for its fabulous food, excellent service, and gorgeous view of the water. The reviews highlight the exceptional veal, perfectly seasoned spaghetti with clams, and innovative offerings not on the menu. Even the bread, from start to finish, is said to be fantastic. The restaurant’s inviting and intimate space, combined with consistently good food, friendly and attentive staff, draws in customers and ensures they return. This place is also appreciated for its live music, adding a fun twist to the charming Italian atmosphere. The chef's skill and accommodating nature make Bella Vie the perfect spot for authentic Italian cuisine in Long Island.

A photo of Marys Pizza & Restaurant restaurant

5. Marys Pizza & Restaurant

4.7

Exceptional(45)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • East Islip

Marys Pizza & Restaurant is hailed for its exceptional Italian cuisine, consistently earning high praise from patrons for its sizable portions, fresh ingredients, and excellent preparation. Celebrated as a hidden gem, the restaurant is lauded for its menu's consistent quality and value, with one pleased customer stating: "No matter what you're in the mood for or decide to try for the first time…nothing on the menu disappoints." Notably, special themed nights like Chicken and Seafood nights are a hit, resulting in meals so large that guests often take home leftovers. The restaurant's success extends beyond its food, with its attentive service, warm atmosphere, and reasonable pricing also attracting commendation from diners. It's the perfect location for celebrations, family dining or simply treating oneself to a delectable Italian meal.

A photo of One10 Modern Italian restaurant

6. One10 Modern Italian

4.4

Awesome(2626)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Melville

Booked 15 times today

One10 is renowned for its excellent Italian cuisine. Patrons have praised it repeatedly in their reviews for its exceptional food and service. Famed for its sophisticated dining experience, the restaurant's menu presents a fresh take on Italian favorites whilst accommodating diversity with lighter Mediterranean flavors and gluten-free or veggie options. One10 offers more than just good food: it creates an ambiance that's modern, airy, and pleasing, complimented by its attentive and knowledgeable staff. The restaurant, frequently visited for date nights, family dinners, or just a night out, consistently delivers a memorable, high-quality dining experience. The reviews reveal a unanimous verdict - One10 is great for Italian cuisine and is highly recommended for future visits.

A photo of Mannino's Italian Kitchen & Lounge restaurant

7. Mannino's Italian Kitchen & Lounge

4.8

Exceptional(1307)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Commack

Booked 23 times today

Mannino's Italian Kitchen & Lounge is highly praised for its authentic Italian cuisine. Reviews are laden with compliments for their exceptional food, ranging from Chicken Rollatini special to Rigatoni Bolognese as well as impressive appetizers and desserts. The restaurant's staff is commended for their professionalism, attentiveness, and courtesy. Dining at Mannino's is described as an enjoyable experience, providing a space that is both elegant and comfortable, suitable for both casual dining and special occasions. Mannino's ability to surpass expectations and maintain consistency in its culinary delivery makes it one of the best Italian restaurants in New York.

8. Osteria Umbra

4.9

Exceptional(1769)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Smithtown

Booked 10 times today

Located in Long Island, Osteria Umbra has repeatedly been hailed as the best Italian restaurant in the area. Renowned for its "true Italian cuisine", the establishment is noted for its exceptional dishes, ranging from the succulent lobster pasta to the delectable fiorentina steak. The meticulous cooking is complemented by an exclusively Italian wine list, curated by Chef Marco, a sommelier himself. The restaurant's warm and accommodating service, led by knowledgeable staff, enhances the overall dining experience. Osteria Umbra's dedication to culinary perfection, as seen through their ever-changing seasonal menu, truly makes it a beacon of authentic Italian gourmet fare.

A photo of Smithtown Pasta House restaurant

9. Smithtown Pasta House

4.7

Exceptional(317)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Smithtown

Booked 5 times today

Located in New York, Smithtown Pasta House is lauded widely for its exceptional Italian cuisine. Multiple reviews cherish the restaurant's "delicious", "amazing", and "excellent" food. It appears to offer a fusion of traditional Italian recipes with a unique spin which heightens their appeal. Patrons have mentioned "outstanding" dishes such as the baked clams, meatballs, shrimp parmigiana with vodka sauce, and their special bronzino. The moderate prices and good portions are also much appreciated. Complimenting the quality of dishes, reviewers consistently commend the excellent service provided by their staff members Gianna, Sue, and Lou. Given these praises, Smithtown Pasta House is definitely a go-to Italian restaurant for many.

A photo of Steve's Piccola Bussola of Hauppauge restaurant

10. Steve's Piccola Bussola of Hauppauge

4.8

Exceptional(476)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Hauppauge

Booked 6 times today

Steve's Piccola Bussola of Hauppauge serves exceptional Italian cuisine that consistently delights its regulars and first-time guests alike. Many claim it to be the best Italian food in Long Island, with irresistible seafood dishes and classic Italian offerings prepared from quality ingredients. The restaurant garners high praises for providing excellent service, with attentive and accommodating staff adding value to the overall dining experience. As numerous reviews attest, Steve's Piccola Bussola is a "must-try", a gem in the realm of Italian restaurants where "everything is cooked to order perfectly". Its enduring appeal over the years testifies to its dedication to quality and authenticity in Italian cuisine.

How is content generated

Discover best Italian restaurants in Bay Shore

Discover the essence of Italian cuisine in Bay Shore, Suffolk, where a variety of restaurants offer an authentic taste of Italy right in the heart of New York State. Each establishment boasts unique interpretations of classic Italian dishes, blending traditional flavors with local ingredients to create mouth-watering menus that cater to all palates. From rustic, cozy atmospheres to modern, elegant settings, the dining scene in Bay Shore provides an ideal backdrop for both casual and sophisticated dining experiences. Patrons can expect top-notch service, high-quality food, and an ambiance that complements the rich, culinary heritage of Italy. Whether you're in the mood for hearty pasta, exquisite seafood, or a fine wine selection, Bay Shore's Italian restaurants promise a memorable dining experience. Embrace the local love for Italian cuisine in this vibrant community, where every meal is served with a touch of Italian hospitality.

Explore OpenTable

Bay Shore

Italian