Best Italian Restaurants in Mamaroneck

Price: Moderate (85)Price: Expensive (91)Price: Very Expensive (17)

62 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Augustine’s Salumeria restaurant

1. Augustine’s Salumeria

4.8

Exceptional(486)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Mamaroneck

Booked 18 times today

Augustine’s Salumeria, located in Westchester, offers a contemporary twist on traditional Italian dishes that left diners raving about the "inventive Italian cuisine", with "fresh ingredients" and "absolutely first rate dishes". The establishment is praised for its "complexities in both taste and appearance" and the modern, cozy setting. Reviewers emphasized the high-quality service and unique culinary touch, with many stating it was one of the best Italian restaurants they had visited in the area. Several diners even stated the food matched the quality of meals they had in Italy, further emphasizing the restaurant's commitment to authentic Italian cuisine.

2. Nonna Carola

4.8

Exceptional(540)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Mamaroneck

Booked 9 times today

Nonna Carola elevates Italian cuisine to new heights with its creative and refined approach. Reviewers consistently praise its fresh ingredients, delicious pairings, and subtle seasonings. Traditional Italian classics are given a modern twist, resulting in a menu brimming with interesting, excellently executed dishes. From mushroom pasta dish with grated, pickled shallots to mussels risotto with crunchy garlic chips and pea shoots, every course at Nonna Carola comes highly recommended. Critics also appreciate the restaurant's beautiful modern decor, perfect lighting, and welcoming ambiance. While it may be pricier than the average neighborhood Italian restaurant, the unique dining experience it offers makes it well worth it.

3. Piccolo Mulino

4.5

Awesome(251)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Mamaroneck

Piccolo Mulino, located in Westchester, is a revered Italian restaurant that is hailed by patrons as a favorite local spot for excellent, authentic Italian cuisine. Customers rave about the delicious food, generous portions and the restaurant's ability to create a cozy, warm and friendly dining atmosphere. They appreciate the large and varied menu with Italian classic dishes, and note the accommodating outdoor dining experience. Reflecting in their reviews, patrons compliment the tender calamari, delicious Chicken Francese, Sea Bass, and Linguine in Clam sauce, among other dishes. They also laud the attentive, pleasant staff and the timely, relaxed service. Piccolo Mulino is often considered a hidden gem in the community, offering an outstanding dining experience that never fails to go beyond expectations.

4. 25 North

4.9

Exceptional(1635)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Mamaroneck

Booked 11 times today

25 North is an acclaimed Italian restaurant, celebrated for its authentic cuisine. The eatery is renowned for its delightful fusion of traditional Italian dishes with a unique, contemporary twist. Patrons often commend the friendly service, exceptional food, and cozy ambiance. The Broccoli Di Rabe Egg Rolls and pasta "25" Our Famous Ala are particularly endorsed for their heartiness and distinctive flavors. Famed for being a perfect fit for those with dietary restrictions, 25 North also caters to a gluten-free diet, despite not having a separate menu. More than just a restaurant, 25 North is a symphony of exquisite tastes, warm service, and authentic Italian charm that keeps its guests beckoning for more.

A photo of Meritage - Scarsdale restaurant

5. Meritage - Scarsdale

4.8

Exceptional(574)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Scarsdale

Booked 21 times today

Meritage - Scarsdale is highly recognized for its American cuisine. The restaurant consistently draws rave reviews for its food, service, and ambiance. One reviewer calls it, "the best American restaurant in Westchester," commending the fresh, seasonal ingredients and the perfect portion sizes. Another reviewer speaks highly of the restaurant's "creative, delicious food," and "excellent and attentive" service. The menu features a variety of dishes, from the crowd-favorite pasta bolognese, bursting with flavor, to the pan-roasted chicken, described as "fantastic." The extensive wine list, with selections from California to France, further showcases the restaurant's commitment to quality. Meritage’s staff and owners also earn praise for their friendliness and attention to detail, culminating in a dining experience that is universally enjoyed and highly recommended.

A photo of Serafina Scarsdale restaurant

6. Serafina Scarsdale

4.6

Exceptional(422)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Scarsdale

Booked 10 times today

Serafina Scarsdale shines as an Italian gem in the culinary scene. Customers rave about the excellent service, the spot-on food presentation, and the amazing taste of their meals: the Brussels Sprout Salad, Pizza, and Serafina Chicken Salad being particular favorites. Reviewers also emphasize the beautiful environment and elegant decor, both indoors and outdoors, enhancing the overall dining experience. However, a recurring suggestion is for a reduction in the noise level, especially the volume of the music, in order to strike the perfect balance between vibrant atmosphere and comfortable dining. Encouraged by the ample parking, the accomodating staff, and the consistently good food, customers express their desire to return, appreciating Serafina Scarsdale not only as a local spot for Italian cuisine, but also as a venue for celebrations and gatherings.

A photo of Lenny’s Seafood and Steakhouse restaurant

7. Lenny’s Seafood and Steakhouse

4.9

Exceptional(1423)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Larchmont

Booked 8 times today

Lenny’s Seafood and Steakhouse, located in Larchmont, stands out as an amazing spot for Steakhouse cuisine. This place comes highly recommended by many customers for its quality food, great service, and wonderful ambiance. As one customer put it, "the incomparable Lenny's Steakhouse was outstanding...first time dining there and I was amazed." Another declared Lenny’s prime steaks as top-notch even when compared to several steakhouses in New York City. They also complimented the freshness of the seafood. The attentive staff and meticulously mixed drinks further elevate the dining experience. "Great food, great atmosphere and GREAT service," states a satisfied customer who has made Lenny’s their regular spot. The restaurant provides extraordinary dining experiences and is a favorite among steak and seafood enthusiasts.

A photo of Sapori of Scarsdale restaurant

8. Sapori of Scarsdale

4.8

Exceptional(822)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Scarsdale

Booked 17 times today

Sapori of Scarsdale is a cherished eatery, lauded for its authentic Italian cuisine. Patrons compliment its menu, full of exquisitely prepared Mediterranean food with Italian flair, such as their succulent lamb chops, fresh Branzino, and divine zabaglione, prepared tableside. Its clientele appreciates the restaurant’s atmosphere, describing it as a ‘slice of Little Italy in Scarsdale’. Reviews frequently mention the excellent and friendly service, suggesting that the team led by Eddie is top-notch. While some customers note difficult parking, they maintain that the culinary experience is worth it. Whether you are a local or visiting, the exceptional food and ambiance make Sapori of Scarsdale a destination of choice.

A photo of One Rare Italian Steakhouse restaurant

9. One Rare Italian Steakhouse

4.6

Exceptional(229)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Scarsdale

Booked 18 times today

Boasting an upscale city steakhouse vibe, One Rare Italian Steakhouse has quickly become renowned as one of the finest steakhouses in Westchester County and the Hudson Valley. Reviewers frequently praise the quality and execution of the steak dishes, with particular emphasis on the NY Sirloin and the steak for two. The menu is reported to also include exceptional seafood and pasta dishes, with fresh and wild salmon, and homemade pasta dishes among the favourites. In addition to the culinary excellence, reviewers also consistently commend the elegant ambiance, excellent service, and personal attention from the staff—including the restaurant manager and the executive chef—making One Rare Italian Steakhouse not just a place to eat, but a memorable dining experience.

A photo of Zero Otto Nove - Tuckahoe restaurant

10. Zero Otto Nove - Tuckahoe

4.7

Exceptional(493)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Tuckahoe

Booked 9 times today

Zero Otto Nove located in Tuckahoe is a gem of an Italian restaurant that leaves customers satisfied with its superior food and delightful service. Noted as being "not your typical Italian restaurant," Zero Otto Nove offers spectacular dishes from rigatoni to linguine vongole and penne a la vodka that have left patrons with their taste buds tingling. Praise has also been given to their exceptional staff who provide excellent service, contributing to the overall positive dining experience. One reviewer even called it "likely, the best Italian restaurant in the area." The restaurant's philosophy of using fresh ingredients is clearly the reason behind its wonderful creations. The restaurant's equally excellent new location in Tuckahoe also speaks volumes about its constant pursuit of quality and excellence in Italian cuisine.

How is content generated

Discover best Italian restaurants in Mamaroneck

Discover the charm of authentic Italian dining in Mamaroneck, Westchester, a locale celebrated for its vibrant culinary scene. This picturesque area offers a variety of Italian restaurants, each providing a unique blend of traditional and innovative Italian cuisine that caters to all palates. From the heartwarming ambiance of family-run trattorias to the sophisticated settings of modern Italian eateries, Mamaroneck is a destination for anyone craving genuine Italian flavors. Patrons can expect to enjoy a range of dishes, from classic pasta and seafood specialties to creatively crafted modern Italian fare, using fresh, locally sourced ingredients. The dining environment in these establishments is often highlighted by warm, inviting atmospheres and attentive service, making each meal a delightful experience. Whether looking for a cozy dinner spot or a refined culinary adventure, the Italian restaurants in Mamaroneck offer an impressive gastronomic journey through Italy’s rich culinary heritage. Enhance your dining experience by exploring Mamaroneck's Italian restaurants, where every meal is served with a dash of Italian passion and a commitment to culinary excellence. This is truly a place where every dining choice is a gateway to the flavors of Italy, right here in New York State.

Explore OpenTable

Mamaroneck

Italian