Best American Restaurants in Bay Shore

Price: Moderate (28)Price: Expensive (29)Price: Very Expensive (14)

34 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore restaurant

1. Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore

4.8

Exceptional(930)

Price: Moderate

• American • Bay Shore

Booked 16 times today

Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore is highly recommended for its outstanding and authentic Italian cuisine. Consistently praised by customers in their reviews, this restaurant offers traditional Italian dishes and unique, delicious creations that are hard to find elsewhere. Whether it's hearty eggplant, pork chop, or baked clams, the food is prepared to perfection, and presented with flair. Many customers have deemed Butera's as their preferred place for Italian cuisine locally, and frequently express their anticipation for the next visit. The exceptional service, large portions, and great ambience also contribute to the overall dining experience. The restaurant further impresses with its attention to customers, with the owner taking the time to greet patrons and ensure their satisfaction.

A photo of The Linwood Restaurant and Cocktails restaurant

2. The Linwood Restaurant and Cocktails

4.7

Exceptional(782)

Price: Moderate

• American • Bay Shore

Booked 9 times today

The Linwood Restaurant and Cocktails is a celebrated establishment renowned for its contemporary American cuisine. The restaurant consistently receives high praises from customers for its excellent food and service. Patrons appreciate the imaginative menu featuring a variety of flavors and ingredients. They especially love the grilled octopus and mussels in white wine sauce, citing them as delicious and satisfying. The staff is commended for their friendly and attentive service, ensuring a top-notch dining experience. Furthermore, The Linwood is recognized for its unique and tasty drinks, as well as its comfortable and appealing ambiance. It's hailed as a neighborhood gem and a favorite dining spot by many.

3. ITA Kitchen

4.4

Awesome(919)

Price: Expensive

• American • Bay Shore

Booked 9 times today

ITA Kitchen is an Italian restaurant highly praised in numerous reviews for its delightful cuisine and exceptional service. Diners describe their dishes as "amazing," "outstanding," and even the best Italian food they've ever had on Long Island. The restaurant has indoor and outdoor seating, with both options offering a great ambiance and beautiful decor. Staff members are frequently recognized as polite and attentive, significantly enhancing the dining experience. The menu includes a variety of vegetarian and vegan options, with most visitors stating they can't wait to return. ITA Kitchen evidently offers an elevated Italian dining experience, indicative of its reputation and popularity.

4. Salt and Barrel

4.8

Exceptional(1649)

Price: Expensive

• American • Bay Shore

Booked 3 times today

Salt and Barrel, a restaurant renowned for its excellence in contemporary American cuisine, comes highly recommended by patrons for its outstanding service, amazing food, and vibrant ambiance. Customers particularly rave about the restaurant's fantastic seafood, especially the Tigre oysters, sea bass and lobster rolls. Their oyster selection, gleaned from the finest offerings around the US, has proven to be a favorite, described as 'out of this world delicious'. Whether you're dining in for a cozy family dinner or looking for a lively bar scene, their diverse menu and exquisite servings never fail to impress. Patrons particularly commend the attentive and professional service. Whether it's excellent recommendations, perfect timing or even accommodating last-minute reservation changes, Salt and Barrel puts service at the forefront. The combination of a warm, inviting ambiance, delicious contemporary American fare, and impeccable service make this restaurant a sterling choice.

5. Tullulah's

4.7

Exceptional(415)

Price: Moderate

• American • Bay Shore

Booked 3 times today

Tullulah's is a cherished restaurant that delivers an exceptional Tapas / Small Plates experience. Reviewers consistently praise both the food and drinks, noting the rotating menu that offers seasonal delights, ensuring every visit feels unique. The chicken apple wrap, the Gouda Mac and chorizo come highly recommended. The ambience is described as 'low key' and 'comfortable'. With the attentive service, excellent food, and delightful cocktails, Tullulah's is a place where diners return to, year after year, for all sorts of occasions, confirming its status as a local favorite. The restaurant's dedication to quality and innovation has left a lasting impression on its patrons, making it an unmissable culinary destination.

6. King's Chop House

4.5

Awesome(188)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Bay Shore

Booked 1 time today

King's Chop House, a hidden gem on main street in Bay Shore, NY, specializes in American cuisine and is renowned for its exquisite steak and sea scallops. Customers rave about the memorable cocktails, outstanding service, and the consistent excellence of their food. Notable mentions go to their 75-day old dry aged rib-eye and their creamy horseradish sauce doused NY strip steak that "just melted in the mouth". The ambiance is cozy and intimate, with live jazz music often accompanying the delicious meals. Don't miss out on their seasonally changing specialty drink menu. Whether it's the first visit or a return trip, King's Chop House never disappoints.

7. Roadtrip

new

4.8

Exceptional(7)

Price: Expensive

• American • Bay Shore

Booked 8 times today

Come to Roadtrip Restaurant, where we celebrate American cuisine and cocktails. Join us on a culinary journey through America's favorite states and flavors! Savor our delicious BBQ, smoked on-site, or indulge in a USDA Prime Beef Center Cut Filet Mignon with purple potato purée. Chef Mike Artist continues his quest to earn a Michelin star, bringing his passion to every dish. Enjoy exceptional American cuisine in our modern, classy Americana setting, featuring just the right amount of wood accents for a touch of rustic charm.

8. The Lakehouse

4.7

Exceptional(3104)

Price: Expensive

• American • Bay Shore

Booked 28 times today

The Lakehouse, a contemporary American cuisine restaurant, is praised for its exemplary dining experience. It garners consistent acclaim for its succulent Berkshire Pork Chops and Halibut, expertly crafted by Chef Andrew. Its diverse menu, focusing on new American and seafood, features remarkably executed dishes such as marinated skirt steak with gorgonzola butter and herbed fries or the perfectly cooked venison. Beyond the cuisine, the ambiance of the restaurant is equally appreciated, with diners lauding its beautiful setting overlooking the Great South Bay. Despite occasional remarks about portion sizes and busy reservation lists, the overall consensus from reviews reflects The Lakehouse's commitment to top-notch food and service, solidifying its reputation as one of the best restaurants on Long Island. Whether for a casual lunch, romantic date night, or special celebration, The Lakehouse is an essential spot for lovers of contemporary American cuisine.

9. Whalers

4.6

Exceptional(1339)

Price: Expensive

• American • Bay Shore

Booked 4 times today

Whalers restaurant offers a brilliant rendition of Contemporary American cuisine. Perched by the water, patrons relish the ambiance paired with an outstanding service. The menu offers a diverse range of dishes with reviews highlighting the mussel appetizer's exquisite broth, the delicious seafood paella, the creamy crème brûlée, the perfectly cooked scallops, and the heavenly lobster mac and cheese. The restaurant creates an ideal summer vibe with pleasant staff interactions and beautiful views. Whalers also prides itself in offering vegetarian options, with the cauliflower dish being a delightful surprise. Reviewers mentioned the neat, clean atmosphere and attention to detail that made their dining experience unforgettable. Whether it's the light dressing on the watermelon salad, the spicy twist on the short ribs, or the moist and flavorful coconut crusted cod, Whalers undoubtedly delivers a memorable culinary experience.

10. Captain Bill's

4.7

Exceptional(1978)

Price: Expensive

• American • Bay Shore

Booked 10 times today

Captain Bill's restaurant is highly praised for its excellent seafood cuisine. Reviewers consistently mention the freshness and outstanding preparation of the seafood. The "surf" is always fresh and perfectly prepared according to one patron who has been going there for more than 50 years. Menu highlights include the Seafood Tower and the Broiled Seafood Platter which never disappoints. The location of the restaurant, right on the water, adds to the appealing ambiance, providing a beautiful harbor view especially during outdoor dining. The service is also frequently commended, with many visitors promising to return. From the quality of food and service, it is clear why Captain Bill's is a beloved seafood destination.

How is content generated

Discover best American restaurants in Bay Shore

Discover the best of American cuisine in the bustling area of Bay Shore, Suffolk, New York. This locality boasts a diverse selection of American dining options, from classic American fare to innovative dishes that highlight local ingredients. Bay Shore's dining scene is characterized by its vibrant atmosphere and commitment to culinary excellence, making it a prime destination for food enthusiasts. Whether you're in the mood for seafood, steak, or a fusion of Italian-American flavors, the restaurants in Bay Shore cater to every palate with their high-quality, creatively crafted dishes. Patrons consistently praise the exceptional service, scenic locations, and the welcoming ambiance that these eateries offer. Each restaurant in this area ensures a memorable dining experience, emphasizing freshness, flavor, and impeccable service. Explore Bay Shore for a true taste of American cuisine that combines traditional cooking with modern twists.

Explore OpenTable

Bay Shore

American