Montauk Seafood Grill
"Where the oceans meet the mountains"
Since 1987, Montauk Seafood Grill has been bringing high quality seafood and meats to Vail- flown in fresh, never frozen, from all corners of the globe.
Located in the heart of Lionshead Village, we combine a fine dining experience with a casual and fun atmosphere.
We hope to see you soon!
BOOKING SEPARATE RESERVATIONS DOES NOT GUARANTEE TABLES WILL BE SAT TOGETHER.
Please call 9704762601 for parties of 7 or more.
Loved the atmosphere. Seafood was very fresh. Good trick getting that freshness to Vail. Closest ocean is quite a distance.
Great food !
We had a great experience. Everything from the host to our server to the excellent food.
The restaurant was very nice in regards to atmosphere unfortunately, the halibut was over cooked. Everything else was excellent. The waiter was average, some what slow to bring things to us. I noticed this waiter was much more attentive to the table to the left of us, giving them water checking back with them quite often compared to us. I even had to ask for more water.
Celebrating a fall getaway to Vail. We have had delicious scallops, halibut and salmon! Great service too!
Pina was fantastic! The scallops were delicious!
What an excellent meal! Our server was a gem! The food was amazing.
Great food, felt safe, tables spaced apart and staff taking Covid precautions. Halibut was excellent and my husband had scallops carbonara, also excellent.
Excellent food! One of the best in Vail. Server was a little lacking but again I’d return for the food and give the server another shot!
Really enjoyed our meal at Montauk Seafood! Hadn't been in a few years and thought the quality of the seafood was great!
Outstanding meal! Special occasion to get to know son's new girlfriend. Started with delicious oyster shooters and it got better and better from there. The scallops melted in your mouth and the crab legs were huge. The steak was prepared to the perfect temp. We even stuffed ourselves with a decadent dessert. Highly recommend!! You will not be dissapointed in anything.
Celebrating Two BD's. It was perfect for our family. Everyone loved their food.
Food was fantastic. Chelsea was our server and was awesome as usual. She is extremely attentive, hustles and had a great personality! This is our go to restaurant when in Vail. Prices are a bit steep but it is Vail!
My plate was 50% good!
The Fish was good! The side was terrible !
Montauk is absolutely worth every penny. As locals we don't always go out to the higher end restaurants, but we were amazed and will go back as soon as we can. Romantic, beautiful ambiance and lighting, just enough quietness to enjoy your privacy. I would like to go back and have that Sea Scallop Carbonara again. And again! The Halibut is so buttery. A perfectly cooked fish. Highly recommend for couples, special occasions and an evening out. Thank you to Teva, our waiter, who took great care of us.
As a whole good restaurant for seafood in Vail. We have visited when in Vail over 20 years, making it a landmark restaurant. Had a great cioppino as it was the special and recommended by our waiter.
The service was top notch. Our waitress was great. The host, Chad, was totally wonderful. Great seafood.
My wife had very good selection of seafood, and I good Manhattan -- both very expensive, but that is Vail.
I had a mediocre crab appetizer salad with little stringy crab.
The restaurant is one of the only choices for seafood in Vail.
Very tasty dinner. No concerns about Covid while dining. We know we can always count on a good dinner at Montauk Grill and were pleased as usual the other evening.
My significant other loves seafood, so I chose Montauk after reviewing the menu. Was not disappointed in the least! Sometimes, we are a bit skeptical about visiting a seafood restaurant that isn't near the coast, but we were pleasantly surprised by Montauk Grill. The Mussels were excellent, fresh as ever and bursting with flavor. We were lucky enough to have a "low country boil" as the special, which we enjoyed thoroughly with the Alaskan King crab. There were a couple times that I commented how they must have a top quality chef running the establishment! Enjoy!
One of my favorite places! Love the food and the service.
Great spot, great food, very friendly and professional service.
A favorite, and a don’t miss restaurant!
Fantastic food and service!
We sat at the bar. They’re we’re out of a few things but the drinks were really good and so was the bartender.
The crusted Halibut may well be the best piece of fish I have ever eaten. Our family of three had an amazing meal with each one of us believing we had the best entree, truth is everyone was incredible starting with the Halibut, the BBQ Salmon and the seared Ahi.
Everything was amazing, food was delicious, service was awesome. Shout out to our waiter Honsy from the Czech Republic.
We have been eating here for over 30 years and have always been pleased. Our most frequented Vail Restaurant.
Excellent menu offerings and great drinks. Very good selection of oysters and all were very fresh and tasty
Food was very good
Service was excellent
Fish selections were sparse
Prices were high even for Vail
BEST RIBEYE I'VE EVER HAD. HALIBUT OUT OF THIS WORLD.
The food was fine, but not very inspired. I can open a raw oyster or grill a piece of fish at home.
Good seafood, great service. Pricey, but it's Vail.
Amazing food, great service and ambiance!
After reading all the great reviews, we decided to make reservations for Montauk, and it was the best dinner and experience while in Vail.
We had Maine Lobster Arancini as our starter and I was in love... all the flavors on this appetizer were exquisite!
Our entrees didn’t disappoint either, my halibut was to die for!
Our server was amazing as well, he offer great recommendations and was very pleasant and friendly.
Colorado is a beautiful state with wonderful restaurants and many options, Montauk Seafood Grill is definitely one of them! It is must if you are visiting Vail. Highly recommend it!
This is our second visit as we had dined here last year when we were staying in Vail. We were able to sit outside as the weather was very nice. We all had a crab or fish dish which was very good. Great service and a good location.
Expected to be an expensive restaurant but was pleasantly surprised. the Food was quite good and overall for the level of restaurant that it is it was very reasonably priced.
Fabulous crab dinner for our anniversary. Would highly recommend the restaurant as service was as good as the food.
I had the halibut and my wife had the scallops- both were excellent. Beautiful filet of halibut Panco crusted and cooked perfectly. Mussels as appetizer were good but not great. Recommend the outdoor seating for good people watching.
Excellent food! We enjoyed every item that was served. One of the best steaks I’ve ever had! Worth every penny!
We loved Montauk! The service, the food, the wine. It was outstanding. We had a long weekend in Vail and first time going to Montauk. The seafood was outstanding. The crab legs were some of the best we have had. A wonderful evening. Helena our server was fantastic and a real pro.
Montauk Seafood Grill is rated 4.7 stars by 1081 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.