Gnocchi Crema Rosa
Potato Dumplings, Fresh Tomatoes, Zucchini, Basil, Creamy Vodka & Tomato Sauce
Italian for Carry me up! Mascarpone, Espresso soaked ladyfingers, Shaved Chocolate
All Natural Ground Turkey with Chia Seeds, Quinoa, Kale, Parmesan, Flax Seeds, Pomodoro Fresco, Side of House Flatbread (Maui Cattle Beef Meatballs available)
LOVE, LOVE, LOVE Matteo’s.
Michael is our fav!!!!!
Some of the best Italian food I’ve had ever!! Great service, love the patio. Outstanding wine list!!
Best place on Maui! We went twice in 4 days.
Try the lasagna.
The food was excellent and the service matched. Our glasses were never empty and the attentiveness when our food was ready was on par. Would definitely go back!
Great food, been here many times. Noise level this time was off the charts. We asked to be seated outside but were told it was too late (8:45pm reservation). I understand, no biggie, but I really couldn’t hear my son talking next to me. Maybe turn down the background music so people don’t have to try and talk over it? Thanks!
The food there was amazing! The wine was great! The service was outstanding! It’s a little hard to find, but it’s well worth it. Love the place and would go back!!
Third time to this restaurant. It’s pricey but so worth it! They were very accommodating when our group added one last minute. Food was excellent! I will definitely go back!
Went for a family meal while in Maui- our server was excellent, very attentive. The food was very good and the wine selection was nice. We sat in the outdoor patio area and it was a nice space for a group. Would definitely visit again!
Food was excellent, staff was attentive, accommodating and truly engaging, a most delightful experience overall!
Had a very enjoyable dinner. From the hostess to the table, everyone was very friendly. Our waiter explained and suggested various options and made us feel very welcome.
Noise level was high. The restaurant was full and many large tables which made it feel even louder. This did not disappoint us but if looking for a quiet night, this may be challenging.
Would go back for sure!!
The food was excellent and the patio environment was a nice atmosphere to enjoy good food and good company.
Way too loud. There was a woman next to us with a very loud voice. Awful but not your fault.
Everything was great but wine was a bit overpriced. Paid $105 for a $20 bottle 😕
We’ve always enjoyed the meals, very prompt service, the folks always make you feel welcome.
Food and service was 4 stars. Portion sizes were a little bit than average but perfect for us because we're light eaters. I like that their pasta noodles are made in house, perfect textured. I had the black pasta seafood.
Great service and drag bright food
Great meal and excellent service. Already recommended to friends also visiting Maui.
Good food but a little noisy
Delicious squid ink pasta and my husband said it was the best lasagna he had ever eaten.
An excellent addition to the Maui dining scene. Especially the friendly, efficient service by everyone. Well done! From a big Happy Birthday to hugs to getting my food delivered fast, they all did great. And a fantastic wine list; varied, lots of top-rated Italian, many interesting & well-chosen wines. I went twice in 3 days so you know I loved it.
We often eat at Matteo's and take our off-island visitors there. The food is delicious and the staff attentive and friendly. We recommend eating outside on the terrace, as the inside tables are very noisy. It's our favorite Maui restaurant.
Family dinner with 8 persons, including two 7 year olds. Food was excellent, but because the room was busy, service was variable. Regardless, we enjoyed the meal, and would go back another time. Four of us had the signature lasagna, and enjoyed it. My only negative comment is that the wine by the glass prices are silly. For example, a 6ounce glass of Zenato Ripassa was priced higher than the retail price for a 750 ml bottle. That is foolish thinking by management.
Loved this restaurant! Great food great service. Had the squid ink seafood pasta and it was wonderful. Clams were very fresh tasting.
On vacation in Wailea and were craving our Wednesday night pasta night. Matteo’s hit the mark. I had the Gnocchi and substituted brocollini for zucchini. It was fantastic. My husband had lasagna. It was served steaming hot in a crock which was different but delicious. Waitstaff was very attentive too.
Great service by our waitress Rachel and food was excellent.
Great food, highly recommend the pizzas. Good service very friendly. Just a little loud when the place got busy.
Delicious pasta dishes and attentive service. Great value for your money. A pleasant evening all around!
Service a little slow. Wait for dessert was longer than we liked. Food great and would we return...yes!
Family in town wanted to take us to dinner and we saw the great write up and picked MATTEO’S. We have know MATTEO for years back to the old site! Always delicious and excellent drinks and dinner.
Lasagna was very greasy and noodles were mushy. Lamb Parpadelle was lacking flavor. Our entrees took a very long time to come out. Restaurant was extremely loud, overwhelmingly so. The price was not worth it at all.
Delicious & the service was incredible!
We have been to Matteo's Osteria a number of times, and it never disappoints. The food was excellent, and the service amazing!
Front of house was a mess - they had trouble managing reservations - we ending up waiting 20 minutes despite being right on time for our reservation
Matteo’s is a lovely, smaller restaurant in Wailea. Featuring Italian specialties, wines and pastas, which are homemade.
I chose the tomato, burratta salad which was delicious!
My enter was lobster ravioli, which was just so so.
I thought the ravioli were tough, not at all what I had expected.
For the appetizer we chose the rice ball stuffed with ground lamb. Which was one of their specials . It was delicious!
My husband’s lasagne he said was fantastic as was my son in laws seared tuna looked delicious as well as the paperadelle. Overall , our dinner was lovely, our server was excellent as well!
One of our favorite spots.
Outstanding. Wonderful food, great wine selection, and fantastic service (Justin was a great bartender and waiter this evening). Highly recommended to everyone.
Matteo’s is our go to spot
Great food and great value
The only downside there is no sunset vet
They cover this up however by providing a nice atmosphere with outdoor plants etc
Took a date there first time for her and she loved it
Despite some negative reviews, we decided to give Matteo's a try. Unfortunately it was overall disappointment from the ambience (noise) to (most of) the food to the service and the price. My wife and I were seated inside which is incredibly loud making it almost impossible to have a casual conversation. Our server asked if we would like him to review the menu. I said yes thinking I would hear about the specials but he told us what we could already read on the menu as though we either couldn't read or had never eaten in an Italian restaurant before. We ordered cocktails (negronis) which were good. We had the meatball appetizer which was unremarkable and bland. My wife asked for gluten free bread but they charged us $5 without telling us it would be an extra expense. For dinner we had the house salad, lasagna, and squash ravioli. The salad was fine but not exceptional given the price. The lasagna was bland, overcooked, and the meat was dry. The squash ravioli was very good. Our wine was the highlight at $20 a glass and worth the cost -- however our server was no help in the selection. We ordered flourless cake and kula strawberries in balsamic vinegar with green tea gelato -- it was lovely. My wife ordered the flourless chocolate cake -- which she thought was good but too much. Overall, just ok, but overpriced for just okay. I would definitely recommend dining outside -- the noise level seemed much less.
MATTEO'S OSTERIA offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (808) 891-8466.
MATTEO'S OSTERIA is rated 4.5 stars by 2265 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.