Mama's Fish House
Mama's Stuffed Fish with Lobster and Crab
Baked in a Macadamia nut crust
Crab Luau Soup
Macadamia Nut Crab Cakes
with fire and ice relish
They didn’t tell us it’s closed. We get e-mail the day before reservations that the dinner is confirmed.
We get a Taxi from Lahaina to Paia and then we see it’s close.
Macadamia nut crusted fish stuffed with crab might be the best thing I’ve ever eaten. Cocktails were perfect. Beautiful place and the view of the ocean/beach is a perfect touch. Great ambiance. Server was amazing. He was very knowledgeable, friendly, helpful, and energetic. Complimentary bread was ok, but i could’ve had a gallon of the complimentary Clam-and-mushroom bisque. Black pearl oyster dessert was beautiful and elegant, but I definitely think we probably could’ve gotten a better tasting dessert based on the other options we saw. No problem if we get to back though!
Incredible food and beautiful view!
4th time at Mama’s Fish House and it, of course, never disappoints!!
It was our first time at Mama's Fish house and the food was amazing and so was the ambience.
The food and atmosphere are amazing. I had a vegetarian option that was not on the menu, it came with a banana curry sauce, which was absolutely to die for. I highly recommend going here at least once. However, the price is a very steep. Drinks are $20+ and food is $50+. I would expect to pay a premium for the quality of the food, but unfortunately the price is so high I do not see myself coming here more than one time per vacation.
We had a wonderful experience at Mamas the day before they had to shut down. We almost put it off a day and I am so glad we did not. They’re Mai Tai was the best I’ve ever had. We ordered every appetizer on the menu and they were all outstanding! Our server was so wonderful as well as all the staff.
A legend for dining in Maui. This place is always a treat - everything is done right. From the valet to the end of the meal - it all flows seemlessly and seemingly w/o effort! Yes it's expensive - very - but worth every penny.
We've been to Mama's many times in the past and have never been disappointed. Everything was exceptional, except that somehow we got missed with soup and bread appetizers, however the server apologized sincerely and sent us home with a goodie bag with bread, butter and soup. The meals were excellent
Food was delicious and presented well. Our waiter was wonderful as well. We were seated along the coastal view area which added to the wonderful experience. We will be back!
Wonderful day to lunch at Mama's and celebrate our granddaughter's upcoming 12th birthday while she is here on spring break from Colorado. Attentive, thoughtful service by Will along with wonderfully flavored mahi mahi and yummy creme brûlée. She felt very special and we enjoyed the moments at Mama's with her.
This is by far the best place to eat on the island! The food is prepared beautifully and the servers are right there to help you with anything! The atmosphere is romantic and if you don’t want that it still is incredible!
Awesome food and service. We always enjoy our vidd sad it.
I sent my daughter and son-in-law to Mama's Fish House for their anniversary. My daughter texted to say it was the best meal they had ever had and that the waitress was really great to them. I gave the restaurant my credit card ahead of time and they did everything right, including having an anniversary card from me all typed up and ready to give them. Really impressive as I did all of the arranging from California! Thank you, Mama's for making their anniversary REALLY special!
Outstanding atmosphere! Great food and history at this place. They should bring back the old menu with more fish and preparation options.
The food was amazing!
Mama’s House is a Must Do when in Maui.
Probably the best restaurant on Maui and possibly one if the best in the USA. Setting, food, service and ambiance are excellent. This is a very unique place. Just go. Make reservations.....
Amazing food and service!! Be sure to save room for the Black Pearl.
had to wait 20 min. with reservation with plenty of open tables
Worth every penny! Coconut ice cream and coconut cake were more amazing than words could describe.
The staff as always was exceptional and made my birthday special.
As always - MFH was outstanding from the moment we arrived to the time we left. The ambiance is without compare - service & food more than that! Will always make MFH a must whenever on Maui!
I have heard great things about Mama’s Fish House so thought I’d give it a try. It far exceeded my expectations on every level. Food was outstanding, drinks were quenching, service was attentive and friendly and the ambiance was what you would expect for a Hawai’i atmosphere.
Horrible service from bar and hostess stand. Food and server were great though!
Not a better place to have Dinner in the world. Food is the best bar none.
Amazing restaurant. From the beach and views to the wonderful service
Hubby and I got a beautiful scenic spot by the window in this open air waterfront restaurant. The service was amazing and the food was pretty good. Will return again.
It was excellent in all aspects!
Everything I expected and more! Food, service, and view all top notch.
Mama’s was great as usual. The setting is gorgeous and the food excellent.
Excellent selection of fresh fish. Beautiful restaurant, attentive staff.
Absolutely our number one favorite restaurant. Best Hawaiian setting, atmosphere ,on Maui..Everything is excellent.
Dave Baker the day manager is perfect....
great food and atmosphere. second time eating there and was great both times.
ALWAYS a great experience! This time was no exception. Gluten Free options great as well! My compliments to all.
Always a must destination for us when we visit Maui and never ever disappoints. Service is great. Food is spectacular. But the ambiance is like now other. It’s like a movie set it’s so amazing
Our server Mike was awesome, the food delicious and the ambiance spectacular. Would definitely recommend Mama’s!
Wonderful experience! The food is truly the best on Maui. We visited for our honeymoon and they staff made us feel so special and cared for!
I'd highly recommend Mama's fish House to any visitors to Maui. The service was unreal and the staff made sure every aspect of our dining experience was perfect.
Wonderdul location! Great food! Fabulous service! Felt a bit gouged by the prices. $20.00 for a glass of fairly inexpensive wine
Mama's Fish House is rated 4.9 stars by 30649 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.