Restaurants near Bonefish Bay Motel

We arrived and were ushered right to our seats outdoors. The waitress was genial and the seating was comfortable. We all really enjoyed the food. It was a great way to enjoy a warm night in the Keys.

It was great!

The service was great. We ordered the Cuban sandwich as the main dish and the shrimp gazpacho for the appetizer. Both were awesome.

Best food in the Marathon area during our recent vacation. We visited all the top rated restaurants and Castaways had the best food and service. Food recipe were well thought out and prepared. Don’t forget the Key Lime Pie.

We absolutely loved our meal at Angler very relaxed. We especially loved our server Basil!

We are local and frequent this restaurant often. Food and service are always excellent.

We are officially Big Pine Rooster fans. When we first saw how extensive the menu was, I was a little concerned about great it would be with everything on the menu. Boy were we wrong, from the Lobster Mac, Cuban Sandwich, Thai Chili Shrimp and even a steak, everything was fantastic! We spend a...See More

Wonderful..we stayed 3 days in Islamorada, we ate 3 times at Pierre and lunch 3 times at cafe Morada..don’t hesitate there isn’t another place to go..the ambiance, the view, the food, so romantic, the decor wonderful..

Some of the best sushi we have ever had. We sat inside. They also have outdoor seating with beautiful view.

Amazing views, excellent service and great food!