We made reservations for a special night out.

The bar closed 15 minutes after we arrived due to “Covid” (mind you, this isn’t March of 2020). We couldn’t order beverages with our meal besides water. Our meals arrived room temperature cold. We brought our concerns to the manager, noting that from a customers perspective we simply would have made reservations elsewhere (or, earlier) if they were planning on shutting down early. Was basically told that it was our fault for eating late.

The food seemed to be high quality, and server was good - but I can’t say it was worth anywhere near the $150 or so we paid. Certainly didn’t feel like a valued customer through the experience.

Cannot recommend.

Food was great, but service was lacking a bit at 4:30. We were sent a coupon for making reservations that offered $15 off of a steak. They tried to tell us they don’t accept coupons on a Saturday…nothing posted and nothing in the fine print on the coupon sent directly from J. Gilbert’s website. Feels a bit like false advertising to get people in the door.

In the end, they honored the coupon “this time”. They either need to stop giving out those coupons or add to the fine print that they won’t honor them on specific days. I’d still recommend the food, but be weary of the promotions.

The was over priced. It was good but you could go to Texas Roadhouse and get a better steak for much less. My biggest problem was the lighting it was so dark in that place the table behind us was using the light on there phone to read the menu. And the floor of the whole place was slick. Over all wouldn’t recommend unless you’re trying to show off for a date or something.

Great service and food. The waitress went out of her way to help us. Excellent job!

Everything was awesome.Our waiter was great .He made us feel so welcome.It was our anniversary and it was so special.We will go ther again. I recommend it for a great evening.

The food and service was outstanding. It was quiet so we could have a nice conversation. The entire experience was the best.

Always have had a great experience here for many years! An upscale dining adventure! Excellent food and service! 5 stars!

Wonderful meal. Be sure to join their a-list for a complimentary $25 birthday coupon for an entree and chocolate velvet cake with raspberry ice crean.

We have dined there for years. Food is always excellent or they make it right right now!

My wife and I got out for a date night, finally. J. Gilbert's was perfect for a much needed night out. Maylee (sp?) was a fantastic server. She was very knowledgeable about the menu and had a great sense of humor. Perfect for our personality types. The food was top notch. The corn was unreal and the steak was fantastic. I am a sucker for good lighting and J. Gilbert's had a perfect lighting scheme. I could see what I was eating but it was still romantically dim.

The 4 oz filet + shrimp 3-course special was amazing.

Stopped in for Sunday Happy Hour and food and cocktails were fantastic! Susan took great care of us.

Michael, our sever, was amazing! Highly recommend!

The staff works hard to make sure your experience is a great one. Also was impressed they remembered it was my wife's birthday month with out me saying a thing. There was a card at the table when we were seated recognizing her day and a note for a free desert to go! Too Easy!!

Loud music is the only negative. Felt like we were trying to talk over the sound system most of our dinner.

streaks are usually perfectly cooked. However last night my steak and my wife’s steak were not cooked correctly.
waitress was nice and friendly but forgot things were asked for and had to ask multiple times for steak sauce an straws

Waitress was top notch. The price to portion was pretty steep though.

Great service.

Food wasn’t as g

Great food, service, very romantic.

Have a regular at J Gilberts it’s always good I’ve never had a bad meal there

Service was impeccable, steak cooked perfectly, cozy, low key dinner. Great for any occasion.

We enjoyed a wonderful dinner last night. We love the food and atmosphere!

Service was great, but the price point is high for the utterly lackluster quality of the food.

Surf and Turf...excellent value. Steak was superb, prepared perfectly. Scallops were yummy. Wife had the salmon and loved it.

Took my parent's there for their anniversary. Said that's what it was for on the reservation. When we were seated they got a happy anniversary card with a choice of a free dessert or champagne. That was nice. Food was great. Love that smoked butter that comes with the bread. We've been before & will come back again.

Wonderful evening dinner on patio

excellent steakhouse. service very attentive and professional.

Only one thing made our experience not perfect…table next to use was very loud and the girls were shrieking. Other than that food and service were excellent.

We were seated right away. Our waitress was friendly and attentive. The food was perfect. The lighting, music and climate were spot on.

Best steaks in Kansas City area hands down!

Our favorite place for a date night or special occasion. Food is consistently great. Highly recommend if you're in an area with J. Gilbert's.

Noisy but good food. Steaks quite good. Mashed potatoes cold. Pricey on some items but reasonable on others. Great bread.

As soon as we walked in the door we were politely greeted and everyone we encountered was helpful and professional. Pre dinner cocktails at the bar were masterful. Kudos to the bartender! Dinner was delicious. The filets are some of the best around. Our servers Andrew and Carly were delightful. They were friendly and attentive without being overbearing. They were superb. We always enjoy visiting here. Thank you!!

It was great to be back to in door dining at one of our favorite places to dine.
Seemed a little confused at reception desk. But still a great visit

The waitress was inundated, but handled it exceedingly well. We had a reservation
for 5, but arrived at 4:30 because we were bored at home. By 6:15 the place
looked to be full, despite the holiday. My chicken penne was just right, husband’s
pork chop just a tad overdone. He still enjoyed it.

J. Gilbert’s is our go-to for a nice evening out! Love it every time!

The quality of the food was excellent, as always. It is one of few restaurants that has not decreased during the pandemic.
The same can be said for the service. There were plenty of servers who delivered the high quality of service you would expect. Again, during the pandemic that has suffered at many restaurants.

Sunday half price is one night and filet scallops combo are our favorite, absolutely delicious! Beat steaks in Kansas as City!

Returned steak to get cooked a bit more and took awhile to get it back and it literally looked like a hockey puck and stated horrible. For a filet not acceptable and still paid full price. I used to come here a lot and it had been getting worse each time.