We've been to the restaurant on several occasions over the years. This time around was for fathers day dinner. Service was great! Somehow this time around the steaks didn't seem quite as good as our past experiences. Three of us had the Delmonico steak and it was dry. The other two in our party had the prime rib. My spouse and I looked at each other and asked how is your steak? Both of us agreed that it was dry and it had no seasoning on it. Everyone in our party seemed like they were sprinkling salt and pepper on their steaks to add flavor to it. We're not sure what was different this time around but, it was surely a disappointment.
Wonderful service and amazing food. I got the prime rib and my wife got the ribeye. Both were fantastic! Last time for desert we got the bananas foster, this time we got the cheesecake. I would highly recommend all of it! Brussels sprouts were the side we chose, and also fantastic. I would highly recommend! Sadly it is starting to be taken over by tourists, nothing wrong with that it just gets a little noisy I think.
Had the tomahawk wagu 38 oz ribeye which had no flavor and overpriced at $110! Won’t be back there again! Excellent service but steaks weren’t tasty, Ruth Chris had better tasting steaks!
My daughter ordered the chicken, needed to be cooked another 4~5 min.
I have been in the grocery business for 44 years and sell prime and choice beef. My preference is prime and that is why I eat at Hy’s. I would question if the Delmonico I ate on Saturday was choice. The prime I cook at home can be cut with a butter knife. The steak I had Saturday was cut with effort using your steak knife. Plenty of fat and grizzle to boot. I have dined at Hy’s a number of times and love the service, but was disappointed with my experience Saturday. Because I was with friends I didn’t want to make a huge issue, but needed to let you know about the quality of my meal.
It was AMAZING!
It was a great experience
We celebrated birthday and the server was nice and smiles all the time
We had a free dessert after the meal and they took a photo fur us and put it into a beautiful frame
And the food was wonderful
Especially the onion soup
We definitely will came back again!
Great dinner..food was excellent as was the service. He's is well worth the trip
Hidden away from the main street but once inside you feel like you are somewhere unique.
Everything was wonderful!
We enjoyed our booth table, the service and if course the food as always.
Hy’s is like stepping back in time to when dining out was a 5 star experience. This gem is nestled off the beaten path of the tourist clogged ocean front of Waikiki, and you would have no idea it was even there. This makes the entrance into the portal back in time even more dramatic and magical. The decor is old Hollywood meets castle and immediately you get the sense that you’re in for an experience. The staff is impeccably trained and they make you feel like royalty. They are incredibly attentive and the food is delicious. The French onion soup was the best I’ve had since being in France. They aim to please and when we commented that the truffle sauce didn’t taste at all like truffle, though it was tasty, they promptly went to the kitchen and whipped up a new and very truffle filled batch that was perfect. The prices are high but it’s a great place for a fancy dinner or special occasion.
As usual . Nothing but the best steak house in Hawaii !!
Really nice restaurant. The decor is amazing. Old bookshelves with old books. Just a really great place with top notch service.
Have been going for more than I can remember. Always excellent service.
Quality tasting food and relaxing surrounding.
Service is always top notch, witch is friendly and informational.
Always a pleasure and enjoyment to celebrate special occasions.
Our waiter wasn’t really interested and we had to constantly remind him our our dietary requirements
Medium rare steak was overcooked
Very good time for my family
Foods and services are excellent
But a little noise but not annoyed
service , food and ambiance were so good. we plan to come agan.
I am beyond amazed by there service there! It was my boyfriend and I first time there and I was ecstatic by every minute being there. I would say the only con there is the wait time for our food. To think back at what restaurant we were at, a steak house does inquire on timing because of how amazing the taste of everything was prepared for our main course. I had the Beef Wellington with steamed veggies, mashed potatoes and everything I had including the gravy was delicious. Our waiter explained very well on the specials they had, we were served with water every time and when we say "thank you" there response for all times is "absolutely" and I think that is very clever and polite. I will be very excited for our next visit here at Hy's Hawaii :)
We've been coming to Hy's for years and it NEVER disappoints! Hubby ordered the tomahawk steak, while my m-in-law and I both had the filet mignon. Brett and Stuart were our two wonderful servers. As always, Audy supplied the soothing background dinner music. Then for dessert, we all had the DELICIOUS bananas foster. Can't get much better than that!
Great food. Wonderful staff! Everything was great and truly enjoyed our dining experience.
Very good steaks, service is always excellent. Nice place for that date night dinner
What a great Steakhouse. The service was fantastic and food amazing!
As always, we had a wonderful meal at Hy's!! Can't wait for our next one.
I think this is the best restaurant in Waikiki. The food and service is always perfect and the setting amazing!
Overall a great dining experience. We got there about 15-20 minutes before our reservation time. Seated us in the lounge and we had a drink or two while waiting. Which is nice. Beats just hanging around out front.
Our Server and staff in general were great. Making sure everything was fine and not being intrusive.
Food was great. “Nuff said” LOL.
Can’t go wrong at Hy’s. Always enjoy when we do dine here for special occasions.
Awesome meal. Over the top steaks
Just fair service. Two waiters , one excellent and the other a young person who seemed petrified of the facility. Very tired menu, nothing new or fresh. Wine list ridiculous. Not a single bottle of Champaign less than one hundred dollars.....really? Better food and values elsewhere .
Hy's is one of a kind. The ambiance is great. The service is exceptional. I order everything table side.
It was our 33 Anniversary and wanted to go somewhere special while in Wakaki. Someone suggested Hy's Steak House, and it was not disappointing. I love Filet Mignon, and it was wonderful. Everything was first class.
My husband & I went there for dinner for our anniversary. We found the service to be excellent & very attentive . We'll definitely be going back.
This is one of the best steakhouses through my life. It was for a wonderful night for my wedding anniversary.
Went their with my wife recently. First issue was with table location - in a secluded nook with another table near the kitchen entrance. Was told alternate table was not available even though many were.
Oysters rockefeller was very tasty as an appetizer although it seemed as though the oysters were cooked at different times as some were hotter than others. Wife's shrimp appetizer was good.
Wife had beef wellington which came rare instead of medium and was skimpy on the duxerlles. I had steak oscar which was cooked to order but could have tolerated some additional crab.
Service was very good in general although they seemed to want to rush us to order after we received our drinks.
As a comparison, we actually enjoyed the meal more at Wolfgang's.
My husband and I went to Hy’s to celebrate our wedding anniversary. Dining at Hy’s made it so special. We started with the fabulous shrimp cocktail, followed by lobster bisque- yummy! My husband had the filet with bacon wrapped scallops- outstanding! I had the prime rib with Alaskan king crab legs - already split and filled with meaty sweet crab. Hy’s then surprised us with delicious cheesecake for dessert as an anniversary gift. Of course, the truffles at the very end complete a wonderful evening at Hy’s! Well worth our trip from Virginia to eat at Hy’s for our anniversary!!