Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York City

Best Historic Restaurants in Sheepshead Bay

Price
Cuisine
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Award-winning
Accessibility

29 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Gargiulo's Coney Island restaurant
1. Gargiulo's Coney Island
4.8
Exceptional(845)
Price: Expensive
• Italian • Coney Island
Booked 13 times today
For a taste of Italy in the heart of Brooklyn, look no further than Gargiulo’s. We are an authentic Italian restaurant serving delicious, traditional Neapolitan fare made from family recipes that have stood the test of time. Our food is unbeatable, made with fresh, high-quality ingredients and cooked in-house with care. Gargiulo’s has been family owned and operated since 1907, making us a Brooklyn staple and a Coney Island favorite for over a century. We have a huge dining area, perfect for enjoying a lunch with coworkers or a romantic dinner for two. In addition to lunch and dinner, we also offer private dining rooms that can host anywhere from 20 to 400 people. We also provide catering, so your next corporate meeting, party, wedding reception or event just got a lot tastier!
A photo of Fraunces Tavern restaurant
2. Fraunces Tavern
4.7
Exceptional(3244)
Price: Expensive
• Contemporary American • Financial District
Booked 57 times today
Fraunces Tavern Restaurant, est. 1762, is a historic landmark in FiDi. Offering small batch craft & specialty beers, handcrafted cocktails, & 1000+ spirits, experience the delectable flavors of thoughtfully prepared American cuisine, featuring our farm-to-table ingredients. The establishment boasts 7 distinct spaces, each providing exceptional options for both public & private experiences alike. Invite friends to sit around the warm fire in the Dingle Whiskey Bar or gather & mingle in The Wine Room. Host a formal event under the crystal chandeliers in the Washington Room for a private dining experience. Whether you prefer the Independence or Hideout Bar, both offer a fun and informal atmosphere to enjoy happy hour with friends. Experience the secluded charm of The Piano Bar Upstairs, to enjoy exquisite food, drinks, and live music in a relaxed atmosphere. If you're a history buff, visit the Bissell room to view the beautiful mural painting depicting downtown NYC in the 1700s.
A photo of Gage & Tollner restaurant
3. Gage & Tollner
4.7
Exceptional(61)
Price: Very Expensive
• American • Downtown Brooklyn
Booked 37 times today
For more than a century, Gage & Tollner was the cornerstone of the Brooklyn restaurant world. Generations of Brooklynites found comfort and community in Gage & Tollner’s magnificent landmarked dining room; generations from now, we want our children and grandchildren to find comfort here, too.With three longtime friends and celebrated local restaurateurs at the helm -- partners Sohui Kim (chef, Insa / The Good Fork), Ben Schneider (Insa / The Good Fork), and St. John Frizell (Fort Defiance) -- our community-driven team has worked to restore Gage & Tollner to its former glory and guide it into the 21st century. Consistently on The New York Times Best Restaurants List since reopening (2021-2024), our delicious chophouse menu takes inspiration from the Gage & Tollner archives, honoring and elevating beloved longtime classics with meticulously-sourced ingredients and diligent technique.
A photo of Heroes restaurant
4. Heroes
new
4.9
Exceptional(15)
Price: Expensive
• French • SoHo
Booked 2 times today
Heroes Restaurant is a culinary gem in a historic townhouse on West Broadway, perfect for discerning palates and adventurous spirits.Inspired by everyday heroes, it offers a distinctive dining experience with shared plates, inventive cocktails, and a vibrant atmosphere. Step inside to find a modern sanctuary with sleek lines, warm lighting, and curated art. The open kitchen invites you to watch chefs craft dishes with skill and care.Heroes' menu features fresh, seasonal ingredients and bold flavors. Start with smoked salmon with dill crème fraîche or crispy calamari with spicy aioli. For mains, enjoy steak, grilled seafood, or pasta. Signature smoked dishes are slow-cooked with hickory and cherry wood. Finish with cocktails from expert mixologists, including classics and house creations.CANCELLATION POLICY:Cancellations within 48 hours incur a $25 per person fee. For emergencies, email reservations@heroesrestaurantnyc.com. WE DO NOT HAVE A PHONE.
A photo of Industry Kitchen restaurant
5. Industry Kitchen
4.4
Awesome(2080)
Price: Moderate
• American • South Street Seaport
Booked 63 times today
Nestled along the East River next to the historic South Street Seaport, Industry Kitchen is just steps from the water’s edge. The menu, curated by Executive Chef Jonathan Haffmans, features modern American cuisine based on seasonal market ingredients and simply prepared dishes that New Yorkers know and love, such as abundant salads and wood-oven grilled meats, seafood, and pizza. Complimenting all menu choices is a wide variety of craft beers, signature cocktails, and an extensive wine list. The stunning 5,000 square-foot venue accommodates up to 300 guests with indoor and outdoor seating, allowing for unobstructed views of the Brooklyn and Williamsburg Bridges and Brooklyn Skyline.
A photo of Clover Hill restaurant
6. Clover Hill
new
4.9
Exceptional(3)
Price: Very Expensive
• Contemporary American • Brooklyn Heights
Booked 3 times today
Tucked away on a charming, cobblestone street in the heart of the Brooklyn Heights Historic District, Clover Hill is an intimate 20-seat restaurant offering a warm and refined dining experience. With a deep appreciation for tradition and a modern touch, we aim to blend the elegance of classic fine dining with the creativity and warmth of contemporary cuisine. At Clover Hill, we believe food is at its best when it comes from memory. Our intent is to deliver an experience that feels like home: inviting, comforting, and deeply personal. Whether it’s a special occasion or a quiet evening out, Clover Hill offers a culinary experience where nostalgia meets innovation in every bite.Due to the nature of our cooking at this time we are unable to provide a menu that is vegetarian, allium-free, or entirely free from trace amounts of gluten, dairy, soy, shellfish, finned fish, animal product or mushroom.
A photo of Essex restaurant
7. Essex
4.5
Awesome(3224)
Price: Expensive
• Fusion / Eclectic • Lower East Side
Booked 31 times today
Lower East Side pioneer famous for award winning contemporary cuisine, oyster happy hours & NYC's original bottomless brunch party. A vibrant multi-level space in the historic Shapiro's Winery, Essex offers intimate seating as well as group dining and event spaces. Essex's New American Dinner Menu, guided by Chef Steffen Sander, who has helmed some of New York's top Michelin-Starred restaurants, showcases seasonal and locally-sourced ingredients, with extensive vegetarian, vegan and gluten-free options, as well as burgers & classic steakhouse fare. Our Prime Cuts Menu features shareable Dry Aged and Prime Angus Steaks.
A photo of Temple Court restaurant
8. Temple Court
4.7
Exceptional(1405)
Price: Very Expensive
• American • Financial District
Booked 4 times today
Steps away from The Beekman's centerpiece atrium and the bustle of The Bar Room, is Tom Colicchio's Temple Court. Surrounded by a series of stained-glass windows, and full of historic charm, Temple Court's Dining Room is a destination for the fine dining devout. Now under the stewardship of Executive Chef, Travis Sowards, Temple Court is a tour de force of Tom Colicchio's most classic flavor profiles, reimagined and assembled on a showcase menu in Downtown NYC. *The Bar Room is not reservable through Open Table*
A photo of Jules restaurant
9. Jules
4.9
Exceptional(18)
Price: Expensive
• Pizzeria • Brooklyn Heights
Booked 6 times today
Located in Brooklyn Heights, Jules places modern embellishments on late 20th century style pizza. The menu features a continually evolving selection of old New York style pies, a few shareable plates, locally sourced salads and sneaky good desserts. Vintage fixtures illuminate a lively, demure dining room that feels modern yet appropriate in the historic neighborhood. The full bar features classically inspired cocktails & wines by the glass from burgeoning producers. Jules was opened by Chef-Owner Julian DiChiara, Hallie Lahm and designed and constructed by partner Colin McTigue.
A photo of Dudley's restaurant
10. Dudley's
4.7
Exceptional(64)
Price: Moderate
• Café • Lower East Side
Booked 42 times today
From the team who brought us Ruby’s & Elephante, Dudley’s is a neighborhood staple that delivers good vibes and great food in equal measure. The American-meets-Australian all-day cafe serves a lust-worthy brunch, alongside sandwiches, and pasta, all within a lively environment that’s a destination to see-and-be-seen.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you

Explore OpenTable

Discover
OpenTable
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Press
More
Our sites
Businesses
  • Restaurant Management Solutions
  • Restaurant Reservation Software
  • Restaurant Marketing Software
  • Restaurant Event Software
  • OpenTable For Restaurants
  • OpenTable For Restaurant Groups
  • Restaurant Resources
  • OpenTable Pricing & Plans
Join us on
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2025 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 500, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo